Impossible KVM Setup

I’ve been trying different iterations to support the following:
Monitor: Samsung Neo G9 - 5120x1440 @ 120hz
1x PC w/ RTX3090
2x 14" M1 Macbook Pros

Awhile back I purchased the L1 Dual Monitor (single was sold out) DP1. 4 KVM hoping it would allow me to support this setup. The weird thing is that it mostly “works” with some insanely annoying issues.

PC: Works 100% of the time. Have not had an issue here yet.
M1 Macbooks: Connected to the KVM with Moshi DP → USB-C cables and USB is connected to Caldigit TS3 docks.

Here’s what I’ve tried:

  1. Connecting KVM → Directly to M1 laptop.
  • Mac fails to wake up the monitor roughly 50% of the time. Have do some random un-plug/replug and open/close lid of the Macbook to get the display to pop on. Sometimes you can see the display flicker like it’s trying, but it ends up shutting off.
  • Rarely, but once and awhile the screen will just go completely black. Have to do the unplug/replug or lid open/close dance again. Sometimes have to reset the monitor
  • M1 Macs have an issue with USB hubs where they literally just kernel panic randomly and throw a " SOCD report detected: (AP watchdog expired)" error. No idea if it’s the KVM or some device(s) I have hooked up to it throwing this error.
  1. Connecting KVM display cable to Caldigit TS3
    Doesn’t seem like the TS3 can handle the resolution. The wakeup issues happen less often, but the font is noticeably more grainy looking then when the display cable is plugged directly into the laptop

  2. Connecting KVM display cable to Caldigit TS4
    I thought this was going to be the fix, however, since the TS4 added more USB ports, you actually get a “USB HUB DEPTH EXCEEDED” error if you plug the USB cable from the KVM into the dock! Video seemed to work fine, but it’s pointless if I can’t carry over USB devices.

Is anyone else running a similar setup? I realize I’m on the verge of being unsupported (especially at this resolution with this refresh rate) but I’m curious if anyone has suggestions or alternate setups that work for them.

Will reply more later. Since the last Macos update I’ve had more reports of the wakeup issue. It’s an apple thing. Big sur was doing it too for a few versions – not just the KVm. Apple will eventually fix it. It probably works better with the Mac open than closed. As insane as that sounds.

Try a USB cable straight off the mac, too, instead of the caldigit ts4 for usb. and also try several usb ports on the ts4. They aren’t all in the same spot in the USB topology

That’s optimistic :smile: Yeah, I don’t fault the KVM in the least – Windows/PCs work fine and Macs have problems waking up monitors even when they’re plugged directly into them. Wish I understood more about the specifics of the problem.

Running the USB cable from the KVM straight into the Mac works, but makes the dock kinda pointless since the point is to run everything through a single cable - otherwise the dock is doing nothing but driving the display. I think I tried most (if not all) of the USB ports on it with the same outcome, but I’ll double check.

Where did you see the “USB HUB DEPTH EXCEEDED” message?
I’m trying to get an M1 MacBook Pro to work through a CalDigit TS4 into an Aten CS1964 KVM. The screen works fine, but not seeing any USB devices that are plugged into the KVM show up on the M1…

I don’t have a l1t kvm yet, but I was planning on ordering one. I’m glad I saw this, since believe it or not my intended setup is 100% identical to yours.

G9 at 5120x1440 120hz to both a desktop with a 3090 and an M1 Max macbook with a TS4 dock.

Were you ever able to find a solution to the “USB DEPTH” error? That would definitely be a dealbreaker for me-- as you said, not much point in swapping only the displays and not the USB devices!

If you connect USB direct to the Mac bypassing the dock then it’s fine.

I’m experiencing the exact same issue with similar setup. Instead of the Macbook, I’m using Lenovo X1 Yoga 6th gen and my monitor is LG 32GP850-B. My desktop is Ryzen 7 3700X with RTX 3070 Ti. The dock TS3 Plus and KVM is Aten CS1944DP. I have second monitor (Dell U2715H) which is not connected to the laptop/TS3, but is connected to the desktop via KVM. I’m using laptop screen as the second screen.

All the connections are using DP, except from the laptop to CalDigit is TB. The LG and the Dell monitors connected to the desktop works 100% of the time. The LG monitor connected to the TS3 wakes-up about 30-40% of the time (less than 50% for me). I’m guessing this issue not related specifically to the Macbook, but either TS3 or TB.

Looking for a solution. If not, need to replace the TS3 and see what happens.

[UPDATE] FIXED! I did test with multiple other docks and it wasn’t the dock. The issue was the output frame rate from the laptop. I purchased the Aten CS1944DP KVM knowing it’ll support 1440P @ 144hz frame rate on the LG monitor using the RTX 3070 Ti from the desktop. However, my laptop has i7-1165G7 CPU with embedded GPU. Not sure what the embedded GPU is capable of, but when I restricted the output to 60 fps to the LG monitor, the wake issue was fixed. Now both LG and the Dell wakes up properly every time. I don’t need more than 60 fps on the LG from the laptop since it’s just a work computer, not gaming. My desktop still outputs 144 fps and works well. Last note. The “Adaptive-Sync” must be on and set to “extended” on the LG monitor and make sure it’s enabled in Intel Graphics setting.

Also, the DP needs to be set to the lowest DP version in the device chain. For example, in my setup, all devices have DP 1.4, but the KVM is DP 1.2, so LG’s monitor must be set to DP 1.2 in the menu. Even then, sometimes LG monitor will be out sync when the laptop is connected. Dell works just fine every time. When out of sync, I have go into LG’s menu and switch from DP 1.2 to 1.4 and then back to 1.2 and that fixes the issue. I think that is LG’s software issue. I hope this helps someone.

why not plug the usb directly into the laptop?

the level1techs kvm will probably fix the wakeup issues, but the usb issues is “a usb thing” depending on how the dock is implemented. But you don’t want usb sucking all your display bandwidth in 2022 anyway. It was fine for usb + display to run over thunderbolt in 2017.. 2022? not so much imho

This topic was automatically closed 273 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.