Would you replace this drive?

The situation:

  • 16TB Seagate drive failed 2 extended offline SMART tests: Had a few unreadable sectors
  • Pulled the drive. Full wipe with dd. then a full read to test
  • Unreadable sectors are now gone, since they have been remapped.
  • Drive reports 24 reallocated sectors, which is below the 100 threshold

Here’s the rub; It’s a factory re-certified drive. Seller agreed to RMA by refunding me the original purchase price of 200 usd. Buuuuut. A new replacement drive is almost 700 usd today. And my guess is the drive wouldn’t actually fail a smart test today.

Usually I’d just replace without a second thought, but 500 usd is a big price tag. Who would have thunk the cost of storage would soar a few years back eh?

So: Would you RMA and take the cost of a new drive? Keep the iffy drive in the pool? Replace with a new drive and keep the iffy one as a spare? Something else?

Some more nitty gritty:

Set-up: 1 x RAIDZ2 | 8 wide (16TB each)

Usage: Homelab. But there’s valuable stuff on there I can’t afford to lose (backed up but still)

Logs:

smartctl 7.5 (build date Jan  1 1980) [x86_64-linux-6.18.53] (local build)
Copyright (C) 2002-25, Bruce Allen, Christian Franke, www.smartmontools.org

=== START OF READ SMART DATA SECTION ===
SMART Self-test log structure revision number 1
Num  Test_Description    Status                  Remaining  LifeTime(hours)  LBA_of_first_error
# 1  Extended offline    Aborted by host               90%      9896         -
# 2  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      9858         -
# 3  Extended offline    Completed: read failure       70%      9790         -
# 4  Extended offline    Completed: read failure       70%      9705         -
# 5  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      9690         -
# 6  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      9522         -
# 7  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      9354         -
# 8  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      9186         -
# 9  Extended offline    Completed without error       00%      9089         -
#10  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      9018         -
#11  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      8850         -
#12  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      8682         -
#13  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      8514         -
#14  Extended offline    Completed without error       00%      8352         -
#15  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      8178         -
#16  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      8010         -
#17  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      7842         -
#18  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      7674         -
#19  Extended offline    Completed without error       00%      7600         -
#20  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      7506         -
#21  Short offline       Completed without error       00%      7338         -
smartctl 7.5 (build date Jan  1 1980) [x86_64-linux-6.18.53] (local build)
Copyright (C) 2002-25, Bruce Allen, Christian Franke, www.smartmontools.org

=== START OF READ SMART DATA SECTION ===
SMART Attributes Data Structure revision number: 10
Vendor Specific SMART Attributes with Thresholds:
ID# ATTRIBUTE_NAME          FLAG     VALUE WORST THRESH TYPE      UPDATED  WHEN_FAILED RAW_VALUE
  1 Raw_Read_Error_Rate     0x000f   082   064   044    Pre-fail  Always       -       0/171599872
  3 Spin_Up_Time            0x0003   091   088   000    Pre-fail  Always       -       0
  4 Start_Stop_Count        0x0032   100   100   020    Old_age   Always       -       122
  5 Reallocated_Sector_Ct   0x0033   100   100   010    Pre-fail  Always       -       24
  7 Seek_Error_Rate         0x000f   086   060   045    Pre-fail  Always       -       0/375227340
  9 Power_On_Hours          0x0032   089   089   000    Old_age   Always       -       9918
 10 Spin_Retry_Count        0x0013   100   100   097    Pre-fail  Always       -       0
 12 Power_Cycle_Count       0x0032   100   100   020    Old_age   Always       -       120
 18 Head_Health             0x000b   100   100   050    Pre-fail  Always       -       0
187 Reported_Uncorrect      0x0032   100   100   000    Old_age   Always       -       0
188 Command_Timeout         0x0032   100   100   000    Old_age   Always       -       0 0 0
190 Airflow_Temperature_Cel 0x0022   069   044   040    Old_age   Always       -       31 (Min/Max 28/47)
192 Power-Off_Retract_Count 0x0032   100   100   000    Old_age   Always       -       68
193 Load_Cycle_Count        0x0032   100   100   000    Old_age   Always       -       901
194 Temperature_Celsius     0x0022   031   056   000    Old_age   Always       -       31 (0 19 0 0 0)
197 Current_Pending_Sector  0x0012   100   100   000    Old_age   Always       -       0
198 Offline_Uncorrectable   0x0010   100   100   000    Old_age   Offline      -       0
199 UDMA_CRC_Error_Count    0x003e   200   200   000    Old_age   Always       -       0
200 Pressure_Limit          0x0023   100   100   001    Pre-fail  Always       -       0
240 Head_Flying_Hours       0x0000   100   253   000    Old_age   Offline      -       9861h+75m+55.827s
241 Total_LBAs_Written      0x0000   100   253   000    Old_age   Offline      -       53358743744
242 Total_LBAs_Read         0x0000   100   253   000    Old_age   Offline      -       137625347601
smartctl 7.5 (build date Jan  1 1980) [x86_64-linux-6.18.53] (local build)
Copyright (C) 2002-25, Bruce Allen, Christian Franke, www.smartmontools.org

