SystemD adds Age Verification & r/linux bans those talking about it

Yeah I agree. I don’t feel that companies so much as donated to the Trump campaign because they wanted him to win, but because they thought he would win. For others, such as Elon Musk and Larry Ellison, I am not so sure that that holds true, but I don’t know either.

Well if the American newsmedia prior to the latest Paramount thing is to be believed, Larry and Trump are good friends and worth noting many of the media properties the Ellisons have purchased have softened considerably in their coverage of the admin. Anyway, kind of off-topic.

The point that companies will comply to continue doing business especially in California is well taken.

Compile from source and patch it out instead

4 Likes

Yep. Came here to post this.

Anyone here caught engaging in or advocating for the sort of behavior this developer is reporting will no longer be welcome on the forum.

The guy had a very good argument for why he created the PR, and at the end of the day, as much as y’all don’t like it, you don’t get year of the Linux desktop without systemd-censord at this point.

I’m sure there will be patches designed to bypass these features in the near future, and because it’s open source, nobody can stop you from implementing it.


RE: discussion of corporate-government ties:

While it’s semi-relevant to the current situation, let’s please try to keep it strictly on-topic. While we technically have a rule against politics, I’m inclined to allow it so long as it’s strictly relevant to the age-verification stuff, because we’re discussing government policy impacting our hobby and tools.

6 Likes

That kind of open minded thinking and willingness to engage all sides is making this forum what it is today. Keep up the good work.

Wow this is crazy wtf. Doxxing and harassing an open source contributor for complying with legislation is not cool.

1 Like

sad to hear that this guy is doxxed now. submitting his personal datas to harm him is way above any civil mannor.

there’s one thing annoying me in this discussion all over (this place is not the only one). everybody is pi$$ed on this law and i agree, but what has the whole community ever done to be active in child-protection? i’m not a father (and i’m certain lots here aren’t too), but try to get some sense into a parent that is forced to hand over an access to the internet because this whole society believes that even a child needs access nowadays. that’s a simple fact. i can remember the hanna-montana distro years ago, the whole linux-community made a laugh about it without knowing that the developer created a distro for his girl, aged 6-years. this guy made a lot of work into a distro that fits the needs for such a young child and he has my respect. i also respect the work that biglinux is spending actually to this topic to create a user-friendly installation-process where parents can create a safer account for their childs. that’s real child-protection. this topic should be used for all distro-maintainers to think about. it’s a great opportunity and marketing-chance to create and promote linux as a system that can be used from the parents to gain a safer access for their childs. linux has already everything under the hood to implement it easy. and always remember every linux-noob-child from today will be a linux-power-user in the future. don’t hand the childs over to microsoft and apple. they are too worthy to end as dumb consumers of products that harm them.

The doxxing is unfortunate and the mob has a poor track record with facts. But the idea that FOSS folks are “just developers” is naive at best. It’s like they have no idea how government agencies work.

Yes, I always advocate people take care of their own children. You can’t have this responsibility outsourced to the gubbermint or to corporations or anyone else. And just because one is too ashamed to talk to his kids about naughty things and explain to them like they would to an adult, that doesn’t mean one should turn a blind eye when that happens and especially shouldn’t shift the burden to someone else.

off-topic and very political

The reason the whole world is p*ssed right now is because politicians are not letting a good crisis go to waste and exploiting the crap out of it. The reason this is a thing is because people digitally neglect their kids (and not just that, but simply don’t take parenting seriously - instead of spending time with their kids, they just hand them a tablet connected to the internet and call it a day).

The internet is a place created by adults, mostly for adults (the old saying “the internet is for p*rn” has more than just the obvious meaning). What would you think would happen when you leave kids online without supervision? The same thing would happen if you let your kids hang out with people in gangs: they get corrupted (sure, some may be smart enough to not fall for that, but don’t expect most to do that).

Kids are information sponges, they just absorb whatever is around them. If they are surrounded by gang activity, like intimidation, alcohol and drugs, then they won’t know any better, they’ll just fall under peer-pressure and do what others do. The internet is the same. Don’t let your kids unsupervised on the internet (or do and face the consequences - it’s your kid). Yes, obviously some kids can be trusted with being online after a period, especially if you know one has a tight bond with his kids and the kids come to their parents to ask things they see. Again, that’s few and far between, but it’s a parent’s responsibility.

That doesn’t mean we need some complete asinine legislative fiat that does a lot of harm to the whole world. And nobody’s asking why are all these laws coming out / getting proposed in so many places, at such a high pace? Something is going on. People claim faceberg is behind the lobbying behind all the bills introduced in the US, in order to help meta avoid the costs and penalties related to identifying children and bypass laws mandating no information be collected on kids. This move would make a lot of sense in that case, because they stand to benefit. I can’t say either way, I didn’t do any investigation myself on that, so take that with a grain of salt.

