I wanted to discuss the following story:
Needless to say I don’t agree with the author’s conclusions. Reddit is home to a fair bit of very niche information which is not really available elsewhere. There is a ton of useful info for homelabbers on there, for example. Reddit knows this, it’s one of the few things that makes their website remotely valuable.
I and many other people don’t actively participate on Reddit but do often find myself linked to the website in SERPs. Often it’s the only place I can find descriptions of a particular issue I’m facing with a piece of software.
But for a long time the general bent of the last bastions of “social media” that I find useful: namely Wikipedia and Reddit, has been tending toward very anti-user modalities. For years you have been largely unable to participate on Reddit proper until you have “accumulated sufficient karma” which leads to an obvious chicken-egg problem and promotes low quality posting. Then, if you participate in the wrong subreddits your account can be banned by super moderators who control the largest subreddits on the site. Oh, and technically once you are permabanned that is it- for life! Good luck appealing to Reddit management about your local subreddit’s tyrannical group of moderators.
English Wikipedia has become a hotly guarded hell-hole of shockingly biased information, whose overwhelming bureaucracy and strict adherence to “Wikipedia is not a democracy” ethos that has largely resulted in a very hostile environment for drive-by or casual editors. Consequently, driven by the insular nature of editing, the quality and reputation of English Wiki has suffered deeply. It also becomes pretty clear reading public discussions by admins that Wiki moderation and administrators are a relatively small (incestuous) group, often to the detriment of the massive Wiki bureaucracy itself.
This all leads me to question: what is the fucking point of these websites if not the users? Wikipedia is supposed to be a community created encyclopedia, but it’s become more of an encyclopedia of an elite group of users who have all day to defend their pet project and engage in endless bureaucratic melodrama.
So too with Reddit: who wants to participate in a community which encourages botting and actively obscures account history to prevent the discovery of bots.
We know that Wiki and Reddit are both likely in training datasets for AI. Why should I even bother visiting these websites anymore when Google will regurgitate what little useful information they contain for me.
/rant