Solved: Can ZFS stripes be wider than the total number of disks in a vdev?

THIS IS PRECISELY WHY THE SPREADSHEET IS WRITTEN FOR SECTORS, NOT ASHIFT.

By using sectors, it makes ashift completely irrelevant in the calculations because for the most part, you’re not going to reformat and re-flash the drive itself, so that it will present to the OS, a different physical and/or logical sector size.

99.999999% of the population that uses drives of ANY kind, aren’t going to bother doing that.

Therefore; whereas ashift, as you stated, can be a user defined variable, sector sizes, is not a user defined variable.

That makes the calculation, on the spreadsheet, far more stable.

Like, how do you still not get this?

Bullshit.

There are still PLENTY of drives that uses 512b sectors.

Companies like Backblaze still use PLENTY of drives that are using 512b sectors.

You literally write stuff from your ass, that has no basis in reality, whatsoever, when it’s so easy for me to find data sources that disprove the statements that you pulled from your ass.

Oracle DB isn’t a drive.

It’s an application.

Why do you need the idiot in the room to explain this to you?

No! Patently false.

You cannot assume that 99% of all drives use 4k.

Again, you’re just literally pull this shit outta your ass.

If the drive reports the sector size to the system that’s hosting ZFS, correctly.

Again, the OpenZFS documentation is explicitly clear about why alignment shift is a thing they introduced to begin with.

Read it again.

Why do you have to pull stuff outta your ass when the OpenZFS documentation explictly tells you what it is and why it’s there?

Note your claim here:

And yet, you spent most of your reply, talking about drive sector sizes, and not ashift, which is what I’ve been pointing this out to you, a week ago.

Again, if you were actually interested in increasing your understanding of how ZFS works, you would’ve acknowledged that you were to wrong to equate “sectors” as “ashift”, but even after spending this comment, talking about drive sectors, you still admit that you were wrong for making that incorrect equation.

This is answered in George Wilson’s presentation.

Read the OpenZFS documentation again.

Did not have the time yet.

Was busy dealing with your other BS from the other thread.

The only people who b!tch about a wall of text are those that don’t read.

Again, once you can man up and admit that you were wrong, then I will answer your question.