This is to every user’s detriment (of any OS). Now everyone in the world has been burdened with adding information about their age in the OS they use and have been forced to provide their age to every program they use. And every software developer now has been forced to add additional code or face penalties. And some states and countries may not have just age attestation, but require complete age verification (I think Colorado has that).

The whole thing is a mess and it’s just because politicians are just wanna-be tyrants. They want to dictate how your life should be and you must obey… or else!

5 Likes

Achieving the FSF’s vision of computing where the user is control, is the greatest gift this parent could ask of the community.

This is an interesting comment from another community:

The framing is - in my opinion - merely a
rhetorical device used such that anyone forced to take an opposing
view can be framed as some bumpkin who is against the “children”; it
is irresponsible of policy makers. At the risk of showing off my
tinfoil-hat; It seems to me there are forces at work that align with
large data-hungry incumbents,
– 'Re: URGENT: Age Verification Laws' - MARC

2 Likes

Disclaimer - I don’t know the average age! (pun so intended!) of the users here, but I remember Microslop modus operandi since Windows 98. It was Embrace, Extend, Extinguish, and today it’s a war-cry of all corporate entities. From first-hand, decade long experience in European automotive industry - oh, it’s still that and worse.

Second: No one should engage in the reported behavior. I think that we can all agree on that here.

That being said…

The PR this guy made was going to be unpopular and hated - that was obvious to anyone with even a single brain cell let alone to a senior dev, I can’t for the life of me accept that anyone would be so clueless to expect a pat on the shoulder for this. I can bet, and heavily at that, that there are thousands! better and more experienced devs who were entertaining the idea of how they would approach this particular problem/solution because that’s how their brains work, but haven’t thought of even touching the keyboard before somebody asked them to.

All this person had to do was - nothing! If you disagree with the proposed laws as you state, and the idea itself - all you had to do was stop, until somebody asks you to do something. In writing!

A couple of facts:

  • SystemD is also an open source project, yet majority of leads and devs are from Red Hat (IBM) and Microslop.
  • The wish of the community was NOT to implement this, but the discussion was swiftly stopped.
  • A Microslop employee and lead dev merged the PR into the equivalent of svchost.exe present in 90% of the Linux distros.
  • Pottyring is only accidentally leaving M$ and starting a startup for ‘cryptographically verifiable integrity’. That field will only accidentally be useful to verify the device owners age in a secure, safe and immutable way as well. Of course, if he makes some profit out of it, that’s just a happy accident.

… And we are all born yesterday.

Tinfoil hat hypothesis:
What if none of this hasn’t actually happened? None of the reported behavior?

We have communities all over now switching the narrative and the topic of conversation (if one is allowed, because god forbid we have ‘heated conversations’) from ‘we don’t want this crap inside our OS’ to signaling about the behavior and defending the victim. Because we have nothing better and more constructive to talk about.

Now, if I was entertaining an idea about how I would begin a psyop - this would probably be one of my scenarios. In this age - of fabricated narratives, generative models and who knows what else - the thought of this guy not even existing is not really that far fetched to me. If Meta spends billions on lobbying for all these laws (and who knows who else is as well) - how much extra would it cost to create a guy out of thin air? 100k if even that?

So we come to a situation of turning the conversation onto ourselves, defending the victim, debating if he deserves it or not, and then we naturally come to ‘moderating’ conversations all over and locking discussions. Arch calling ‘breaking CoC’ for expressing your stance? Pottyring saying ‘not interested in these discussions, not a place for them’ - yeah, where exactly is that holy place for debate, discussions, expressing a clear ‘NO’ - the F in FOSS is disappearing more and more and somehow everyone is OK with it…

So the so called discussions are happening, but are actually not - because it’s polarizing, because leading and moderating proper discussions is hard, because the decisions are already made, and this is just for show - to show that ‘we really tried to have a discussion, to give the community a chance to vote, but unfortunately it got out of hand, mums were mentioned and we just had to stop it’.

As to the @SgtAwesomesauce

I’m sure there will be patches designed to bypass these features in the near future, and because it’s open source, nobody can stop you from implementing it.

This is a false choice at best.

  • If the services you need decline your device because your OS is patched - that’s not much of a choice.
  • If I am against this, and I don’t have the means to create or implement it - and even if did → see the above.

In short - asking the user for DoB is step one to getting people accept it. After that they’ll (rightly so) point out that people were lying, and they’ll need our government ID to verify (and link us to activity). The plumbing is already in place, infrastructure set - they just need a good reason and the right timing.

8 Likes

This has nothing to do with kids. Any of us with any age or gray hair can attest that we have seen porn at a young age I would wager. These people are just not interested in protecting kids, that has zero to do with this stuff. It’s about control, this is just the beginning, we all know this. This is about removing anonymity from the Internet, and then punishing those who are deemed to be dissidents or guilty of wrong think in a myriad of ways you will not be able to even identify because you will be at an information disadvantage. Why were you sued? Why were you audited? Why were you denied a job? You will have no idea, but those who monitor the Internet will know and they will see what you do.

