Not really happy with AM5

I’ve had my Asus 870E proart for two years now. I’m not that happy with the platform. I’ve had RAM instability, had to turn down the RAM speed to get it stable. After months of instability I wasn’t sure if it was the IMC or the RAM, but I took a chance I got new RAM which fixed it.

Still the memory training and other small annoyances makes me wish there was more platform choices. Maybe I’ll try W890 platform, I miss my LGA1366 (I still have it).

There’s no point to this post, other than old man yells at cloud. Anyone else hungry for a “workstation lite” platform, without threadripper prices?

3 Likes

9950x3d2 and 256gb of DDR5 at 6000mhz here. It’s so hobbled by dual channel bandwidth that it’s almost not really worth having. I don’t know why this kit of ram is selling for $5k on ebay because the platforms it works with just don’t have the throughput to do anything with it at useful speed, and I would honestly feel bad for selling it to anyone at that price at this point because it just doesn’t do what 256gb of ECC ram does in a quad channel threadripper build, not even close.

So we already have consumer desktop cpus that blow well past needing more than dual channel ram already, but the thing is, the product segmentation is just never going to allow for anything more than that, as far as I can see. Dual channel is all any regular consumer needs for gaming or office work, and anyone who needs more IO and more memory bandwidth is running a workstation and thus will pay workstation prices.

2 Likes

yes

but so far my AM5 update has been working OK for me - I use a supermicro motherboard though and my RAM clocks are at 5600Mhz which is the max spec afaik…which may not be the case for consumer stuff but I haven’t looked.

# sudo dmidecode -t memory | grep -iE "speed|clock"
	Speed: 5600 MT/s
	Configured Memory Speed: 5600 MT/s
	Speed: 5600 MT/s
	Configured Memory Speed: 5600 MT/s
1 Like

Also yes. Just something not hard locked to DDR5 ECC & it’s cartel pricing & still on PCIE 5.0 would probably be enough.

Man, props on your build! That’s exactly what I would have if I’d done mine back when prices were reasonable.

That said, how did you get all 4 sticks to run at 6000 MHz? I thought AM5 limited full speeds to the 1st 2 RAM sticks?

This is expected behavior.

There are workstation lite Granite Ridge SKUs. The problem is Granite Ridge isn’t optimized for gaming. In fact, I daresay no non-soldered CPU family since Cascade Lake has had both a gaming friendly architecture and 4+ memory channel support.

Until you get into running local LLMs. Gorgon Halo is quad channel and Spark is 16(!!!) channel. As local LLMs can also be used to make many aspects of gaming - such as NPCs - smarter, I believe that workload will be the one to push consumer machines beyond dual channel.

1 Like

I’ve got a Supermicro AM5 board and have been fairly happy with it. However no overclocking is allowed by the BIOS so perhaps that’s why it has been such smooth sailing for me.

The Spark is the same memory width as the Gorgon Halo, both 256bit.

1 Like

AM5 just wasn’t an upgrade over AM4 it should have been imo. (but then again it’s not about us plebs anymore is it?)

Still rockin’ AM4 - 5 machines of the platform actually. And I will until the wheels fall off.

2 Likes

It’s not an inherent limitation of AM5 or anything. It’s a combination of factors.

All four sticks need to be part of a matching kit. Very little luck if they aren’t. Then, you need a motherboard that can actually support it. Best results are with high end MSI boards. I’m using MSI X870E Carbon Max. I’m not going to pretend to be smart enough to know exactly what it is about the higher end boards that enable this, but I believe it has something to do with having more layers and more isolation in nicer boards whereas in lower end boards the crosstalk is too high because of the lack of isolation so they can’t go that high. Then, once you have a board and the kit for it, you have to get lucky enough to get a CPU with a memory controller that can deal with it. This isn’t as much of a silicon lottery anymore, both my 9800x3d and 9950x3d2 do it fine on this board. But I’ve heard that it’s not reliable across all chips due to differing silicon quality.

All of those things line up, and it’s just like putting in any other kit of RAM, you just plug it in and turn on Expo, except it takes an obscene amount of time in memory training. One of those factors is off, and it just won’t work no matter what you do.

