Spurred by my good forum buddy @GigaBusterEXE, I am writing more about why the berserk series right now sucks, and Miura is totally using it as a scape goat to play more idol master.
Iām goingto talk about story issues, cause everyone and their mother knows that the animation is trash. They could have pulled off the slide shows with the 3D if it actually looked good, but itās obvious that whatever the director had going for him when he worked on gurren lagann stayed at trigger.
Number 1, not redoing and completing the blackswordsman arc. He fights a fucking giant tree monster instead? What the fuck man? No slug baron!? No lost children?! This is the darkest Guts gets in entire series. Where itās literally just him, and a fairy that never gets in the way when heās going full fucking berserker mode. Guts never shows the extreme rage heās been given in his experience in the eclipse except when he actually dons the berserker armor, but even then. I feel like since itās being pulled out of him it feels crunchier in the vs slug lord and rosine than in the desperate measures use the berserk armor to protect something he lost and has found again.
This sets up everything for Guts, and also not building on the foreshadowing of Rosine making appearances later as she was one of the apostles there at the camp of the band of the hawks murder. It also gives a better sense of time on how long guts was away from caska, and why that might way so heavily on him. In the anime you might even think he was gone either a couple of months or a goddamn decade. Nobody knows!
Except literally everything that has to do with character motivations was cut from the anime. Almost every interaction Farnese has is cut short. Shierke and Isidro are put in too early, and this theme feeds into the most abhorant, disrespectful, bullshit that there could be for a berkserk anime.
The theme of causality and Guts lamentation at himself and everything he has to do and has done wrong is completely missing. Itās just get to plot point 1 to 2 to 3 to 4 asap without any of the info that really builds on it properly. This is the crux of berserk! This is why you always feel a connection to Guts regardless of his own actions. Because in some way everyone can relate to having to do things they may not want to do that drastically impact their life. Either by the actions of other people, or the needs you need to fill, or your mistakes through life.
All of this because some studio low balled the rights holders on price of creating the anime. A studio that never used 3D animation but relentlessly pursued a lack luster hasing filter for shading that requires so much time to add that they have no time for other textures or sub surface scattering, or anything else that might make the 3D side of things look better with itās fucking shiny blank fill tool coloring. Or maybe that was the desired look and for some reason they canāt afford the render time for 24 FPS animation in 3D. Makes sense since they donāt seem to have the time or budget for animating a 3D tween
Miura probably doesnāt give too much of a shit so long as that royalty cheque comes in and more tankobons get sold so he can play some more idol master, watch some more japanese youtube looking up vocaloid videos or something. Iām sorry Miura-sama, please finish berserk.