And is not xmas any more… ive swapped icons so many times ill need a need QAI hate for 2027 but AI may do that for me
Why u saucing a xmas hat on april fools
Old man ![]()
I’m probably too late to the party, but even ignoring the ridiculousness of the whole debacle, I find it infuriating, that nobody proposed simply using user groups as a “signal”. Distros willing to comply would simply add the user to an “under18” or an “under13” or w/e group, with lack of any group meaning “no restrictions”. Every process ran by the user can inspect the active supplementary groups and get a clear “age bracket signal”.
I still don’t like the premise, but I’d rather it reused an existing mechanism than introduce a new one.
Hot take though, most people here would not be using linux at all if they had to hand write init scripts like the old days.
@daemond , I am using Artix Linux (Arch-like without SystemD) with OpenRC init for many years, and the only time I had to write a custom init script - is for my friend to automatize a workaround for his dual AMD GPU problem on 6.19 kernels ( AMDGPU fix for 6.19+ kernels running on dual-GPU AMD laptops! Package, upstream? ) . Also, 99% of Arch wiki works for Artix perfectly. Therefore, most people could be using Artix without ever realizing what’s under the hood, other than feeling that their system is slightly snappier. Actually, its even slightly more user friendly than Arch, considering that it has ISOs with preinstalled DEs
“why are security coprocessors running at higher authority level than the cpu itself, embedded in any modern processor or motherboard chipset (intel ME and amd PSP) in the last 15-20 years a problem”
@starshipeleven , if you’d like to evade this ME/PSP crap with as minimal of sacrifice as possible, take a look on coreboot-supported AMD PCs: since PSP got introduced much later than ME (shortly before Ryzen , vs a Core 2 Duo era) - the performance is still good enough, and thanks to the opensource coreboot BIOS there are no UEFI holes and stuff like Computrace spyware. Some examples of said PCs: AMD Lenovo G505S with A10-5750M quadcore CPU and 16GB RAM, A88XM-E desktop with A10-6800K, and of course a powerful ASUS KGPE-D16 server with two 16-core AMD Opteron 6386SE and up to 256GB - 512GB RAM. All mentioned PCs support IOMMU / virtualization and could be used with Qubes OS for those who would like (although sadly there’s no no-SystemD Qubes OS equivalent yet)
P.S. yes, G505S and A88XM-E got dropped from the official coreboot repository not so long ago, but I am maintaining a “restore_agesa.sh” script that helps to deliver almost the latest coreboot master branch’s source code to them - Lenovo G505S hacking - DP
Yeah, but even today the vast majority of Linux on the desktop users are not interested in consulting a wiki to get a working system.
I feel like I am having to do it quite regularly to run binaries with non-standard flags. Particularly for things which are only configured by flags rather than files.
Looks like Age Verification is coming in at a federal level now:
https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/8250
Software is free speech, and free software is a movement. I wish government good luck.
Lennart is a corporate suck-up Disney adult. Let’s hope the next financial crisis wakes him up to the reality, that corporate doesn’t care about his side projects. And that he shouldn’t grant them their wishes, and sell out his users, for nothing in return.
Effectively he’s doing free work for the Zucc, and he’s too blinded to see.
I hope a lot of open-source maintainers come to that realization, hopefully it will bring back some sanity. No dipshit cosplay dress up anymore, playtime is over kids.
I pray every day this propped up economy on fugazi money collapses, and brings us back to the 1700s on a global scale. Hopefully this “AI” bubble will do it. Then you’ll really see who cared about open-source and free software, and who was just pretending for ill-intended corporate interests or temporary monetary gain. Fuckers.
If that means a marketshare decline, and Red Hat plus The Linux Foundation closing shop; that’s a good compromise. We, the people, don’t need 'em.
And these age verification mechanisms may eventually also rely on remote attestation mechanisms:
This is EU, but don’t be surprised when this cancer spreads, and only certain “authorized” hardware will be allowed on the internet.
and only certain “authorized” hardware will be allowed on the internet.
And how do they propose on acomplishing that? MAC address whitelisting? We’ll just spoof it, done.
