Yeah, the date of birth field is in itself not bad.
What’s bad is that this is one of the steps toward boiling the frog. If one government demands date of birth to install an operating system, it’s only a matter of time before others start demanding a photo of our driver’s licenses and a webcam feed for verification.
Because he’s a consistent pearl clutcher about the (IMO) silliest things. The format of most, if not all, of his videos seeks to stoke outrage. The internet is chock full of that already, and I’m genuinely tired of it. So, anything he gets concerned about is usually something that he’s blowing massively out of proportion and the messenger must be taken into account with the message.
I mean just the fact that he’s calling this age verification is a lie. It’s whatever the systemd-homed user puts in with exactly zero verification, if they even fill the field out.
I say this is a nothing-burger because of the above reasons. Especially in the face of all the current Orwellian surveillance the average person is subjected to on a daily basis from corporations that governments happily slurp up. If governments & corps collude to actually verify ages for all devices then I’m right there with you.
Because this “boiling the frog” (a synonym for slippery slope, by the way) argument keeps coming up, I want to reiterate:
Google et. al. are currently polluted with results discussing the current hysteria. But according to my memory, 18+ disclaimers started being implemented online by at least 2011. This means we have seen almost 2 decades of rudimentary age verification online which did not “slip” into the more invasive, authoritarian forms of surveillance being gestured at in this thread.
Now, one could argue that the legislation being discussed in this thread is part of a longer teleological arc that leads to mass surveillance… however…
Nobody in this thread or the last has bothered to formulate an argument that shows us that an event A (age disclaimer, OS level age signal, etc.) is a reasonable precondition of the event B (mass surveillance, no more computer without scanning your gubbermentz issued ID). In other words, we have yet to establish a reasonable argument that OS age signals lead to a fully blown age verification system with attendant network infrastructure, data storage, API, documentation.
Who is developing the user-facing components of this surveillance system?
Are libraries in development to allow programmers to interact with this mass surveillance system?
Apple and MSFT might be mum about it, but are we to believe the entire Linux ecosystem is also preparing and keeping this under their hats?
Anyone with a rudimentary knowledge of programming, even vibe coders, would understand that a system of this scale would not just appear overnight.
It’s actually wanting to do verification, and though they claim it will be done in a PII preserving way, I have zero faith it would happen like that in practice. On top of that, they want to mandate that devs change their apps/services to request a signal.
Okay, you have to know that is exactly what the end goal is here. Just shocking to me that anybody would think otherwise. I also note that you didn’t want to provide your birthdate even though you don’t think providing that info to strangers isn’t a big deal and therefore Lunduke is pearl clutching. Odd.
Me providing my birthday to a stranger is a strawman as that’s not even remotely what’s happening here, nor would it happen in any current or proposed laws.
20+ year experience C++ developer here. When developing a feature of any complexity, I always plan out the foundation first.
It’s a data point. What’s the harm in an advertising ID? Why are TPMs a problem? It’s about fingerprinting your device and placing the capability to track your age, even if it’s a nonsense option that can easily be worked around (by lying), it’s one step in the wrong direction. It’s a foot in the door to requiring more information.
It should be obvious to those implementing steep fines (California, Colorado, etc) for allowing someone to use a computer without verifying their age that such an easily worked-around implementation is not enforceable.
Incidents will happen where age verification would have theoretically stopped it, and it will be expanded to something more concrete and effective.
I hesitate to post in this thread, because as a Gentoo user it is not my battle. I strongly encourage anyone, who possesses both the means and the patience, to switch to a source-based Linux distribution that will respect your choice.
We have already seen in the case of snap/snapd and Wayland that Canonical and Redhat believe that they, not the user, should be the arbiter of what software resides on a machine. This parallels the “slippery slope” of increasingly mandatory updates to software and hardware (like Edge, Microsoft account signin, TPM) that transpired between Windows 95 and Windows 11. There has been a consistent and unrelenting march in this direction over the past three decades, and that this behavior has now come to free software should surprise nobody.
To me it is a matter of self respect and dignity. The computer belongs to me. It is my property, and I will not tolerate so much as a suggestion otherwise. You wouldn’t tolerate a stranger walking into your home and questioning you, or leaving things laying around your property, so why would you allow the same to be done to your computer?
That is what, for me, has been so liberating about Gentoo: that, with exceptions and within reason, the source code for my system will reside on my local storage and be built to exactly my specification. Not a single package or dependency will exist without my express permission. Nobody knows better than me, the owner, how my system ought to operate and be composed.
How a reasoning person could look at the abuses of the PATRIOT act, FISA, and the contents of the Epstein files and come to the conclusion that “I would really like my government to have more control over my life, and more information about my children,” is frankly beyond me.
But there remains a persistent group who are convinced they have “nothing to hide.” Strangely, members of this same group never seem to provide their home address or banking information when pressed to, so I guess we all have some things to hide?
It surprises me that someone as metered in tone and as reasoned as yourself could provide such a nearsighted take on the topic.
