X870E pricing is so bad, I might as well buy a sTR5 motherboard and just splurge on a Threadripper 7960X

It’ll catch up …eventually—when USB4v2 (Thunderbolt 5) is introduced and the dual-port configurations have to have a PCIe 5.0 × 4 uplink by necessity.

My main problem with the X870E is that I’m not sure if ASM4242 vs Intel JHL8540 an upgrade or downgrade

1 Like

ASM4242 uses PCIE Gen 4 x4 uplink. Intel JHL8540 uses PCIE Gen 3 x4 uplink. ASM4242 got more bandwidth on paper.
They all provide 2 usb4 ports. Some reports indicate that if 2 usb4 ports are connected, ASM4242 will downgrade bandwidth to usb 20gb even in idle. JHL8540 could dynamically allocate bandwidth between the ports based on needs.
Evil hides in details.

PS: I just realized ASM4242 is a USB4 controller that supports Thunderbolt 3, while JHL8540 is a Thunderbolt 4 controller that fallbacks to USB 3 20Gb with non Thunderbolt devices. Here is the difference between USB4 vs Thunderbolt 4. Thunderbolt 4 vs. USB4: What's the Difference?

That is indeed an interesting question which in need to dive into as well.

I understand the difference between Thunderbolt 4 vs USB4 which is why I’m not convinced it’s better. TB4 is everything USB4 and (slightly) more.

But the TB4 (seemingly) not working until after a reboot with it plugged in (i.e. no plug and play) is also annoying.

I forgot to specify but I’m talking about X670E boards with the intel chipset (e.g. ProArt X670E) vs X870E.

the X870E Godlike will be $2400 AUD or 1,479 EUR or $1,605 USD if international prices are all the same, which i feel they won’t be. Prices for x670E have already begun dropping slightly, so bios update and then :smiley_cat:

When you add a 5080, a 9800X3D or 9950X3D with the x870E-G, then you have already spent approximately one billion dollars, so TR, or even TRPro in the lowest 24 core sku with matching Motherboard and sensible non over the top ammount of ECC, you are almost around that same billion dollars…which, you’re right…its very, very weird!

ofc there are other options, the taichi for example, and there are even more motherboards coming out now like that one which has no USB type A at all, just type C, so maybe wait a few months until like March or something and maybe there might be some better options, or even motherboards with CAMM2 memory options for semi-future proofing :innocent:

ofc if you play the game of wait a little longer, you’ll always end up waiting a little longer :face_with_hand_over_mouth:

1 Like

Well yeah in my opinion it does not make much sense to spend more then $450 / €450,
on a main stream platform motherboard.
In my opinion super over expensive boards like the Msi X870E Godlike are a waste of silicon.
And not worth bothering about.
There are actually a couple of very nice boards in the $300 to $400 range that pretty much have everything that most people would need.

maybe not, but that €450 motherboard once it gets to australia is around $800 AUD to around $1100AUD depending on where you buy ($550-$750 USD) so the budgetness is kind of gone a bit.

i sort of agree and disagree with this at the same time :stuck_out_tongue:

1 Like

Was looking at Threadripper for next upgrade but the price jump from AM5 16 cores is too much just for quad(octa now on DDR5) channel and PCIE lines.
Dont need 24 cores, even 16 is bit overkill most of the time but for Gentoo user its nice.
But would like to see 16 more lanes from CPU in future so full 2 x16 are possible.
Not that there would be space for then when 7 slot 1200+ W GPUs hit the market.

For now ProArt X870 will be sufficient.
Was looking at the difference between ProArt X670 and X870 and found the X870 more useful.
Seems like the ASM4242 is Thunderbolt 4 certified and has enough uplink bandwidth to drive all PCIe lanes for both ports. Something that the JHL8540 cant do with its x4 Gen3 uplink.
There will be 2 x4 ports left usable after connecting 2 m.2 drives to CPU.
With Proton advancements I dont have need for second GPU for VM so no problem with the second slot dropping to x4.

Wonder if there is a USB 4 addon card with ports than can be routed to front panel.
Having them only at the back is not very user friendly for some.

2 Likes

I agree pricing is really bad. Especially, when trying to build a PC that’s both good at Gaming and intense workloads. For me, intense computational work loads and simulations. One can do it but, it’s like being punished for doing so, while buying 6 year old computer parts.

I looked at the current offerings for the X870(E) generation of motherboards, and I’m going to have to pass as well. Threadripper is the way to go—great for the folks who love to micromanage their setup by having as blank of a slate as possible. Just give me all the PCIe lanes and I’ll figure out what to do with them…

The mandatory requirement for a Gen 4 × 4 USB4 chip combined with the Gen 4 × 4 chipset forces the use of double the number of CPU lanes than if the chipset were Gen 5 × 4 and they dangled the USB4 chip downstream of the chipset like most motherboards from the X670(E) generation did. This inefficient piecemeal approach kind of rubs me the wrong way, and possibly can’t be fixed until a totally redesigned chipset or new socket are introduced.

The zen 5 threadrippers are rumored to have a 16 core sku. Could be interesting for a „budget“ build

Yeah, it is puzzling. If they want to prioritise USB4 like this they should put the controller on the io die. I think that’s how laptops do it (and perhaps intel desktop?). Perhaps they couldn’t figure out how to do it in time for the AM5 launch and that’s why it didn’t happen?

I feel generally desktop platforms are in a pinch. Most of the money is in mobile & servers. Desktop is dominated by gaming. HEDT has gotten super expensive since it’s derived from server platforms that are overkill for HEDT.

1 Like

CPU sockets are far enough from the rear panel USB4’s 20 Gb needs a PHY near the connector to support reasonable cable lengths. Basically the same physical constraints as PCIe 4.0 (16 Gb).

Also, Zen 4 launched September 2022 and ASM4242 availability seems to have started in January 2024. It’d take a 32 lane socket or 5.0 x2s instead of 4.0 x4s, which I’m not surprised AMD noped out on.

I’m not sure pinch is quite the word I’d pick, but yeah. If your compute can match the shape of gaming or large OEM corporate productivity sales then it’ll do fine, otherwise not so much.

Zen 5 being EPYCy has been really good for us. 2-3x perf gains over Zen 3 on a number of core workloads and sometimes the dual decode SMT kicks out a +20% that wasn’t there on Zen 3 or 4.

Same boat - really want a new Threadripper to replace my current 3970X but will wait until Zen5 range launches and for some price drops too.

In the “interim” - went with X670E ProArt for linux compatibility - especially the wifi chip. I believe (hope) mine also has USB4 if my BIOS settings are to be believed. Will buy a USB4 SSD enclosure to use with a PCIe NVMe Gen 4x4 m.2 which should approach the 4 GBps speed limit.

1 Like

the (rumored) upcoming TR (and TR pro) lineup (rumors) looks to be very, very interesting and if the rumors are true, that potentially TR platform could be getting X3D, then the base tr pro 16 core @300W (because reasons :upside_down_face: ) with all those extra lanes and the ability to productivity + gaming, well…that’s awfully tempting

Wait another year and the old AMD HEDT Threadripper platform will be defunct and replaced by the equivalent HEDT product based on Zen 6 with 24 and 32 cores and more PCIE lanes than the current Zen 5 offerings, maybe 50% more than Ryzen Zen 5, but still not as many as the older TR platform. You can also expect X3D on the chiplets too.

1 Like

hehe that’s the problem though, if i did that i’d end up waiting another year every year!

for me, making a decision is hard enough already :laughing:

1 Like

I am looking at exactly the same solutions. The threadripper is a 7 year system if I do go that route. Have to justify it.

This topic was automatically closed 273 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.