How long before the ban on the Personal Computer?

I’ve been pondering on this for a few years and the way things are headed , has only greatly affected my concern

  1. The removal of control

The digital age has slowly brought forth the enshitification.

Netflix when it was new was GREAT
It provided the easy cost effective solution for people to actually pay for access to what they want. It proved that piracy isn’t what people strive to do. Especially if the market just makes it easy for people to pay for things.
Then slowly everyone wanted a piece of the pie and lost all the content people wanted. Netflix lost customers, so to subsidize raises it’s prices every 6 months for LESS content. Ultimately added ads on a once “ad-free” platform. Other studios wanted control. Not saying they aren’t entitled to do so, but led back to the TV packages era that we all wanted to get rid of.

2.) The push for MORE CLOUD

With more data centers popping up every day, more people and companies are loosing what they bought and paid for in favor of subscriptions. Companies (not naming names) removing access to already paid software, locking out people until they pay up, again, and again.
The recent loss of affordable computer hardware makes it impossible for average joe to play a damn game.
Sony removing access to NBA 2Kwhatever, No physical discs, and trust me, Xbox isn’t far behind.
And instead of being able to resell your bought game for a few dollars back, they would rather sell it to your friend at full price.

Because where are you gonna go to get the game? NOWHERE, it’s only on the PS store at full price. This brings back point one of control.

Another note is the ID checks. It also starts there.

Look- People won’t start breaking down your door to take away your illegal computer. But We’ve seen Windows trying to force people to buy new computers with the TPM debacle.
They want to control what they deem is allowed to run windows.

Then the discord ID check, Not only will they know who you are, but could refuse install if you’re running a unauthorized VM or a old computer.
I’m using Discord as an example but it is easy for the powers that be, decide how you use that software.
if running on approved Azure windows VM from approved crypographically signed thin client
then install
else fail

3.) THINK OF THE CHILDREN ™
We recently saw lobbyists state in court that running a minecraft server is illegal and against TOS. Microsoft can’t protect children if people are allowed to run their own games.

No not long from now, everything will be cloud because companies can lock down who has access and at their price. And law makers are easily bought, just make laws and run on the whole

“Computers are for criminals. Why won’t you just go to the cloud, Are you a criminal?”

“Are you using that computer for Stealing? Are you a predator?”

I think there is great cause for concern that not long from now, owning a personal compute device will be outlawed (or forcefully phased out of society) unless it’s a tightly locked down cell phone, a thin client that connects to a VM in Azure for “computer” work, Or a locked down Xbox or Playstation.

9 Likes

This is something I’ve been actively concerned about. Its why I run my own Teamspeak server (You can get it to run on a Raspberry pi nowadays) and I’ve been building as many pc’s as possible and I’m picking up more. I’ve built up a substantial bluray collection that I put on my own NAS (I’m not one to sail the 7 seas ever though). I also picked up 4 spare 14tb drives and a 10tb drive before prices became insane. This allows me to hopefully run my servers for quite some time. Also if the AI bubble pops, for a time until it recovers we should be able to buy gear again, at least temporarily while some of the companies collapse.

1 Like

It’s getting to the point that personal computers are already practically a luxury item, the effect being essentially the same.

It’s sort of ironic that without people who can develop the solutions that leverage AI, the wizards in silicone valley have effectively kneecapped the superintelligence revolution in its infancy. You can’t get those “embedded engineers” as they are calling them without raising successive generations of technically inclined people with relevant skillsets, which are unobtainable without access to the underlying technology. It’s a real catch 22. And, time is not unlimited: eventually lenders funding this “revolution” will expect payments on these moonshot debts.

5 Likes

I think being able to buy/build a computer is running out. Crucial is a great example. Why should they sell to consumers? They have customers who are paying for what they produce before they even make it and they are making an incredible amount of money as a result. How long will it be before Nvidia and AMD stop selling consumer GPU’s? I’m surprised they still do.

I can see a ban as things get more locked down, but I think the market will already be gone at that point. At that point most people will not care. Nothing is set in stone yet, but the PC/PC Parts market is going to change even further in the future, like now to 4 years in the future.

I think the only way personal computing becomes full-on illegal is if there is some real or imagined threat that the government (I’m thinking US because that’s where I am, but could be anywhere) uses as an excuse. By nature, I’m not an alarmist or a doomer and as little as 5 years ago I would have thought the idea of a “legal” ban absurd, but the more I see corpo-tech holding hands with government the more I think it might not be too far outside of the realm of possibility.