I just don’t see it happening. I get that this is what Nvidia is selling with their tech demos where there’s AI working behind the NPCs, but the reality is that if any game is going to use anything like that and want it to be anywhere near impressive, it’s going to have to rely on a cloud based solution that’s way smarter than what you would be able to fit into the amount of RAM that any normal person who wants to play video games can afford at this point. Those use cases of ultra high bandwidth memory and lots of it, those are strictly workstation use cases now. You’re describing an AI workstation. And I know it sounds cool to imagine an AI workstation running a game, and they can do that - the spark laptops game acceptably, but it’s a multi thousand dollar AI workstation that just happens to game, not a gaming device that has AI capability.

3 Likes

Ah OK, because the 9950X3D2’s specs mention the RAM limitation so I assumed it was the same across the board.

Most boards are eight layers, whether you buy like a US$ 170 B850 or drop 500 on an X870E Carbon Max. While there’s often minor differences in DDR clock specs as board spend increases I’ve been unsuccessful in locating any evidence to show there’s actual engineering differences. So it may just be marketing segmentation.

Similarly, I don’t know of any evidence to show higher mobo spend gets a lower loss dielectric. It might but it wouldn’t surprise me if does that it’s mainly a consumer-workstation segmentation. Also not sure I’d expect X870E type spend to amount to more than a steep upcharge for a slight FR4 upgrade.

There’s a lot of posts around where people assume, without evidence, DDR speculative layout improvements as a function of board cost and chipset branding. While I haven’t worked on DDR5, from my experience with earlier gen DDR it wouldn’t at all surprise me if every 2DPC ATX board in a mobo manufacturer’s lineup typically uses the same layout block for a given socket and DDR gen. AM5’s a little different in that AMD’s marketing aligns with the idea of a new block for 800 series, though again I’ve failed to locate any actual physical evidence this is in fact the case.

1 Like

From what i read around the interwebs with the 800 series motherboards,
Msi seems to be least fiddly when it comes to higher speeds ram kits.
However there is no conclusive evidence for this of course.
But Msi does not support ECC on their consumer boards.
So for the people who need this feature Msi is pretty much a non option.

But there is still the issue where both Asus and Asrock are dealing with a higher than average cpu failures and instability rate on some of their 800 series motherboards.
On which both companies still not gave an official statement of what the root cause of the issue was and what they actually did to prevent this from happening again.
And it´s still happening even on up to date bios versions.

Msi and Gigabyte on the other hand have less reports than the upper two on this issue.
However this might also be due to the amount of motherboards sold worldwide.
But still to me personally this raises some question marks.

2 Likes

I had ram stability issues for years on AM4. I was using an asus B550m-tuf and I couldn’t get my B-die ram stable. I switched to a gigabyte X570s board. And haven’t had a problem since. Sometimes it is the board sometimes it’s the ram. My old b550 works fine with 64Gb of B-die ecc. But it didn’t like my gskill royals even without xmp.

B-die is dualrank. Which means, for best speeds and stability, you should only run 2 RAM sticks of those. 4 sticks makes it quadrank and the memory controller will hate it.
I would be guessing the ECC-ram ran at slower speeds. When B-die is capable of so much faster speeds. With 2 sticks.

3600/3800 Mhz is pretty pedestrian with B-die. Sure, it is a limitation of the AM4 Ryzens too, very few CPUs do over 3800 Mhz RAM. APUs can do over 4 Ghz RAM speed.

Oh yeah for sure, hopefully I made it clear I was only speculating. I have no idea how it works.

But what I can say for sure is that it’s not generic to 800 series boards or anything. I used to work for micro center and so I just went through a lot of hardware, got to test a ton of different boards without having to pay for them and just bought a bunch of stuff on employee discount, and in my own testing it seems like they do have some sort of segmentation going on where only the premium boards from certain vendors will support it. And it could be artificial segmentation like you mention. All I know is I’ve tried all kinds of x870E boards from all kinds of vendors and the only ones that really work with this 256gb 6000 cl34 kit straight out of the box without tweaking are the higher end MSI X870Es and some Asus. My Asrock Nova almost got there, like 4200mhz, same with some gigabyte boards. And all of the lower end ones are stuck at 3600 or something like that.

So yeah I don’t know what it is, but there’s gotta be some kind of secret sauce there, even if it’s just a different BIOS or something.

2 Likes

OP touched on two issues really

  1. unstability of overclocking AM5
  2. the bare-bone features of AM5

I find O/C on AM4 was not anywhere smooth sailing either, especially when people were aiming high. The day of quick profit from O/C was long gone.