The concern being expressed does not begin or end with this discrete event, that “systemd is adding age verification,” but follows the entire historical thread of the social contract as it exists in our societies. It is an analysis of what we as citizens stand to lose or gain.
For example: First there were taxes, and that was great! Because now the government can build roads and public improvements, and provide for the needy. Then there was compulsory public education, and that was great! Because now everyone can read and write, and not be beholden to demagogues interpreting information for them. Then there was mandatory vaccination, and that was great! Because never again will a child be afflicted with polio.
In each of these cases, citizens gave up some autonomy in exchange for what they perceived to be a greater good.
But now the scales have tipped in the opposite direction. What do we collectively stand to gain from age verification online? That irresponsible parents are even freer of responsibility, and may continue neglecting their children? That governments will be able to more fully take on the role of parenting, and that children can safely be abandoned to their digital devices?
If that reads like a strawman, it is because what we stand to lose is far greater. The first that comes to mind, is our ability to dissent and converse semi-anonymously in spaces like this.
Nobody at this intersection or the last has bothered to formulate an argument that shows us that an event A (I don’t see any cars right now) is a reasonable precondition of the event B (I’ve been run over by a car).
See how absurd that sounds?
The crux of the issue is that we as citizens stand to lose quite a lot if simple “age verification” progresses to “identity verification.” Whether or not it progresses to that point is immaterial, because the risk is present. In the same way as you look both ways before crossing the street; just because there aren’t any cars in your line of sight right now, does not mean they do not exist, and pose a threat.
Mass surveillance, loss of anonymity, and thereby the loss of the right to dissent is the foundation of every dystopian fiction, and every dystopian regime. Because it is exactly this “check” or “balance” by the masses of reasoning, self-interested citizens that prevents a minority of overbearing tyrants from crushing us.
Those predictions about the heat death of the universe are backed by calculations plugging in proposed values for currently unknown variables. But the equations themselves are agreed upon or theoretical based on the scientific paradigm of the day. This is akin to what I am asking for when I say reasoned argument.
It’s not near sighted so much as I am unwilling to accept a slippery slope argument without an explicit description of the inner workings that gets us from A → B. It intentionally obscures what exactly the speaker is speaking about. That arrow between A and B (age verification and mass surveillance) is doing a lot of heavy lifting in the absence of any facts, reputable sources to confirm, etc.
Is it plausible that age verification may lead to mass surveillance? Yes.
But that’s not a good argument either, for: is it plausible that the internet may lead to mass surveillance? Yes.
Arguably more so since the forms of mass surveillance we imagine almost invariably require computer networking of this type to transmit data back to the gubbermentz.
So therefore following the same logic we should probably not have networked computers at all. Is that the future we are advocating for?
This is a cop-out argument to me. For one, blaming parents does not solve societal problems involving children and technology. Whether people want to write it off as a moral panic is their perogative. However I feel that building tools as “force multipliers” for parents in this day and age wrt technology is not a bad idea. Examples are not lacking (I gave an article with several in the last thread) particularly with respect to generative AI. Current tools however do not adequately address a number of apps including e2ee messaging, local inference, etc which are clearly problems.
Besides, we already effectively accept identity verification in most countries for all manner of goods and services which societies rightly deny to children. Whether the topic of discussion represents legislation catching up with technology OR democracy backsliding into authoritarianism is a point of opinion, not fact.
Not to beat a dead horse, but I don’t see the connection between an age signal that says one of [under 12, under 14, under 18, over 18] and the inability to converse anonymously.
I will happily tell Wendell my age since this is his place.
Perhaps it stems from my own misconception but I think if the government wanted to identify dissidents online the last thing they will be relying on is an age signal emitted by the operating system. More likely they can just read the server logs and get subscriber info from your ISP. Whether this requires a visit to a judge depends on where you live, I suppose.
Totes off-topic of me but I would say that this is generally not true. Popular movements like the Arab Spring converted online engagement to action in the streets. Unfortunately many activists in the West (don’t worry I live here too) are stuck in the online phase. In some ways looking at what is going on with Silicon Valley & the White House, one might get the impression that the online peanut gallery is the State-sanctioned form of grievance since it has been so totally ineffective for us in the West.
None of this is being done in a vacuum. The DNI herself said she thinks everyone on the internet should be tied to their ID.
I’m interested in your theory. Why do you believe that multiple states have pushed through legislation to fine an OS provider if they do not build in age verification?
I think lawmakers are taking note of some disturbing trends with respect to children’s use of technology and are attempting to set up a legislative off-ramp that:
Absolves corporations of (some) liability
Prevents access for (some) children
Centralizes (as much as possible) implementation by doing it at the OS level
Assists parents in navigating constantly changing technology
May divert some youths from the legal/penal system
Taking again the example of these school kids using generative AI to create deep fake nudes, the creators of the images are now exposed to some of the most serious criminal charges a person can face outside of murder. If even one such case could be prevented by the implementation of a shitty law, it is probably sufficient for legislators to vote into the books.
Whether or not the costs outweigh the benefits is an exercise left to the reader.