Captive portals enforcements on the ISP level? We’ll setup our own ISPs, hijack from a lower layer.
TCP optional extensions? Again, spoof or crack crypto implementation. Done.
Politicians have no idea what streisand effect that would cause.
Well in the US , federal law already requires parental permission for minors to use certain sites; usually p**n or social media sites. so if the child is under 13, the site must still acquire parental permission for the child to use that site. So if this is so good why not just raise that age limit to 18? or 21? or 85 for that matter. So the os verification is moot for under 13 users. I am still opposed to OS level age verification because it is already covered under federal law.
Rant on age limits on alcohol/tobacco use deleted.
Edit:
Its because farcebook/Xtitter/youtube all piled money into politicians via brib… err lobbying, as opposed to using that money to improve their platforms to comply with existing law. IE being lazy..
Perhaps you should look into Play Integrity hardware based attestation, and the amount of hoop jumping required to get around it. It’s not nearly as simple as spoofing a mac address or things like that, its much more involved. It’s cryptographic keys buried in hardware that the user does not have access to.
Imagine buying a lock but only google has the key. (Therefor, you do not own the lock…) Not to mention bootloaders that you can’t unlock… You do not own your own computer.
Currently the meta in the cat and mouse game is finding valid leaked keyboxes (that haven’t yet been revoked/blacklisted), and soon RKP (Remote Key Provisioning) will be making this even more tricky. Warning, this is a bit of a rabbit hole.
https://xdaforums.com/t/tricky-store-bootloader-keybox-spoofing.4683446/
https://xdaforums.com/t/module-play-integrity-fix.4607985/
And reread the EU article (and linked source code), where the age verification is reliant on this Integrity mechanism, meaning bypassing it will become increasingly painful.
In short, it is already causing a large hassle on alternative roms. Banking apps not working if you cant hit `MEETS_STRONG_INTEGRITY`
Perhaps Stallman was Right^tm: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/can-you-trust.en.html
In 2015 Richard Stallman suggested to replace the term “Trusted computing” with the term “Treacherous computing” due to the danger that the computer can be made to systematically disobey its owner if the cryptographical keys are kept secret from them.
“Remote attestation” is a plan to force your computer to tell the truth to a company when its web server asks the computer whether you have liberated it.
Call me a tinfoil. Call it slippery slope fallacy. But I fear this awful mobile trend will creep into the desktop space…
That is rather ambitious. Good luck!
What do we think might happen with shared corporate computers, like Point of sales machines in shops, where they sell liquor, or medicines?
And machines in hospitals?
And in household televisions, with no users set up, but wanting access to potentially 18+ action movies / TV shows and such?
They run operating systems..
Things like desk phones and such can default to “not adult” and have locked down corporate apps, I guess..
Hmm, and what about appliances that don’t have users, but still require web access, like (yuk) AI bots and such
Don’t they still run windows 95
Wait that nuclear submarines
Glad to see some consistency in the world, Reddit steadily doing Reddit stuff
@0xDE57 is mostly correct here, except you don’t really need play integrity here. Using device attestation with strongbox-backed keys is already a very robust proof to know if the backend is talking to a legitimate application and on an untampered device.
And it’s not really for nefarious reasons. I work in a field of identity verification and I could go on a whole rant about what’s being done properly and whatnot, but being able to verify that we’re taking with our app, deployed on a genuine device, is actually good for users’ privacy, because we don’t have to collect and process more data than necessary, if that can be reliably done on the end-user device.
I will be taking a look into the new EU app shortly. The whole EUDI wallet thing is a mixed bag - some things are done pretty well, some not so much, and a lot of people are scaremongering which isn’t helpful. Privacy could be improved (e.g. with ZKPs) but AFAIK it’s not as bad as it sounds with OpenID4VP and SD-JWT. (The issuer can still link presentations IIRC in the current model, but it’s much better than what’s being proposed in other jurisdictions)
Yes, given all we know and all the trends, it’s really no big deal. Big power, big tech, big politics, they all really have our best interests in mind.