X870E pricing is so bad, I might as well buy a sTR5 motherboard and just splurge on a Threadripper 7960X

My friend bought ASUS ROG STRIX X870E-E Gaming WIFI yesterday.
The board looks nice and has that premium feel to it but… that shit costs as much as my ASUS TUF X670E + Ryzen 7800X3D combined!

Few weeks ago I was thinking about board and CPU upgrade when 9000 X3D comes out, but not anymore. I will either go for 9000 X3D CPU only or I will try new Core 200 from Intel, depends on the performance/power consumption.

Price of 7800X3D skyrocketed in the last few weeks, so I can sell it used for the same price as I bought it new.

I want to upgrade my network to 10GbE as well, but since I only have 4070 Super, I can live with 8x8 gen4 PCI-E on my “plebs” mobo and throw my money on the NAS/homelab system instead.

In my opinion the prices of at least the Asrock X870E boards are pretty reasonable.
Or at least not any worse when X670E firstly launched.
In fact Arock´s flagship X870E boards are actually cheaper (at least up here)
than the flagship X670E boards when those were launched.

The Asrock pro art X870E creator with 10G nic is around €519,- ish up here.
And that price isn´t actually that far of the the X670E variant of that board.
But you could argue if that is really worth it over the previous one.

The pricing is a but if a jump but I can’t say I’m not tempted. They’re definitely stuffed with options and for my main system I only need GPU and two M2 drives. I’d like on board 10gig as I’ve just updated my network to have a 10gig core that my NAS and VM hosts all live on but 5gig is probably plenty given that I use my main machine for mostly games and the odd movie rip etc. The USB post selection is good and a step up from my x570 too so unless there’s a good B range board coming, I can see myself springing for this should we get a 9xxxX3D chip soon.

1 Like

Good point. I mentioned book, rather than break or direct, pricing. I’d guess like US$ 0.50-1.00/unit direct, depending on factory to factory shipping costs, so it’d be interesting to know how the Ali sellers are getting to 14 cents/unit.

Hmm, yeah, I can get the ProArt X670E for US$ 460 and the X870 for 480. For Taichi it’s 380 and 450 but IIRC the X670E Taichi’s launch price was like 480.

Some of this thread’s disconnect’s probably manufacturers pricing X870(E)s as if they were a new socket release rather than revisions of established boards.

2 Likes

I like x870e proart more than other x870e boards. The USB4 controller is connected to the chipset instead of cpu. Thus you get two PCIE Gen 5 m.2 slots directly from CPU. It is even better than x870e Hero in this regard. Also the 3rd pci slot support x4, which is better than x670e proart that only supports x2 pcie line for the 3rd slot.

1 Like

Sadly that does not seem to be the case…

*** PCIEX16(G5)_2 shares bandwidth with M.2_2 slot. When M.2_2 is enabled, PCIEX16(G5)_1 will run x8, and PCIEX16(G5)_2 will run at x4.

From

The only board where the second m2 doesn’t share bandwidth I saw is the msi godlike. It almost seems like it’s a requirement of AMD to use cpu lanes for usb4…

You are right. I misread the specs page. X870E Proart uses cpu lines for usb4 controller, while x670E proart uses the chipsets lines. Yes, x670e proart got usb4, too.

Yeah, it really doesn’t make sense. USB 4 uses pcie 3.0 lanes, wasting pcie 5.0 lanes on that doesn’t make sense. It’s really too bad. Especially on x870E there are plenty of chipset lanes to use.

Yeah, all of ASRock’s X870(E)s use the CPU 4.0 x4 for an ASM4242. I suspect 800 series boards with chipset USB 4 may be uncommon as probably that would mean a complicated setup for display over USB. Also ASRock’s dropped DisplayPort from their IO blocks, though there’s still HDMI.

Personally I’d rather have a second CPU NVMe but in B650 it’s often 3.0 x4 and under the dGPU with X670E, so it’s been mostly a miss anyway. Hoping there’ll be some good B850 alternatives but can’t say I’m particularly optimistic.

USB 4 tunnels Thunderbolt 3, which is 3.0 x4, yes, but a 3.0 x4 uplink from a USB host is 31.5 Gb and thus can’t support full rate USB 4 gen 3x2’s 40 Gb. The ASM4242 is dual 3x2, so ASMedia putting it on 4.0 x4 makes sense, though running both ports the same direction will still throttle on the uplink.

At 10k pieces, you are down to 60ct/piece.

You’re making the same mistake of not going to the Chinese sources directly :wink:
(my offers were already 14.4c and 13.6c per piece already)

Still, I couldn’t find anything below 14-15 cents per piece, so I guess my bad xD

Oh wait, I found one that lists them down to 6c/piece:

There’s also this guy that lists 1c/piece at 50k+, but can’t tell if the $10 shipping per piece is an error or a scam xD

1 Like

I did an upgrade from my AM4 system to AM5 last month.

Rolled with a B650 motherboard.

