The situation:
- 16TB Seagate drive failed 2 extended offline SMART tests: Had a few unreadable sectors
- Pulled the drive. Full wipe with
dd. then a full read to test - Unreadable sectors are now gone, since they have been remapped.
- Drive reports 24 reallocated sectors, which is below the 100 threshold
Here’s the rub; It’s a factory re-certified drive. Seller agreed to RMA by refunding me the original purchase price of 200 usd. Buuuuut. A new replacement drive is almost 700 usd today. And my guess is the drive wouldn’t actually fail a smart test today.
Usually I’d just replace without a second thought, but 500 usd is a big price tag. Who would have thunk the cost of storage would soar a few years back eh?
So: Would you RMA and take the cost of a new drive? Keep the iffy drive in the pool? Replace with a new drive and keep the iffy one as a spare? Something else?
Some more nitty gritty:
Set-up: 1 x RAIDZ2 | 8 wide (16TB each)
Usage: Homelab. But there’s valuable stuff on there I can’t afford to lose (backed up but still)
Logs:
smartctl 7.5 (build date Jan 1 1980) [x86_64-linux-6.18.53] (local build)
Copyright (C) 2002-25, Bruce Allen, Christian Franke, www.smartmontools.org
=== START OF READ SMART DATA SECTION ===
SMART Self-test log structure revision number 1
Num Test_Description Status Remaining LifeTime(hours) LBA_of_first_error
# 1 Extended offline Aborted by host 90% 9896 -
# 2 Short offline Completed without error 00% 9858 -
# 3 Extended offline Completed: read failure 70% 9790 -
# 4 Extended offline Completed: read failure 70% 9705 -
# 5 Short offline Completed without error 00% 9690 -
# 6 Short offline Completed without error 00% 9522 -
# 7 Short offline Completed without error 00% 9354 -
# 8 Short offline Completed without error 00% 9186 -
# 9 Extended offline Completed without error 00% 9089 -
#10 Short offline Completed without error 00% 9018 -
#11 Short offline Completed without error 00% 8850 -
#12 Short offline Completed without error 00% 8682 -
#13 Short offline Completed without error 00% 8514 -
#14 Extended offline Completed without error 00% 8352 -
#15 Short offline Completed without error 00% 8178 -
#16 Short offline Completed without error 00% 8010 -
#17 Short offline Completed without error 00% 7842 -
#18 Short offline Completed without error 00% 7674 -
#19 Extended offline Completed without error 00% 7600 -
#20 Short offline Completed without error 00% 7506 -
#21 Short offline Completed without error 00% 7338 -
smartctl 7.5 (build date Jan 1 1980) [x86_64-linux-6.18.53] (local build)
Copyright (C) 2002-25, Bruce Allen, Christian Franke, www.smartmontools.org
=== START OF READ SMART DATA SECTION ===
SMART Attributes Data Structure revision number: 10
Vendor Specific SMART Attributes with Thresholds:
ID# ATTRIBUTE_NAME FLAG VALUE WORST THRESH TYPE UPDATED WHEN_FAILED RAW_VALUE
1 Raw_Read_Error_Rate 0x000f 082 064 044 Pre-fail Always - 0/171599872
3 Spin_Up_Time 0x0003 091 088 000 Pre-fail Always - 0
4 Start_Stop_Count 0x0032 100 100 020 Old_age Always - 122
5 Reallocated_Sector_Ct 0x0033 100 100 010 Pre-fail Always - 24
7 Seek_Error_Rate 0x000f 086 060 045 Pre-fail Always - 0/375227340
9 Power_On_Hours 0x0032 089 089 000 Old_age Always - 9918
10 Spin_Retry_Count 0x0013 100 100 097 Pre-fail Always - 0
12 Power_Cycle_Count 0x0032 100 100 020 Old_age Always - 120
18 Head_Health 0x000b 100 100 050 Pre-fail Always - 0
187 Reported_Uncorrect 0x0032 100 100 000 Old_age Always - 0
188 Command_Timeout 0x0032 100 100 000 Old_age Always - 0 0 0
190 Airflow_Temperature_Cel 0x0022 069 044 040 Old_age Always - 31 (Min/Max 28/47)
192 Power-Off_Retract_Count 0x0032 100 100 000 Old_age Always - 68
193 Load_Cycle_Count 0x0032 100 100 000 Old_age Always - 901
194 Temperature_Celsius 0x0022 031 056 000 Old_age Always - 31 (0 19 0 0 0)
197 Current_Pending_Sector 0x0012 100 100 000 Old_age Always - 0
198 Offline_Uncorrectable 0x0010 100 100 000 Old_age Offline - 0
199 UDMA_CRC_Error_Count 0x003e 200 200 000 Old_age Always - 0
200 Pressure_Limit 0x0023 100 100 001 Pre-fail Always - 0
240 Head_Flying_Hours 0x0000 100 253 000 Old_age Offline - 9861h+75m+55.827s
241 Total_LBAs_Written 0x0000 100 253 000 Old_age Offline - 53358743744
242 Total_LBAs_Read 0x0000 100 253 000 Old_age Offline - 137625347601
smartctl 7.5 (build date Jan 1 1980) [x86_64-linux-6.18.53] (local build)
Copyright (C) 2002-25, Bruce Allen, Christian Franke, www.smartmontools.org
Seagate Field Access Reliability Metrics log (FARM) (GP Log 0xa6)
FARM Log Page 0: Log Header
FARM Log Version: 4.19
Pages Supported: 6
Log Size: 98304
Page Size: 16384
Heads Supported: 24
Number of Copies: 0
Reason for Frame Capture: 0
FARM Log Page 1: Drive Information
Serial Number: ZL24SR1F
World Wide Name: 0x5000c500c55688c9
Device Interface: SATA
Device Capacity in Sectors: 31251759104
Physical Sector Size: 4096
Logical Sector Size: 512
Device Buffer Size: 268435456
Number of Heads: 18
Device Form Factor: 3.5 inches
Rotation Rate: 7200 rpm
Firmware Rev: SN04
ATA Security State (ID Word 128): 0x01621
ATA Features Supported (ID Word 78): 0x016cc
ATA Features Enabled (ID Word 79): 0x0000000000000040
Power on Hours: 9918
Spindle Power on Hours: 9905
Head Flight Hours: 9880
Head Load Events: 902
Power Cycle Count: 121
Hardware Reset Count: 182
Spin-up Time: 11 ms
Time to ready of the last power cycle: 22009 ms
Time drive is held in staggered spin: 0 ms
Model Number: ST16000NM001G-2KK103
Drive Recording Type: CMR
Max Number of Available Sectors for Reassignment: 57754
Assembly Date (YYWW): 2443
Depopulation Head Mask: 0
FARM Log Page 2: Workload Statistics
Total Number of Read Commands: 223459490
Total Number of Write Commands: 109583581
Total Number of Random Read Commands: 27394870
Total Number of Random Write Commands: 85892576
Total Number Of Other Commands: 46053090
Logical Sectors Written: 53358743744
Logical Sectors Read: 137625347601
Number of dither events during current power cycle: 226
Number of times dither was held off during random workloads: 305
Number of times dither was held off during sequential workloads: 14774954
Number of Read commands from 0-3.125% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 931436
Number of Read commands from 3.125-25% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 6334003
Number of Read commands from 25-75% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 10045500
Number of Read commands from 75-100% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 9762188
Number of Write commands from 0-3.125% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 1790009
