The internet is becoming hostile to users

I wanted to discuss the following story:

[credit]

Needless to say I don’t agree with the author’s conclusions. Reddit is home to a fair bit of very niche information which is not really available elsewhere. There is a ton of useful info for homelabbers on there, for example. Reddit knows this, it’s one of the few things that makes their website remotely valuable.

I and many other people don’t actively participate on Reddit but do often find myself linked to the website in SERPs. Often it’s the only place I can find descriptions of a particular issue I’m facing with a piece of software.

But for a long time the general bent of the last bastions of “social media” that I find useful: namely Wikipedia and Reddit, has been tending toward very anti-user modalities. For years you have been largely unable to participate on Reddit proper until you have “accumulated sufficient karma” which leads to an obvious chicken-egg problem and promotes low quality posting. Then, if you participate in the wrong subreddits your account can be banned by super moderators who control the largest subreddits on the site. Oh, and technically once you are permabanned that is it- for life! Good luck appealing to Reddit management about your local subreddit’s tyrannical group of moderators.

English Wikipedia has become a hotly guarded hell-hole of shockingly biased information, whose overwhelming bureaucracy and strict adherence to “Wikipedia is not a democracy” ethos that has largely resulted in a very hostile environment for drive-by or casual editors. Consequently, driven by the insular nature of editing, the quality and reputation of English Wiki has suffered deeply. It also becomes pretty clear reading public discussions by admins that Wiki moderation and administrators are a relatively small (incestuous) group, often to the detriment of the massive Wiki bureaucracy itself.

This all leads me to question: what is the fucking point of these websites if not the users? Wikipedia is supposed to be a community created encyclopedia, but it’s become more of an encyclopedia of an elite group of users who have all day to defend their pet project and engage in endless bureaucratic melodrama.

So too with Reddit: who wants to participate in a community which encourages botting and actively obscures account history to prevent the discovery of bots.

We know that Wiki and Reddit are both likely in training datasets for AI. Why should I even bother visiting these websites anymore when Google will regurgitate what little useful information they contain for me.

/rant

7 Likes

Same thing for the stackoverflow stackexchange etc similar question answer websites, albeit it happened earlier. Overrun by bitter jannies and user interaction took a nosedive

6 Likes

I read a piece yesterday (called The Boring Internet) which says that this hostility isn’t the whole internet / the whole internet isn’t dying, just the thin layer that’s commercially-focused is becoming a dead crust. The social connections you forge (eg here, not Reddit) and the information shared in communities will persist but in another form.

Maybe new money will fund another layer of varnish on top of the internet and we’ll go round the loop again, maybe we’ll learn to make sustainable communities and knowledge-sharing systems.

3 Likes

I think that’s a bit harsh. You’ve missed some things when describing Wikipedia - it’s supposed to be accurate, neutral and reflect mainstream knowledge.

I know a few Wikipedians. They spend a lot of time dealing with idiots who are editing pages in ways that go against those goals.

The obvious high-profile example would be asshats who keep trying to amend the Apollo 11 page to say that the moon landing was faked, because they heard some blazed up nutjob on Joe Rogan’s podcast tell them that. But this happens on more pages than you’d think.

I’m no Wikipedian but I have edited a few pages every now and again, probably starting with a revert to some vandalism on the Pot Noodle page that I happened to see whilst looking for something else. Who the hell is vandalising a page about Pot Noodles? And yet people do, especially when given the cloak of anonymity.

Every community needs rules, even anarchic ones. The L1 Forums have their rules, Wikipedia have theirs. I don’t view the folks who freely give their time to the Wikipedia community to enforce those rules as “elites”, especially not when anyone can join them if they want to!

All of which is a long way around of saying that I disagree with your observation on Wikipedia, it seems off to me.

I can see why Reddit became popular - low barrier to entry, relying on the “wisdom of crowds”, minimal moderation.

But for me that’s also why it failed. I spent some time looking at an issue yesterday with ODBC drivers and Kerberos authentication, and every Reddit post I got pointed to was garbage. But on other occasions the content I got from Reddit was pure gold.

In that regard Reddit is the opposite of Wikipedia, which demands references and a certain presentation style. If I land on a Reddit post that has replies which are linking to references and resources, I know I’m golden. If there’s no links and just crudely written opinion, I may as well go look for answers in my bins…

I got into Reddit towards the end of its golden period, just in time to watch it fall from grace and usefulness. Such a shame, and something of a personal regret that I never made time to participate during the good years.

Now I do find this interesting. Your summary is rather… extractive. It’s all about what these websites can give you.

I’m reminded of that great quote:

“Ask not what your internet can do for you, but what you can do for your internet” - Some asshat vandalising Wikipedia’s Apollo 11 page (probably)

I’m enjoying the L1 Forums because people here seem to want to help within the community. If Wikipedia or Reddit don’t float your boat, that’s fine. Other communities are available. :wink:

Communities are what we make of them. Tools like AI can only go so far because they’re extractive. Eventually their exclusive use will lead you to an “AI dustbowl” in which nothing grows, and you have no choice but to leave them behind for tools that encourage participation.

