Tiny Mini Micro Addiction Support

I have a condition, and the only cure is more mini PC’s it seems. The idea of buying new things is foreign to me so mostly older hardware in my stable. I have two NUC’s(one 8 and one 6) that are homelab workhorses, a pair of m715q lenovos that are in service as HTPC’s running cachy and a few itx industrial mobo and cpu’s that have I7 9700E in them that are currently not in service although highly capable. The question I have offer up for open debate is should I liquidate and consolidate to some better equipment? Or hold my hardware and wait for the deflation or extinction event? Reason for considering is power consumption. My local power company is exercising it’s clout as a monopoly very strongly, and the power bill is making my eyes water from how bad it is. There are several other appliances I could also optimize as far as updating, but since tinkering with homelab is stress relieving and used computers is something I actually enjoy shopping for, this is what I have decided to fixate on for now since shopping for anything is generally depressing due to prices inflating. At least I get the dopamine hit from looking at computer parts to offset the level of woe is how it’s going out there. For additional context most of these computers I have either bartered for or were purchased pre hardware apocalypse so they do hold significantly more value on the used market than what I paid for them(although that is a net negative effect due to the replacement costs). I have been eyeballing some n150 machines for replacements for my pair of nucs, and thunderbolt for me is sadly non negotiable as a must have since I like having capability to link up external gpu’s for llm playtime. Occulink is also a suitable alternative but seems to have fallen out of fashion. No wrong answers here, but would like to get some outside opinions on my conundrum and/or fuel to the PC addiction in these trying times.

1 Like

Everyone’s situation is different and unique, so take this with a grain of salt. I find many homelabs full of overkill power hungry hardware. My power is apparently some of the cheapest in the country and yet I cringe at the 220W my lab pulls from the wall. Mini PCs for me have been a saving grace. I have a ton of lightweight services so they provide an easy way to distribute work among many units, with great redundancy. Attached picture is my K3S cluster of NUCs as proof. Two 6th gen, 5 8th gen, and cheap to replace if needed.

And power stats, even running K3s, while they pull more power than just ubuntu with docker, its still a very small amount:

Sorry to fuel your addiction, but I too love small, intelligently designed compute units with easily serviced hardware and stellar reliability. Can’t beat it.

1 Like

Those are some very impressive power numbers! Do you ever think about moving to anything more modern? The NUC to me feels like an ideal fit and have almost zero complaints. It should be heavily implied from my original post that I am not looking at ddr5 ATM, but the N150 seems to be somewhat compelling as an alternative for my use case as a proxmox machine with a couple vm’s and lxc’s. I also am guilty of having too many plates spinning in my life in general to fully test my itx mobo (and print a little case for it) to evaluate that machines power consumption, it may be that I already have what I desire but just lack the time to migrate my VMs and services. Sigh, maybe I should stop shopping and start building at least one of those :smile:

For $50-100 you can get a half decent matx or itx case from Newegg (shipped by Newegg). Or similar from Microcenter.

That will also let you have a non-eGPU setup that should be more stable and perform better for local AI tinkering.

1 Like

I hear that and totally would grab one, but have something specific in mind for this. The mobo is a bit of an odd ball as it can run on the same 19v external power supply as a nuc. It does have a pcie slot but isn’t really suited for a GPU. I want to design and print a case that is small enough to just fit the mobo, CPU cooler, and a pair of 40 or 60mm fans at the front to make it tiny. Yes I have problem, and yes it is crippling to be that particular about how I want it. I have put it on my test stand already though and did do some overall function testing. I should set that up next weekend and run some power draw numbers with an actual os install :thinking: Before going into the effort of making it what I want though.

Not really. I have redundancy, plenty of compute, scalability, and easy replacement. Newer hardware is more expense for no gain except potentially minimal power savings.

1 Like

I’m in the hold camp too. Two of my always-on servers are old GeoVision NVRs I repurposed with plain Ubuntu Server, and a Dell OptiPlex handles my dev work, so older hardware doing real jobs is most of my lab. Before selling anything, I’d put a plug-in power meter on each box for a week of normal load and let the numbers pick what goes. You might find one or two units account for most of the bill, and retiring just those gets you most of the savings without a full migration.

1 Like