Seagate Field Access Reliability Metrics log (FARM) (GP Log 0xa6)
	FARM Log Page 0: Log Header
		FARM Log Version: 4.19
		Pages Supported: 6
		Log Size: 98304
		Page Size: 16384
		Heads Supported: 24
		Number of Copies: 0
		Reason for Frame Capture: 0
	FARM Log Page 1: Drive Information
		Serial Number: ZL24SR1F
		World Wide Name: 0x5000c500c55688c9
		Device Interface: SATA
		Device Capacity in Sectors: 31251759104
		Physical Sector Size: 4096
		Logical Sector Size: 512
		Device Buffer Size: 268435456
		Number of Heads: 18
		Device Form Factor: 3.5 inches
		Rotation Rate: 7200 rpm
		Firmware Rev: SN04
		ATA Security State (ID Word 128): 0x01621
		ATA Features Supported (ID Word 78): 0x016cc
		ATA Features Enabled (ID Word 79): 0x0000000000000040
		Power on Hours: 9918
		Spindle Power on Hours: 9905
		Head Flight Hours: 9880
		Head Load Events: 902
		Power Cycle Count: 121
		Hardware Reset Count: 182
		Spin-up Time: 11 ms
		Time to ready of the last power cycle: 22009 ms
		Time drive is held in staggered spin: 0 ms
		Model Number: ST16000NM001G-2KK103
		Drive Recording Type: CMR
		Max Number of Available Sectors for Reassignment: 57754
		Assembly Date (YYWW): 2443
		Depopulation Head Mask: 0
	FARM Log Page 2: Workload Statistics
		Total Number of Read Commands: 223459490
		Total Number of Write Commands: 109583581
		Total Number of Random Read Commands: 27394870
		Total Number of Random Write Commands: 85892576
		Total Number Of Other Commands: 46053090
		Logical Sectors Written: 53358743744
		Logical Sectors Read: 137625347601
		Number of dither events during current power cycle: 226
		Number of times dither was held off during random workloads: 305
		Number of times dither was held off during sequential workloads: 14774954
		Number of Read commands from 0-3.125% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 931436
		Number of Read commands from 3.125-25% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 6334003
		Number of Read commands from 25-75% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 10045500
		Number of Read commands from 75-100% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 9762188
		Number of Write commands from 0-3.125% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 1790009
		Number of Write commands from 3.125-25% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 3429104
		Number of Write commands from 25-75% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 7941847
		Number of Write commands from 75-100% of LBA space for last 3 SMART Summary Frames: 9357906
	FARM Log Page 3: Error Statistics
		Unrecoverable Read Errors: 0
		Unrecoverable Write Errors: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors: 24
		Number of Read Recovery Attempts: 0
		Number of Mechanical Start Failures: 0
		Number of Reallocated Candidate Sectors: 0
		Number of ASR Events: 106
		Number of Interface CRC Errors: 0
		Spin Retry Count: 0
		Spin Retry Count Normalized: 100
		Spin Retry Count Worst: 100
		Number of IOEDC Errors (Raw): 0
		CTO Count Total: 0
		CTO Count Over 5s: 0
		CTO Count Over 7.5s: 0
		Total Flash LED (Assert) Events: 0
		Index of the last Flash LED: 0
		Flash LED Event 0:
			Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
			Timestamp of Event 0 (hours): 0
			Power Cycle Event 0: 0
		Flash LED Event 1:
			Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
			Timestamp of Event 1 (hours): 0
			Power Cycle Event 1: 0
		Flash LED Event 2:
			Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
			Timestamp of Event 2 (hours): 0
			Power Cycle Event 2: 0
		Flash LED Event 3:
			Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
			Timestamp of Event 3 (hours): 0
			Power Cycle Event 3: 0
		Flash LED Event 4:
			Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
			Timestamp of Event 4 (hours): 0
			Power Cycle Event 4: 0
		Flash LED Event 5:
			Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
			Timestamp of Event 5 (hours): 0
			Power Cycle Event 5: 0
		Flash LED Event 6:
			Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
			Timestamp of Event 6 (hours): 0
			Power Cycle Event 6: 0
		Flash LED Event 7:
			Event Information: 0x0000000000000000
			Timestamp of Event 7 (hours): 0
			Power Cycle Event 7: 0
		Uncorrectable errors: 0
		Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read errors due to ERC: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 0:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 1:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 2:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 3:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 4:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 5:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 6:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 7:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 8:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 9:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 10:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 11:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 12:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 13:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 14:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 15:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 16:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
		Cum Lifetime Unrecoverable by head 17:
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Repeating: 0
			Cumulative Lifetime Unrecoverable Read Unique: 0
	FARM Log Page 4: Environment Statistics
		Current Temperature (Celsius): 31
		Highest Temperature: 56
		Lowest Temperature: 25
		Average Short Term Temperature: 38
		Average Long Term Temperature: 35
		Highest Average Short Term Temperature: 42
		Lowest Average Short Term Temperature: 26
		Highest Average Long Term Temperature: 37
		Lowest Average Long Term Temperature: 29
		Time In Over Temperature (minutes): 0
		Time In Under Temperature (minutes): 0
		Specified Max Operating Temperature: 60
		Specified Min Operating Temperature: 5
		Current Relative Humidity: 0
		Current Motor Power: 3967
		Current 12 volts: 12.426
		Minimum 12 volts: 12.027
		Maximum 12 volts: 12.444
		Current 5 volts: 5.017
		Minimum 5 volts: 5.010
		Maximum 5 volts: 5.082
		12V Power Average: 0.000
		12V Power Minimum: 0.000
		12V Power Maximum: 0.000
		5V Power Average: 0.000
		5V Power Minimum: 0.000
		5V Power Maximum: 0.000
	FARM Log Page 5: Reliability Statistics
		Error Rate (SMART Attribute 1 Raw): 0x000000000a3a6800
		Error Rate (SMART Attribute 1 Normalized): 82
		Error Rate (SMART Attribute 1 Worst): 64
		Seek Error Rate (SMART Attr 7 Raw): 0x00000000165d8429
		Seek Error Rate (SMART Attr 7 Normalized): 86
		Seek Error Rate (SMART Attr 7 Worst): 60
		High Priority Unload Events: 68
		Helium Pressure Threshold Tripped: 0
		LBAs Corrected By Parity Sector: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 0: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 1: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 2: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 3: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 4: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 5: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 6: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 7: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 8: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 9: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 10: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 11: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 12: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 13: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 14: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 15: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 16: 0
		DVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 17: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 0: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 1: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 2: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 3: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 4: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 5: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 6: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 7: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 8: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 9: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 10: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 11: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 12: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 13: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 14: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 15: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 16: 0
		RVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 17: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 0: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 1: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 2: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 3: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 4: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 5: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 6: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 7: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 8: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 9: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 10: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 11: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 12: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 13: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 14: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 15: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 16: 0
		FVGA Skip Write Detect by Head 17: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 0: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 1: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 2: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 3: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 4: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 5: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 6: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 7: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 8: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 9: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 10: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 11: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 12: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 13: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 14: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 15: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 16: 0
		Skip Write Detect Threshold Exceeded by Head 17: 0
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 0: 13823
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 1: 6659
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 2: 22875
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 3: 6489
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 4: 6479
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 5: 6400
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 6: 6605
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 7: 6448
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 8: 6483
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 9: 6278
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 10: 6643
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 11: 7115
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 12: 7316
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 13: 6758
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 14: 7667
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 15: 6957
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 16: 6963
		Write Power On (sec) by Head 17: 6669
		MR Head Resistance from Head 0: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 1: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 2: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 3: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 4: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 5: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 6: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 7: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 8: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 9: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 10: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 11: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 12: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 13: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 14: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 15: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 16: 0
		MR Head Resistance from Head 17: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 0: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 1: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 2: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 3: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 4: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 5: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 6: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 7: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 8: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 9: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 10: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 11: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 12: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 13: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 14: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 15: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 16: 0
		Second MR Head Resistance by Head 17: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 0: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 1: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 2: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 3: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 4: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 5: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 6: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 7: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 8: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 9: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 10: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 11: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 12: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 13: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 14: 3
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 15: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 16: 0
		Number of Reallocated Sectors by Head 17: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 0: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 1: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 2: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 3: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 4: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 5: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 6: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 7: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 8: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 9: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 10: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 11: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 12: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 13: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 14: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 15: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 16: 0
		Number of Reallocation Candidate Sectors by Head 17: 0