Hence this. gestures all around at the L1 Forums

6 Likes

Perhaps replace “The internet” With reddit or similar social medias. The internet itself is as generic as it ever was. If were talking about the whole picture here.

Will probably get even worse and worse, thanks to the “Moderation” we so so, need so much more of, lol. Thanks to places like Reddit. Where only a few non-generic topics actually get through, rest of the 80+% is so heavily moderated, that it looks more and more like a political party that is running the entire platform itself. Instead of 0 politics sites, there is still moderation and that can be easily influenced, by heavily invested moderators, in staying or forcing their political views, by entirely removing input (Even if the stuff is 100% non-political) Which they already do, because an actual human internet, scares the crap out-of-the-system.

Those kind of platforms will make sure, that genuine human input that do require a lot of attention and urgency, will never get what they deserve. In the name of “moderation”, the typical internet is already proof-enough of this (If not, spend more time on the internet, then youll see)

We will never get a really free internet, even if its just text based.

2 Likes

That’s because they are so actively hostile to new users, why should I “vote with my wallet” (although there are no ads on Wiki) for websites that don’t want me there?

Although that is ultimately the premise of all media. It’s about eyeballs. Particularly for user generated content… Nobody is going to participate in a vacuum!

2 Likes

Isnt that the point of them? Especially wikipedia. I dont go there to wrestle the jannies in the talk section, its supposed to be an encyclopedia. Its expected that most people will just use it, and if they find it useful enough, might start contributing.

For reddit, in the more technical subs, its also similarly transactional, you go there to find answers since most other ol forums got nuked. If it is useful enough you can even hang around and participate.

2 Likes

This is imho the crux of the problem. The moderators are usually volunteers, which often favors activists or people with vested interests in pushing a Message. This is most obvious on reddit but is happening on wikipedia as well to a lesser extent.

Everybody wants jannies but nobody wants to pay them, thats how we got here

2 Likes

TLDR; Deleted Reddit answers are the best that exists on the platform (Wonder why, lol not really)

Activists or not, they know what they are doing. Its all by design, same generic garbage “Moderation” again and again. Its basically moderation-slop whats going on and its not going to end. Itll stay the same, volunteer, payed or not. Doesnt matter, because it isnt the point of it.

Fun-Fact: The moderation is about the same as it ever was. So much for awesome-volunteer work huh?

Its definetly not user-flaws of awesome volunteers, i can assure you that. Lemmy is actively trying to combat what Reddit re-presents, but more and more of it is actually instead turning into Reddit more and more.

They just “Pretend” its not… There is about half the hate on Lemmy that there is on Reddit. Thats mostly the only difference. Otherwise its exactly the same… And that was supposed to be a real, totally different yet the-same-kind-of-alternative…

Its embarrasing being part of the internet, when people have political agendas or are politically invested, more and more people are not and are not interested. Yet none of the platforms conforms to that, its the new norm. Has been for a long time, yet you dont see any platforms conform to that, because real users would be flooding that kind of platform. Instead whats pushed it more meaningless-senseless text-based information that dont solve any remotely real problems and definetly also dont lead anywhere, remotely useful. Instead most if not 90% of topics looks like user-generated slop, with no useful information.

All the useful users “funnily enough” Instead rather delete-themselves, than to be part of where platforms like Reddit are going. Thats why you often see the top,best comment on the site, was a deleted answer.

1 Like

It’s a problem that is almost as old as the commercial internet itself. Corporations want to be able to steer the narrative. It already started with IE 4.0 and Active Desktop, which was Microsoft’s contribution to the effort of the tech companies to drive people towards “push content”. And while the initial initiatives failed, the goals were ultimately met through the development of the Web 2.0 feeds we have today, which serve to promote UGC to support certain narratives, as is very obvious with Wikipedia and YT. I wouldn’t be surprised if some of the supermods are part of an astroturfing collective, as when I still had a reddit account, I had my share of run ins with some of them a couple of times and their behaviour is almost predictably moronic and ideologically motivated.
Outside of the narrative laden tracks you can still find the non-push content without too much trouble. The thing you’re complaining about in regard to faulty information being promoted is that search engines are not good at filtering information for truth and sometimes idiots get to have the biggest say.

The only solution is to vote with your feet and create your own enclave of people who value true freedom over convenience, yet without enforcing ideological boundaries, as this would create a monoculture.

2 Likes

Well they hit the nail-on-the-head with push content, why? Well mentally challenged people will greatly use and outway that specific platform. They already did and do.

While minorities, like those damaged in one way or another by heavy computer usage, only have a few braincells left, and push content doesnt seem to always outway the damage of getting as specialized as one is, by all the damage. They only have a few, braincells left to give out of. So push content shouldnt be hated as much as it likely is by many specialists :stuck_out_tongue:

1 Like

I agree with the commercial focus, reddit’s ownership began chasing the money at the expense of the platform and Reddit quickly began to deteriorate after that. Rules then changed to appease the hands holding the money, mods were fired en mass and replaced to enforce the changes. So much of the world has become profit-first or profit-driven and that is showing up on the internet too.

