Lets also add “why are security coprocessors running at higher authority level than the cpu itself, embedded in any modern processor or motherboard chipset (intel ME and amd PSP) in the last 15-20 years a problem” To the list.
Modern pcs are like a prison cell with the door left open at this point. All the infra is there, it only takes the guard to come in and lock the door.
Btw, arm has their own version of the secure coprocessor, although to my understanding it is a special secure execution mode still running on the same CPU. Arm trustzone
I assume you mean the cp charges, if they create genai unclothed images of their classmates (ie minors).
Then again the whole minor sexting thing and exchanging pictures (real ones) with their peers (so still minors or very close age brackets) would also fall under the same cp laws.
Fair enough but I think a subsequent legislation to mandate which apps must be 18+ would be a pretty simple route to dealing with the former example.
In the case of texting the technical route to blocking that activity is less clear.
Blocking the camera app for minors seems excessive, blocking texting would basically negate the point of having a mobile phone (I think text > talk these days).
It would appear that these laws are in conflict with federal (US) law as in the COPPA act.
IE just providing a birthdate is not parental consent, which COPPA provides rules to do so. These state laws actually do nothing to enhance the existing federal law, and possibly weaken the federal statutes.
If state laws are in conflict with federal laws, they will fail a simple constitutional challenge on federal supremacy.
I don’t know that these laws are, but if the laws require a birth date rather than an age bucket (ie: under 18, 18-21, 21+), we may well see a constitutional challenge here.
I’m torn on this though. I like the idea of a parental control system being capable of emitting an age bucket signal, which can outright block certain websites from children. (there’s a debate to be had that if they’re inappropriate for children, are they appropriate for adults?)
However, I’m concerned with the government mandating it. Government always prescribes the worst implementations and has the stupidest policy, because we really aren’t sending our best people to make laws.
Until someone brings the challenge to court, these laws will stand. Going to court is a rich persons folly, as it is very expensive to do so.
The US justice system is for the rich,we plebs stand (almost) no chance in court even over minor infractions.
And the chance of the courts righting this ship are very slim. They have a horrible track record when it comes to the Fourth Amendment. The SCOTUS ruled that cops have no duty to protect people, they can see you being stabbed and do nothing about it but watch. But they also ruled that cops can enter your home without a warrant and without a suspicion of a crime if they believe they need to for your “safety.” Same court that ruled law enforcement seizures of your person without suspicion of a crime violate the Fourth Amendment, then ruled DHS checkpoints are an exception. The list goes on and on and on. It’s very easy for them to rule a law is a “reasonable” search or seizure, especially when they wrap up the justification with “child safety.”
As Judge Kozinski said, the Fourth Amendment relies on what people find reasonable or not generally. Which is why he had a habit of involving himself in conversations in public when somebody started talking on their phone, to emphasize the point about reasonable expectation of privacy. People just give it away, and that fact is used against them when judges determine what is reasonable or not. Just one look at this thread or the Linux Reddit and a judge could easily author an opinion finding that this is reasonable because of the lack of unified outrage about it. Now, I question the validity of some of the accounts in the conversation with well known state and corporate practices in such things, but even hinting that reality will get a comment deleted around these parts so I won’t expand on that.
At any rate, the courts are highly unlikely to come to the rescue here.
So we must ban scissors with a pointy end? Come on man. Yes there is degenerate stuff and it should be dealt with on a case by case basis. But you cannot blanket treat adults as children.
This is what will happen. Kids aint stupid, and will figure out how to evade bans and will learn to not care about or evade the laws. This is why parental monitoring is needed.That cant happen if the parents have to work all the time to make ends meet.
Edit:
Why post this here? Because the os level verification will fail as well, the child will install a VM and do what they please from there, lie about their age , and in general evade the age limit thing.
I know this from raising my kids, and i had to shut the internet down after a certain time,and they didnt get cell phones till 16 (a positive is i could find them wherever they were via the cell) and i told them what i was going to do and i did it. No hidden agenda, just me talking to my children and making it clear what was acceptable and what was not (even if it was someone else’s behavior).
It’s my understanding that successive generations have been struggling to develop computer skills, so in general I think this is rather unlikely. Have to remember that the average person’s head would explode if you try to explain virtualization, regardless of whether child or adult.
Honestly, I am expecting someone to make an easy to follow script, that will enable script kiddies to evade the immoral laws, which will probably snowball down to harm the rest of us that simply wish to not comply with the egregious laws
I have always been thinking how Age Verification will ultimately the business side of things… will you have to migrate to an enterprise version of Linux or will we have to add a person accountable to have an age for these servers… or what? Someone never thought this through the beginning, as always