However, I am a hopeful person and don’t think it will come to that. Or if the government tries it will fail.

I think the implicit ban, ie, making personal computing prohibitively expensive and cloud services proportionately enticing, just like you were saying, is already here for a lot of people.

There is hope here as well though. We’ve kind of gotten comfortable having bleeding edge hardware at home. Computing can happen on older hardware and a lot of creativity and innovation happens when resources are limited. In that way I think we’ll be able to hold on to meaningful compute at home. And hopefully, either when the ai bubble pops or there is a breakthrough in memory fabrication or something, we can come out on the other end with skills and understanding to avoid being backed into the corner we’re getting pushed into now.

2 Likes

I don’t think they will ever be banned, at least not in free countries, but they might be effectively killed off through cost increases and the industry’s desire to move to subscription models, where they can control and charge you for everything you want to do.

Without regulation preventing it, this really does feel like the direction in which things are going. They have wanted this for 15 years, but it is only with first crypto and now AI out-competing the consumer for hardware and thus making it very expensive that they have actually been able to start realizing it.

So, I don’t think any self respecting democracy will outright ban personal computing, but I do think the likelihood is high that many will fail to enact the required consumer protections that prevent it from effectively happening anyway.

I’ve had a similar discussion recently concerning cars. Is see the possibility of the same thing happening eventually as well. Specifically older “dumb” cars that aren’t “connected”.
Governments won’t have to “outlaw” them. I figure they will become too expensive to keep for many. Insurance companies will keep raising the rates on these cars with no “black box” and that can’t be tracked etc.
Also pressure from the other argument “safety”. Police keep pushing for “remote disable” etc.

Your older “dumb” car will still be tracked everywhere it goes via Flock cameras, drones, vehicle mounted license plate scanners, and EZ-Pass tags.

When the network is complete, don’t be surprised when we get nationwide open road tolling. Ostensibly, to ensure hybrid and electric owners pay their fair share of road maintenance since they don’t use much/any taxed fuel. But you know the gas tax will stay in place so ICE owners will get to pay both.

I doubt we’ll ever see a ban.

…a collapse in supply crushing economies of scale and thus pricing out many on the other hand seems downright plausible. We’re not that far off in a way.

Also some form of internet needing hardware attestation could also lock out devices from practical use even if not banned

Fair point. You don’t need “connected” cars to be “tracked”.

And the way trends are going, it’s going to be Axon instead of Flock.

Same difference for us though.

You’re worried about the same stuff Richard Stallman was in the 80s when he saw computing becoming locked down around him.

This was a fun short story he wrote in 1996 -The Right to Read - GNU Project - Free Software Foundation

We can influence the future. Make computing what you want it to be. We are posting on this forum instead of an L1 Facebook group, an independent server that didn’t even age validate me.

You don’t need Netflix, Windows 11, etc.

Some outcomes I’ve found amazing include:

  • YouTubes most popular creator (for a while) PewDiePie, deGoogled! He even switched to some nerd Lye nucks thing
  • Microsoft is now involved in Open Source
  • A Linux PC has a bigger games catalogue than the latest PlayStation
  • The Copyright enforcers, once one of the most powerful forces in computing, have been absolutely steam rolled by “AI”

This current situation with RAM and SSD sucks. But I think we’ll have free computing for basically forever, because computers got so much faster than we need. We could be writing to each other like this on a 486, while chatting on IRC. So we can make do with any ewaste since the 80s.

But we don’t have to necessarily dig up the ewaste, we have new chips, low power / cheap embedded systems, even microcontrollers, have gotten very powerful. My OpenWRT wifi router has a quad core 2Ghz, 1GB RAM, 8GB eMMC. That’s a crazy amount of power, it has serial on the board and a USB3 port, I could use that as a desktop.

Whether most people have free computing is different, they seem pretty happy with the increasingly locked down and dumb down trend, the iPhone has displaced PCs.

But I don’t need most people to be on board, I just need some people.

2 Likes

There aren’t any “self-respecting democracies” left, are there? They are all run by psychopaths who would sell their first-born if it meant gaining control over people’s digital lives. Control that, and you control what people think, and can remain in power forever.