It is absolutely imperative, if the Internet is to be anything other than the greatest tool of tyranny ever known to mankind, that people oppose this as forcefully as they can. A minority applying patches is not going to undo the closing down of the hard fought values of western society purchased at so great a price by the best among us for the last few centuries. Now is the time, it’s an important time, and this should not be minimized. The idea that the pendulum swings is inaccurate. It will stop swinging, so get it right.

7 Likes

What services?

I’m gonna be real, for the services I actually need in my life, they either already know all my PII (banking services, etc…), or they won’t ever ask that stuff.

Anything else, I believe it will probably be a benefit to cut out of my life. Uncle Ted intensifies

2 Likes

Getting news is not anything you need? Being educated on accurate information in order to vote? Communicating with your countrymen about how to protest and sharing accurate information that isn’t approved not something you need in your life? Having journalists provide you with accurate information, is that not something you need? When the majority of Americans get their info from the Internet, but you’re limited to talking to people at a coffee shop based on your heavily curtailed information flow with which to influence the thinking of one or two neighbors, is that going to counteract what is happening?

You may not think you need more than banking apps, but you do, whether you realize it or not. Downplay for civility at your own peril and the peril of everybody else you know.

2 Likes

I’m not downplaying anything. I’m just giving my perspective.

3 Likes

Also, for what it’s worth, I really don’t think we’re going to need age verification for most of that.

I can tell you right now that I’m not going to need age verification for the communications I prioritize. News will always be available as well, for what little value “journalists” have.

News will not exist always. You should see how it has devolved from partisan to what it is now. Propaganda only bolstered by some semblance of free thought from alternative platforms which are also under attack. That is not a given. And communications you prioritize may not prioritize communications that our Founders understood to be necessary for society at large to prevent authoritarianism. You may be able to leverage some technology to talk with a couple of people online free of repercussion, exercising your First Amendment rights freely. But that won’t save you when others who turn wrenches or plow fields are unable to do the same. This isn’t just about you. In fact, you’re just a small part of it. It’s about us. Although you will be affected nonetheless.

I would submit that one of the reasons we are in the incredibly bad state we are in, is that most people have a perspective that does not apply to their country or others. It’s more of a “how will this affect me” perspective and it’s natural and it’s understandable. But it’s absolutely destroying us.

If we are older and have no kids and we only have cats, that’s perhaps a safe play although I think we’re tempted to think we have more time than we do before it gets into the inevitable nightmare. As in, actual nightmare. We should take note of how quickly the insanity is advancing and consider Moore’s Law and if it means anything to that timeline.

My perspective as an American, and I hope your generosity with politics posted above allows, is that I was lucky to be born into an imperfect nation that was a thunder strike in human history with our understanding of liberty, not the result of a debate but the result of a rare confluence of factors preceded by a staggering amount of raw human nature and a history of suffering before those in power, the natural state of affairs (this change only made possible by the technology of the time that gave the people parity with the printing press and firearms, something that has changed massively today and that point should stand out in my rambling here because it’s absolutely vital to the point I’m making). America’s founding split time, imperfect as it was. It was more perfected by abolitionists who risked everything, then further perfected by Wobblies and other organizations whose politics were different than mine but who essentially had the same love of liberty and sacrificed greatly, followed by Dr. King and Malcolm and JFK and RFK and many other imperfect Americans who crafted near perfection as relates to this whole mess of society and government. And now we’re at a crossroads where we can let it all be destroyed and lost forever if we’re not willing to inconvenience ourselves the tiniest fraction of a fraction of a fraction that others endured to get us here. This isn’t a small thing. It’s everything. It’s everything because human nature has not changed, but technology has. Give technology to do harm to a few at the expense of the masses and you WILL get mass suffering. Look at how technology is being taken out of the hand of the many and given to the few in control. Just as it was when Lords in Castle Walls inflicted upon peasants whatever they wished, except it’s on steroids now. This discussion is an important part of that and it should be concerning, but only if our perspective exists for those outside ourselves.

For those who think I’m hyperbolic, consider Sophie Scholl. Pamphlets. This is not a road any want to travel especially if they have kids they care about, or if they have any feeling of duty to give back for the blessings they have received by luck of the lottery of birth to have been born in America and enjoyed the fruits of those who gave everything to get us here.

1 Like

Someone took the idea of sixos and ran with it further

Apparently it uses finit instead of systemd
http://troglobit.github.io/finit/
I found it from the discussion on the NixOS forum

Also found the Individual talk too

It’s a blessing in disguise that systemd complied because I probably would not have looked into more modular configurations

Some other interesting threads

2 Likes

I’m curious to know which database exists at the federal level that this data could be checked against. Does the US digitize all birth records? How far back does that practice extend? How are operating systems going to interact with these databases? There must then be a public api somewhere.

crazy how in free software you can fork software and remove the age verification. its almost like this is not an issue.

edit:
also not surprised reddit has always been horrible

3 Likes