I don’t agree with the notion the internet’s the same as ever. It’s worse, and continuing to get worse. It feels like the internet has gone from 1800’s wide open prairies where anything could be found or exist or started up, to 1900’s industrial revolution with the big barons owning massive factories of pithy wage employees and lots of land. There’s what, three distinct search engines left, five if we count state-run Baidu and Yandex? And the biggest still return identical results with AI-infused trash anyway? The internet has (and continues to) become significantly more narrow than it used to be.

Distinct stores and outlets that focused on specific niches are gone, 25 years ago there used to be dozens of well known websites selling computer hardware, today it’s Amazon, B&H Photo, and Newegg. And the quality/reliability of ordering from Amazon/Newegg went into the toilet since it’s nearly all third party sellers on them both. Even for watercooling gear more stores existed than I had fingers, now there’s what, two in the US that aren’t Amazon or a direct manufacturer? Sidewinder’s owner blamed Google SEO for its demise. Who remembers Jab-tech, or ZipZoomFly anymore?

it seems like sites that were focused on specific knowledge and expertise are vanishing at a much faster rate than new ones are being created. All the knowledge and expertise of Anandtech, The Tech Report, and a dozen other tech websites are entirely gone. Or requires so much effort to find again that 90% of people won’t even try. New content to replace it is only being generated in video form, not easy-to-find or searchable text paired to dedicated images of spec sheets and diagrams.

I’d argue real, deep analysis and critical expertise isn’t even being replaced in video format. What’s being generated is more closely related to marketing than any sort of actual deep analysis or testing. Who does real deep analysis of motherboards anymore? It’s all unboxing videos and specification regurgitation. These days you have to watch a Wendell video to find out the real information regarding enthusiast/prosumer boards for threadipper or HEDT platforms, and usually that happens after he discovers a myriad of problems with it that would’ve put off buyers had they known. Maybe Buildzoid randomly performs a deep analysis of a random motherboard’s trace design, build quality, and overclockability for fun, but those are rare one-offs. HUB does a very late, massive chipset-wide VRM benchmarking roundup, but that’s nearly it there. Even the HUB video that compared all four motherboard brand’s handling of DDR5 subtimings with the default/moderate/aggressive preset options was novel simply because I never saw anyone else even cover that content.

Yes forums like L1T exist, but how many forums no longer exist now? Of those that still exist how many of the old ones are ghost towns? Many simply got nuked when the accompanying website vanished, others slipped away quietly into the night like Tech Report’s forum.

Could even get into the whole news reporting thing, but that’s as much a symptom as the massive number of industry mergers and decreasing profitability as everything else. But today almost any news website has a commercially motivated paywall of some sort or another. Practically any website that focuses on a specific niche topic now requires a signup and giving personal information just to read free content. So yes there’s a strong commercial focus, and it’s worsening the internet as a whole.

The internet itself is being gatekept behind two search engines that all the rest pull their data from. Even Chrome locked down its browser to the point that I’m astonished exe launcher flags to retain Manifestv2 extension functionality even still work, I don’t expect it to work for much longer. So the number of places to find deep, investigative analysis of computer hardware have decreased. The number of associated websites and forums with similar knowledge have decreased. The number of websites simply to buy hardware, or even non-hardware things has decreased. It’s been done for years that big name websites like facebook and youtube that work perfectly fine in desktop view require mobile users to install dedicated apps and block direct browsing. Installed apps can see other installed apps and directly monetize your personal data, so the motivation is purely commercial. Enshittification of the internet is real, and it’s been slowly happening for decades.

5 Likes

After some reading of that input. guidelines came straight to my mind, they (Moderators) Just almost have to be getting some sort of guidelines, to make it actively worse. I dont see it happening naturally at all… Also reddit was pro-profit even before the takeover, to think it was not is an oxymoron. The takeover just, made it so much more obvious, thats all really…

Your input reminds me of Google, the search engine that back in the day found the EXACT site you wanted when you typed something in, ON THE SPOT, it was internet-search perfected, basically. Now it just finds something in its own walled garden, mostly (Meanwhile chewing on smaller sites, to oblivious recognition, if any at all) Go Ladybird right?

There is the KAGI, which pays google to de-bloat its own search engine. (They pay google to de-bloat results while still paying them for it) So Google is clearly at blame here. They are a walled garden similar to APPLE,GOOGLE and other brands. Its basically became a BRAND, rather than a search engine. So theyve added all that extra bloat to what it was supposed to do, at very heavy user expense, which they dont care about.

Just look at YouTube, which is also like a brand, It doesnt care if you upload 8K, 16K or even 32K footage, which natively is impossible but still, the results would stay the same, because its about algorhitmic popularity than quality. No matter how insane will mostly stay the same with what their “guidelines” deem to be accceptable and whats “supposed” to be popular.

1 Like

Reddit back in the day (<2016) used to be a really great place for niche communities.

I could see the internet moving back to this in a way. Smaller communities, similar to how things were before social media platforms destroyed most forums.

Here’s hoping.

3 Likes

I feel this is a not just a hopeful but also likely outcome.

2 Likes