Since I am currently doing a similar project, here is what I found out so far.
It seems to be pretty complex and the wording and resources from BlackMagic are a little bit strange for a newcomer like me.
So I try to split things up.
First of all, let’s take a look at project libraries.
A Project Library (formerly project database), is a database file storing one or more DaVinci Resolve projects. When you create or load a project from the Project Manager, or save a current project, you read from or write to a project library. A project library contains multiple projects, and each project contains all the timelines, grades, clip metadata, visual effects, audio mixing, etc. for your film. A project library does not store the original media itself, only the instructions on how to use that media to create a finished film. DaVinci Resolve can access multiple project libraries, but can only connect to one project library at a time.
Now for project libraries there are three options on where to store them.
— Local: Stores your project libraries locally on your workstation. This is the default and is best for individual users or single systems.
— Network: Stores your project libraries on an external computer that is connected to several workstations on the same local network. It also allows you to control user access to the project library. This is best for a facility composed of multiple workstations in the same building working on the same material.
— Cloud: Stores your project libraries in the Blackmagic Cloud. This allows several workstations to connect to the same project library over the internet. It also allows you to control user access to the project library. This is best for multiple people working on the same project from different locations around the world.
Let’s take an even deeper look at each option.
Local is probably out of the Window unless you are a very small team and never work on the same project. You could in theory use local by saving the library in a Dropbox or similar “Cloud” folder. That way another project member could access it. Problem is that there is no file lock system (well there is, but it won’t work on cloud services that do not instantly sync) and if two people open it up at the same time there will be conflicts.
Network: This option has basically two parts, storage and collaboration.
Network storage: could be a Windows 11 PC sharing (watch out for the share limitations of none Server Windows) a Mac sharing or a NAS (Synology, QNAP) or TrueNAS.
There is a lock mechanism, so not multiple people at the same time can open it.
Network for collaboration: there is an option to use a collaborative workflow for Network Libraries. Multiple people can work at the same project. But you need a DaVinci Resolve Project Server for that!
DaVinci Resolve Project Server: It looks like there a basically no real requirements for that machine, other than it is up and running 24/7. That is why you probably see a lot of people recommending getting a mac Mini for that. Uptime is probably better than with a Windows client.
So let’s look at the network options again.
We first need to decide if we need collaboration. If not, we can ditch the second part and the Project Server.
Whatever we choose, we could combine it with a VPN so we can work from outside and basically create our own cloud solution. Setting up a VPN in a secure way is not an easy task and you need to know stuff about networks like CG-NAT. Another problem is that you need very fast access to the project with low latency. Since that is not really possible over the internet, unless both sides use fiber, and even then it is not guaranteed, we need some kind of cache. For media we need a fast enough connection to stream it. Proxies make the bandwidth requirements smaller.
Blackmagic Cloud Hardware:
This is basically just some very simple NAS and cache server hardware that Blackmagic sells you. It seems easy to setup and does a lot of heavy lifting for you. You still need to take care of some network stuff and know how to import and trust certs so your clients can access it over the internet.
The storage of that solution is based on two options. Cloud Dock and Cloud Store.
Dock will only work with Dropbox/GDrive as storage backend and Store will work with Blackmagic Cloud as storage backend.
Dropbox or Gdrive as storage backend:
Pricing depends on region. Roughly 1k € per year for 5TB.
Blackmagic Cloud as storage backend:
Pricing depends on region, roughly 5€ per Project, and 15€ per TB.
Another completely different topic that could become interesting for you is proxies. The software Blackmagic Proxy Generator can automatically overwatch folders to create proxies. This could be a local Windows Workstation or macMini, depending on your needs.
That is probably because it all REALLY depends on your workload.
Biggest issue I see currently with your workload, is that you only have 1GBit upload and it is not even fiber, which means high latency. So a VPN to a network drive is not gonna cut it. These editors either need to somehow have the project local (otherwise performance is too bad) and to somehow access the media (either the original or proxy).
To solve that for your remote workers have multiple options.
-
Download a project to their remote systems and tell everyone else not to work in that project. Probably not a good solutions, unless very small and no collab.
-
Install a Blackmagic Cloud Pod in every remote workers home, basically acts as a local cache server for your Dropbox/GDrive storage. Your remote workers each having their own Cloud Pod that syncs with your company Dropbox/Gdrive.
-
Go with the Blackmagic Cloud as storage backend. Here I hope files are stored locally and maybe even collab is possible.
-
This option I would have to test or read up on it, not sure if this can be done. Connect via VPN, somehow get the Project locally cached, maybe from the Project manager and work with small proxies.