Number of Write commands from 3.125-25% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 3429104
Number of Write commands from 25-75% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 7941847
Number of Write commands from 75-100% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 9357906
FARM Log Page 3: Error Statistics
Unrecoverable Read Errors: 0
Unrecoverable Write Errors: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors: 24
Number of Read Recovery Attempts: 0
Number of Mechanical Start Failures: 0
Number of Reallocated Candidate Sectors: 0
Number of ASR Events: 106
Number of Interface CRC Errors: 0
Spin Retry Count: 0
Spin Retry Count Normalized: 100
Spin Retry Count Worst: 100
Number of IOEDC Errors (Raw): 0
CTO Count Total: 0
CTO Count Over 5s: 0
CTO Count Over 7.5s: 0
Total Flash LED (Assert) Events: 0
Index of the last Flash LED: 0
Flash LED Event 0:
Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
Timestamp of Event 0 (hours): 0
Power Cycle Event 0: 0
Flash LED Event 1:
Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
Timestamp of Event 1 (hours): 0
Power Cycle Event 1: 0
Flash LED Event 2:
Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
Timestamp of Event 2 (hours): 0
Power Cycle Event 2: 0
Flash LED Event 3:
Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
Timestamp of Event 3 (hours): 0
Power Cycle Event 3: 0
Flash LED Event 4:
Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
Timestamp of Event 4 (hours): 0
Power Cycle Event 4: 0
Flash LED Event 5:
Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
Timestamp of Event 5 (hours): 0
Power Cycle Event 5: 0
Flash LED Event 6:
Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
Timestamp of Event 6 (hours): 0
Power Cycle Event 6: 0
Flash LED Event 7:
Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
Timestamp of Event 7 (hours): 0
Power Cycle Event 7: 0
Uncorrectable errors: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read errors due to ERC: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 0:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 1:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 2:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 3:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 4:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 5:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 6:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 7:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 8:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 9:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 10:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 11:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 12:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 13:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 14:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 15:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 16:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 17:
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
FARM Log Page 4: Environment Statistics
Current Temperature (Celsius): 31
Highest Temperature: 56
Lowest Temperature: 25
Average Short Term Temperature: 38
Average Long Term Temperature: 35
Highest Average Short Term Temperature: 42
Lowest Average Short Term Temperature: 26
Highest Average Long Term Temperature: 37
Lowest Average Long Term Temperature: 29
Time In Over Temperature (minutes): 0
Time In Under Temperature (minutes): 0
Specified Max Operating Temperature: 60
Specified Min Operating Temperature: 5
Current Relative Humidity: 0
Current Motor Power: 3967
Current 12 volts: 12.426
Minimum 12 volts: 12.027
Maximum 12 volts: 12.444
Current 5 volts: 5.017
Minimum 5 volts: 5.010
Maximum 5 volts: 5.082
12V Power Average: 0.000
12V Power Minimum: 0.000
12V Power Maximum: 0.000
5V Power Average: 0.000
5V Power Minimum: 0.000
5V Power Maximum: 0.000
FARM Log Page 5: Reliability Statistics
Error Rate (SMART Attribute 1 Raw): 0x000000000a3a6800
Error Rate (SMART Attribute 1 Normalized): 82
Error Rate (SMART Attribute 1 Worst): 64
Seek Error Rate (SMART Attr 7 Raw): 0x00000000165d8429
Seek Error Rate (SMART Attr 7 Normalized): 86
Seek Error Rate (SMART Attr 7 Worst): 60
High Priority Unload Events: 68
Helium Pressure Threshold Tripped: 0
LBAs Corrected By Parity Sector: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 0: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 1: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 2: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 3: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 4: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 5: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 6: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 7: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 8: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 9: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 10: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 11: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 12: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 13: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 14: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 15: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 16: 0
DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 17: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 0: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 1: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 2: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 3: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 4: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 5: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 6: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 7: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 8: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 9: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 10: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 11: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 12: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 13: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 14: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 15: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 16: 0
RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 17: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 0: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 1: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 2: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 3: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 4: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 5: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 6: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 7: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 8: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 9: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 10: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 11: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 12: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 13: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 14: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 15: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 16: 0
FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 17: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 0: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 1: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 2: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 3: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 4: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 5: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 6: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 7: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 8: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 9: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 10: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 11: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 12: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 13: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 14: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 15: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 16: 0
Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 17: 0
Write Power On (sec) by Head 0: 13823
Write Power On (sec) by Head 1: 6659
Write Power On (sec) by Head 2: 22875
Write Power On (sec) by Head 3: 6489
Write Power On (sec) by Head 4: 6479
Write Power On (sec) by Head 5: 6400
Write Power On (sec) by Head 6: 6605
Write Power On (sec) by Head 7: 6448
Write Power On (sec) by Head 8: 6483
Write Power On (sec) by Head 9: 6278
Write Power On (sec) by Head 10: 6643
Write Power On (sec) by Head 11: 7115
Write Power On (sec) by Head 12: 7316
Write Power On (sec) by Head 13: 6758
Write Power On (sec) by Head 14: 7667
Write Power On (sec) by Head 15: 6957
Write Power On (sec) by Head 16: 6963
Write Power On (sec) by Head 17: 6669
MR Head Resistance from Head 0: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 1: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 2: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 3: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 4: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 5: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 6: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 7: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 8: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 9: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 10: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 11: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 12: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 13: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 14: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 15: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 16: 0
MR Head Resistance from Head 17: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 0: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 1: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 2: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 3: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 4: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 5: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 6: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 7: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 8: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 9: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 10: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 11: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 12: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 13: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 14: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 15: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 16: 0
Second MR Head Resistance by Head 17: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 0: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 1: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 2: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 3: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 4: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 5: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 6: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 7: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 8: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 9: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 10: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 11: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 12: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 13: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 14: 3
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 15: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 16: 0
Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 17: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 0: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 1: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 2: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 3: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 4: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 5: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 6: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 7: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 8: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 9: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 10: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 11: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 12: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 13: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 14: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 15: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 16: 0
Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 17: 0