Keep the drive in the pool but monitor its smart stats for the next few months. I’d check them monthly and do an extended offline test every 3 months for the next half year. If the Offline_Uncorrectable or Current_Pending counts don’t exponentially increase, you should be fine. I’d avoid getting a new drive at this time if I could help it. This isn’t the best of times to buy new hardware after all.

2 Likes

Nah. Its in a zfs raid and only a handful of reallocated sectors. Drives can get some reallocated and just keep working normally for a full service life, unless the bad sectors are increasing over time it is not a dead drive. See also other opinions here

1 Like

Interesting!

Seems like crudely dding the entire disk roughly did the same thing. Caused the sector to reallocate.

Think I’ll pull a “good” disk from my backup box and plug this one in the backup box as a replacement. Thanks for the link!

Yeah writing to pending sectors will either succeed and they are cleared or fail (at the drive level) and they get reallocated.

Wendell’s method is faster because its writing only a handful of sectors ( the ones with issues and a few around them) instead of the whole drive, but its doing the same thing.

The blanket recommendation is still to fio the entire drive for good measure (as per Wendell himself), then doing an extended offline test.

I replace any and all drives with non-zero reallocated sector, pending sector or offline uncorrectable counts as well as any non-zero “elements in grown defect list” for SAS drives.

In my experience, as soon as you start seeing any reallocated sectors at all, it is only a matter of time before they start growing exponentially, and the drive drops out of the storage pool and loses data.