Specifically the Steel Legend WIFI, not even a 650E.

I still have 3 functional m.2 @ PCIE4.0x4 speeds.
And I plugged my 10gig NIC in one of the PCI slots.

Looking at the X870’s, theres nothing going on there that I feel I’m missing out on. I was hoping they would make 10 gig NIC more common… but nope.

1 Like

Can’t see any benefit to update from X670E.
Might change my CPU only, when 9950X3D comes out.

I am going second hand EPYC for my next upgrade. The PCIe lanes are just too few.

The B650 Steel’s more functional for this than the B650E too, since M2_3’s a CPU rather than chipset NVMe. So losing the E nets ~14 + ~7.2 + ~6.2 GB/s instead of 14 + 6.2.

PCIE2’s 3.0 x4 either way, so I’m not sure what would motivate buying the B650E over the B650. The gen 2 front C’s probably minor and DDR5-8000+ would be the X870 Steel.

That is kind of steep. Last time I bought a $0.01 part the shipping was $3.99. And it was a bigger part. :grinning:

Would love to but threadripper’s cost is prohibiting, it’s even more ridiculous than x870. I’d love more pci-e lanes on a consumer platform, x3d and 32 lanes would make a killer machine.

1 Like

X670E has 24 gen 5 lines from the cpu. 12 gen 4 lines and 8 gen 3 lines from the chipset. Total 44 lines.
If the board can bifurcated the primary pcie into 2 pcie x8 slots instead of 2 more m.2. The situation is not that bad.

1 Like

I’m looking at it from the perspective of having 2 graphics cards. I don’t mind not using nvme storage at all, but I’d like to be able to have 2 graphics cards running at full bandwidth.

1 Like

Agree, with most here, as one can see in my tread, where I try to locate a reasonably priced AM5 motherboard for a media server. It need a few slots for 20/50 server NICs which are typical 8x 2.0/3.0/4.0, SATA and few free slots, so I can add U.2 controller later or what SSD wins the future for the low-end media storage.
Good AMD CPUs are plenty, but all the motherboards need to up-sell to the highest gaming outfitted board they can get away with. It’s a server, so OC and power stages at 4 times the biggest CPUs need is just wasted stuff and money.
Treadripper is not viable for this use, due to costs and overperformance for my need.
On the Intel side I can go with W680 and when Arrow Lake launches, a W880, which is still expensive at 450€-500€, and there are good options from Supermicro, Asus and Asroc. The money goes to functions not gaming geil, or RGBs and I those functions has value for me now, or in futureproofing the investment with connectivity like dum PCIe slots. Can someone make a version where the M.2 lanes can be shifted to actual PCIe slots?
However the longevity of socket 1851 is questionable, so it would be written off, unlike the AM5. AL may be more energy efficient than the RL, but that is also it, and then the nightmare with the E-cores, making AMDs CPUs much more attractive. So as good as Intel is on the motherboard side, as bad as they are on CPU and the longevity of the platform. I understand whyt they add more PCIE lanes to the CPU, but its also a trick to get us to splurge on the next platform, and the next. If they promised 2-3 gens and I could start with a P-core only CPU, I’d be fine with the investment.
As with AMD, if they had a W680 like motherboard, instead of expensive gaming stuff, I likewise spend 500€ on that, and likely a bit extra on the CPU, as the platform is longer lived.
Ideally, a home server for an apartment resides in a cupboard and is cheap, silent and efficient (power prices) in turning power into its services.
I know I should just get a prebuild NAS and STFU, but I hate prebuild NASs, because they are inflexible, noisy, use more power than an individually configured system, and are inflexible.
So I would very much like a W680 motherboard for my AM5 Epyc CPU, for home server.
Plueaaaszze!
/rantoff

https://www.supermicro.com/en/products/motherboard/x13sae-f

First, it’s lanes not lines. Second, the interesting number is the amount of USABLE lanes. 44 is a useless number unless you want a board without sound, USB, SATA,NICs, etc.
They’re fixed and you can’t reroute the USB-lanes to anything else whether you need them or not.
And you inevitably need a connection from your USB-lanes to the CPU, so you need lanes chipset ↔ CPU which you can’t and shouldn’t use for anything else if you decide on a board with PCH/chipset.

Saying the boards have 44 lanes is like saying my 16 core CPU with 4GHz is a 64GHz CPU. It’s not totally wrong, but it’s stupid to count that way.

There is not a single board on the market past, present or announced future with that layout. I wish there was.
The only thing is splitting your x16 into two x8 (often an adjacent slot with PCH/chipset lanes or dumb/passive one) via a hardware switch, highly praised here in the forums. But that feature was very rare on AM4 and AM5 with PCIe 5.0 only has some selected unicorns with it.

x16 slot + scraps → ~20-28 usable lanes is the state of mainboard for a decade now.
10 years of stagnation IS bad. Serverland moved from 32 lanes to 192 lanes during this period.
I call this “milking the consumer market for margin”

4 Likes