I am struggling to think of a single law — passed by any government within the last 25 years — that has promoted any concept even remotely approaching “freedom of personal computation”. It’s all been erosion.

I remember Napster like it was yesterday. I also remember the promise of “Crypto” and how governments have neutered or co-opted the technology.

I look at the recent development of ArtCraft (AI-generated clones of Adobe Photoshop, Premiere, etc., and Microsoft Word, Excel, etc.) and think “Yep, this might be the tipping point.”

AI — in the hands of individuals — is threatening the cash cows developed by corporations. All arguments about the ‘quality’ of clones are irrelevant — what matters is the pace at which clones can now be developed. The legal system is simply too slow to be able to defend corporate profits against such an adversary. It’s like playing whack-a-mole when the moles keep appearing at a geometrically-faster rate.

The only way for governments to do the bidding of the corporations that they represent is to enact some (more) laws written by said corporations’ lawyers that not only eliminate the current crop of clones, but make it impossible for new clones to be created.

One entirely plausible way for that to occur is to “prohibit private ownership of computing hardware that is capable of running models capable of developing clones”. On the ground, that might mean that it becomes illegal for individuals to own GPUs with more than 8 GB of VRAM, or CPUs with more than 16 cores.

Not an outright ban on personal compute, but a further erosion that has some non-trivial implications for most of us.

i think more companies will follow LG example of collecting data from users. so no ban, but “more computers”. more “SMART” products

Europes GDPR maybe? It is at least tangential.

You seem a little bit more cynical than I am.

I see the erosion not coming on purpose from the perspective of the politicians, but through manipulation by pushing for laws that have erosion as a side effect “for the safety of the children”.

These things often get passed even when politicians realize how dangerous they are, because if they dare stand up and oppose them, in the next election all of the SuperPAC ad money is attacking them for “not caring about the children”.

Industry’s main strategy appears to set up bills that are nothing but a trap. Vote for them and you are dismantling everyone’s freedoms, vote against them and you are attacked for not protecting children. it’s kind of vile how monied industry is pursuing these disingenuous bills.

Other than attempting to get money out of politics, I don’t know how we fix this problem, and that will take some extraordinary turn of events, because the monied interests very much do not want money out of politics.

1 Like

I’d argue it’s the complete opposite. GDPR added even more regulatory burden to hobby sites already struggling and put many under.

I’m still salty it put nekochan over the edge and closed them down.

Everyone has good points here, but I think it’s too early to tell.

Personal computing (like phones) is a “PC” if you think about it. It does computing for you. Locally. Offline even if you turn off the cellular feature, and look at Samsung DEX that’s a peak example.

The “PC” itself won’t be banned. But, what I think will get banned, or just get outside of the consumer price range is actual compute. I’m talking 16, 32, 64, 128 core CPUs, big GPUs and large storage devices.

The death around the corner isn’t personal computing. It’s Enthusiast Computing (EC) that is at threat of death.

The topics of Legislation, GDPR, and the likes are valid here. But, as I stated I do not think we will never have a PC (phone, tablet, desktop, laptop, etc). We just won’t have the traditional Enthusiast Computing that we’ve seen over the years.

1 Like

Well, if you’ve got so much money that speeding tickets feel less like a punishment and more like a day pass, is speeding really illegal in your eyes?

And if an RTX spark, the supposed “future of personal computing”, costs 7K new, are you, John Doe, really allowed a PC? They don’t have to ban personal computers, when they can price you out and use the “macro-economic headwinds!“ excuse or whatever new cop-out they have, to explain away any concerns with rigging the market against you. After that, all they have to do is wait for our PCs to stop working.

1 Like

Firearm people all slobbering to post the “First Time?” meme, its me, I slobber.

1 Like

That plan may all blow up in their faces as they sit on unused inventory of gpu’s with no infrastructure to power them. They said the quite part loud when then they stated they were hording hardware and forcing SaaS on everyone. We basically adapt and learn to recycle our old and used computer components. Radio Shack was a thing back in they day when people actually learned how to do for themselves, & it may be the way to bring computers back into the hands of the people. New stuff isn’t even made anymore because big tech has gotten too lazy with stagnation and price gouging other companies.

Well when you rack up enough they take your license away
Edit: I forgot, that’s the law for the normies.

1 Like