HDMI 2.1 KVM w/EDID & Serial Control - Dual Monitor - Four Computer
Problem:
I have two macbook pro late 2021 16 inch models. I dock them both with power cord plugged into both, as well as an HDMI-HDMI cable plugged into both for the secondary monitory, and a USB-C to HDMI cable plugged into the USB-C port of both for the primary monitor. The HDMI-to-HDMI cables are pretty standard and new ones, so I know those are not the issue. In fact, the secondary monitor basically never has issues getting displayed. It’s always the primary monitor that has connection issues. I know the issue is not the monitor itself because it is a brand new one (DELL U2725QE). It must be the cables. The cables are these ones: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0D1SYWK9Q. I purchased these because they were USB-C to HDMI 2.1 and support 4k @ 60hz. My monitor is 4k and supports 120hz. The output to this monitor is unpredictable; sometimes the display flickers pitch black for a few seconds which is only resolved by unplugging from macbook and plugging back in. Other times, the display just refuses to show anything; fixing involves guessing game of unplugging the cable, turning the monitor off and back on, unplugging and plugging the kvm power cable, plugging and unplugging all cables from the macbook (usb-c cable for usb input, usb-c for video, hdmi for secondary monitor, macbook charging cable). The guessing game is highly unpredictable and can take upwards of 5 minutes some times. I also sometimes perform the same game on the other macbook in hopes that somehow fixes things, which sometimes it does. I play this game every other day it seems. I’m so lazy I’ve just been dealing with it for like 5 months. The game is seemingly more prominent when I un-dock either macbook and try re-docking.
Does anyone have replacement cables they recommend that suit my needs? needs to be 4k 60hz and usb-c to hdmi 2.1. apparently macbooks support 120hz through promotion, but i dont see promotion as an option for this monitor when i go to system settings and view the dropdown for refresh rate. i only see 60hz and below. Am I better off with buying hdmi to usb-c adapters?
i dont think i need this for my problem unless there’s something im missing here. the apple adapter seems like a choice. i also saw this DELL adapter but i have no idea if its compatible with apple products… probably not i guess Dell USB-C to HDMI 2.1 Adapter | Dell USA . i have more faith in dell than some chinese bullshit from amzn like CableMatters
i use a hub to handle the type c to video out for some reason video out via type c directly on many devices seems to cause issues not just apple. flickering black screens missing refresh rates and incorrect resolution values
i have not done any looking into why i just needed my video outs to work and using either the apple hdmi multi port adapter or connecting to a hub then video worked for me
sorry im still waking up and not really explaining stuff well i need to get a coffee
it probably works
also make sure any cable you plug into the adapter is rated for the needs you want as well
if you went display port via typec this might be easier but dunno if that is a option
another issue while digging is that manufacturers make different assumptions for display out based on what they think the dispaly will be some adapters act correctly on tvs vs computer displays
if you went display port via typec this might be easier but dunno if that is a option
as in return the hdmi kvm for the display-port variant?
also make sure any cable you plug into the adapter is rated for the needs you want as well
i think the dell adapter should suit my needs since it claims 144hz for 4k but only one way to find out… gonna go ahead and order and if that solution fails me i will circle back and try out the dock method. i wasn’t sure the macbook supported more than one monitor via a single usb-c dock.
eh for me that is a no brainer dp has imo the better specs and does all the same things with a few other features …but are nearly the same for most people sooooo really up to you
like extremely comparable but by dp 2 it was a no brainer imo and was dp 1.4 untill hdmi 2 came but now dp 2 and hdmi has not compared with its revisions
like its really feature sets and opinions so really up to you
I think one concern I had with the available DP 1.4 KVMs is none of them have EDID (please correct me if I’m wrong). I wouldn’t want to switch between sources and lose display resolution and/or monitor arrangements/orientations when going back and forth.
the other concern is im not sure if usb-type a to usb-c cables exist or actually work if they do. in my case they would have to carry the signal from my webcam for both mic and camera to my macbook. this works with my current kvm with usb type-c. i presume the k and m would still work. both my k and m are wireless with usb dongles (logitech)
This is true. Hardware EDID is limited to DP 1.2 as well. However,
The best solution to edid is in software. In windows 11 there’s a toggle in the settings, in windows 10 there’s a github repository. There’s probably something for macs too.
I ended up purchasing the DELL adapters for both macbooks and have been using them since late May (begrudgingly). Unfortunately they are plagued with more or less the same sorts of issues as the amazon cables i was using. They don’t flicker like the amazon cables, but instead they just simply refuse to send video output to my primary display when switching between both macbooks via kvm hot key. my secondary display always shows up fine when switching between. i have to unplug and replug the end of the adapter from the targeted macbook every time i switch to the target mac via the hot key. its a major pain in the ass. the adapters are connected to the main display’s hdmi cables. does anyone have any alternatives? If not, I really would like to return the KVM because it does not work the way it should. Not to mention it cost me like a 1000 bucks.
my rule of thumb is to never, ever, ever bother trying to convert between HDMI ↔ DisplayPort / USB-C
(USB-C is carrying the DP signal)
the results in my experience have always been BAD
IME the ultimate solution has pretty much always been to ditch HDMI and go all-in on DP / USB-C
Note that you can “convert” between DisplayPort ↔ USB-C without any issues because its the same signal just a different cable
But the conversion between HDMI ↔ DP is a lot more precarious and most all adapters I have tried for it have non stop issues
This is especially the case when it comes to Mac’s, it seems that Mac / macOS is a hell of a lot more picky about the video signals it will support than e.g. Windows
I got a KVM with only DisplayPort outputs and I use a DP ↔ USB-C cable for my Mac’s, in fact, I have the KVM → OWC ThunderBolt 3 hub → USB-C → MacBook and it works perfectly, and has for years