Lowering O/C expectation helps.

My old AM4 was and still is rock solid. Zen 2 2700x with 32gb of ram. I put a 10gb nic in it and it’s now my proxmox server. Draws 50w at the socket at idle before VMs are spun up

A lot of what is discussed here has already been mentioned in Democratizing computing: Should AMD & Intel offer more I/O in lower end? in some form.

This bit was topic was such a trigger for me, I’d still like to respond. Traditional HEDT has been dead since Zen2 Threadripper and intel’s inability to compete because they couldn’t advance their lithography as they had planned it. I too was a LGA1366 kid and 1st gen Threadripper was the perfect successor to that for me.

And I have to lament the position we as homelabbers are in. Too small of a market to really matter, but numerous enough to have a niche none the less. I would love to see some kind of intermediate socket with ca. 40 lanes and quad memory channels that wouldn’t cost an arm and a leg. But that ship seems to have sailed since the HEDT days have ended. In today’s market the homelabber has to compromise either on cost or on features. AMD Threadripper and Intel W-series are more workstation than what I would call HEDT and it’s much more business oriented, with a price tag to match.

I wish the days of ca 2008 would return, where there was actual chipset competition (nVidia nForce, VIA, etc.) and the CPU wasn’t tightly bound to the chipset. How awesome would it be if there was an option to have a chipset without (as m)any onboard peripherals? Just configure your computer as you see fit with expansion cards? In hindsight, that was the better option for me. The networking and USB requirements are arbitrary, yet both have their reservations in the IO die. Most of my IO is mostly PCI-e based anyhow. Why not make it more generic and flexible?

1 Like

i have that board too. same ram problems. wish there was a fix that didn’t invole buy more ram.

Didn’t see it discussed in this thread so here’s some key info…. This sentiment is about a year old though.

AMD has already announced that future designs will be based on the Strix architecture. No more “dual channels” meaning per say. It’s best to outline where were and what Strix means:

  • DDR5 == 64 bit. This splits that into 2x32 bit interleaved sub-channels, per DIMM channel. This gives you a 128bit total bus to the CPU; however, made up of 4x32 bit channels.
  • DDR4 == 64 bit, single channel. However, that’s 64bits per channel - not split into interleaving sub-channels. This is why dual channel 3200Mhz DDR4 is tests real world to be ~40 GB/s, compared to DDR5 6000 at around real world 62 GB/s. You’d expect it to be twice as fast, but it’s not.

With AMD Strix, that’s been changed to have a larger 256bit bus width and no more interleaving (iirc). And with that, a board designer can do 4x64 or 8x32, or even 16x16 bit channels, depending on the design and needs (16x16 is useful for ultra-high core counts like routers). LPDDR5X is the new style memory, and goes to LPDDR5X 8533 insanity.

This design yields a real-world bandwidth of 215 GB/s to the CPU. That’s more than 3x DDR5 and 4x DDR4 dual channel setups. Best I can get out of my 8-channel DDR4 3200 ECC is 165 GB/s, but usually 153 GB/s with agents and background tasks running.

So yeah, they have a new design now to get away from the dual/quad channels of the past. And they slap the “Ai” crap on every name. Ryzen AI MAX+ 395, Ryzen AI PRO MAX+ 495, etc.

These newer AI CPUs are also mixed cores. Well actually, all AMD cores are identical Zen5 goodness - they just significantly downclock most cores to save power. My HX 370 is 4 normal + 8c compact cores (still 24 full threads though!) - running at 45W. This is another significant departure from my 9950X3D2 as well - which had all 16 of full blown cores (and it’s power usage to match!).

The thing is, it’s unobtainium for most of us so we are stuck in DDR4 and DDR5 affordability. IMO, that’s fine as agents have shown it still falls on it’s face with concurrency.

Fun fact: the Strix Point Ryzen AI HX 370 CPU is actually 128 bit too. However, I measure memory bandwidth with it’s LPDDR5X at 90-120 GB/s. It’s hyper sensitive to concurrency (e.g. desktop KDE running in the background so plan on an OS with nothing running - no DE).

The DDR5 SO-DIMM versions are still limited to 55-60 GB/s DDR5. But when you find one with LPDDR5X, it should be a good bit faster.

Mine is one of those mini PCs with the HX 370 and 64 GB/s LPDDR5X. If you’re patient, you can find 32 GB versions for $600 on ebay.