Looking to do a Steam Machine build; Level1 was about the only place I thought might have an idea on the below question around CPU’s.
I already happened to have 16gb DDR4 (2x8gb, 3600mhz) ram which given the joys of AI shortages means it’ll need to be an AM4 system. I also have an Rx 9070 for the GPU.
So for Steam OS its a question of 5900x v 3900(x) v 5700x v 5700G. I only mention the 5700G because I was wondering if the frame gen plug in for lesser gpu’s available on Steam, might make the Vega iGPU worth while, or if the L3 cache only being 16mb is more of a disadvantage, especially if some of it is being utilised for graphics. Which then makes the question if the additional 64mb of L3 cache on the 5900x (and 3900x) worthwhile for having over the 32mb on the 5700x. I only mention the 3900 due to price and its L3 cache size, however IIRC it split the L3 to 4 x 16mb clusters over the ICX. Suspect that might be a disadvantaged for gaming? Think they changed the architecture between Zen 2 and Zen 3 pooling the L3 cache more, I think the 5900 is two 32mb caches?
A second question is around PCIE cables and the 9070, as personally I prefer console builds, but is it worth having a PCIE 4 or 5 cable over 3? IIRC there have been stability issues between cables or do we think thats a non issue? (I do already have a couple of PCIE 3 cables that could possibly do the job).
Id go with the 5900X if you plan to do a RAM upgrade to 24-32GB in like a year or two and keep this machine/console in use for 4-5 years. If you plan to only use it for a year or two and then dump it then go with a lesser CPU that doesnt have as many cores. So if you are planning no upgrades to this at all then a 5700x would be the way I would go. Zen3 was a nice IPC upgrade to Zen2+.
I built my Steam Machine a couple weeks ago. Went with a Minisforum BD790I X3D due to the vcache CPU it comes with. I used 32GB of RAM I found a “deal” on for $150, along with originally an RX 9060XT but then upgraded it to a 9070 since it is a significant jump in FPS in games between them. I honestly love the thing. Plays every game so smoothly, and I can see the CPU boosting most of its cores up around 4.5GHz and sometimes a few to 5GHz during gaming. Very good CPU for such low power. The most demanding game I have tried so far is Borderlands 4, which normally has terrible performance on every system. With my custom Steam Machine I am playing on high settings in “4k” FSR quality and getting 55-60fps at all times and if I turn frame gen on it is a 100% solid 60fps with no dips (60Hz limit from my AV receiver it runs through to TV). I used a kill-o-watt and the system is pulling around 250w maximum to achive that, so way better on power use than my main system, which gets worse performance and is drawing 600~ watts, mainly due to my older gen GPU in my main rig.
Be aware you cannot actually use SteamOS yet, it hasnt been updated to support RDNA4 GPUs. You need to use Bazzite in SteamOS mode, which is effectively the same thing but has more hardware support. You should be able to install the actual SteamOS when the real Steam machine launches as it should be updated at that point.
I would also go with a pcie4 or pcie5 riser cable since the GPU is expecting pcie5 connectivity. using a pcie3 one and limiting yourself to that in bios might cause some performance bottlenecks on the GPU.
Of those four specifically for games you want the 5700X. 3900X and 5900X both are two times 6 core CCD (I think that’s still the term). Usually you want to avoid a game to run on both of those because of latency. So one 8 core CCD is the better pick there. The 5700G does come with additional GPU cores but 1. it drops a bunch of cache compared to the 5700X and 2. those (vega aka. ancient) GPU cores would eat into your RAM and you only have 16GB to begin with.
Don’t even think about fake frames, you have a 9070.
Just put it together and have fun gaming.
Thanks both for your input. Ended up going with the 5800x (mainly as managed to get a good deal on it which was cheaper than the 5700x) so have now mostly built the system (though still waiting on the SFX PSU to arrive so currently sat on my test bench. It’s on a Gigabyte b550i itx motherboard, 16gb of ram (Corsair LPX 3600mhz 2x8), Saphire Rx 9070 Pulse, 1tb NVME SSD and a Corsair Sf750 PSU. Gonna 3d print a custom console case for it.
Based on this Arstechnica article did try stalling Steam OS, I just get a black screen when it should boot to OS having gone through installing the OS. I do have an Rx 6600 lying around so next step is installing that to see if it runs. Anyone have any suggestions? (I will go to Bazzite in the interim if needed but ideally I’d just like vanilla Steam OS). I’ve had a poke around Saphire’s website based on another thread in the level1 forums regarding hdmi firmware issues, but don’t see any firmware for the Rx 9070 on their site to be able to update it.
This is exactly what is supposed to happen when you install SteamOS with an unsupported GPU. It wont work since there is no RDNA4 support. It will work with a RX 6600. Or just install Bazzite.
It looks like the Ars Technica people manually went in and installed newer AMD GPU drivers themselves to get their 9070 working in basic SteamOS. My guess would be the process for this would involve using a compatible GPU first to get into the system, manually install compatible drivers, then swap the hardware.
Edit: Currently on the hunt for that PCIE4 riser, will be 3d printing a console style case if people are interested can update here with a progress shot once I’ve finished it.