Seagate 28TB hard drive experiences?

I noticed that Server Part Deals has the 28TB Seagate drives in stock, manufacturer recertified

Seagate Exos ST28000NM000C 28TB 7.2K RPM SATA 6Gb/s 512e CMR 3.5in Recertified Hard Drive

they were $345 USD just the other day, actually, the price just bumped up to $399 as they seemingly got more in stock

You can tell that these are the HAMR drives because it says there’s a laser in it, at the bottom of the label

I did a quick Google search on these drives before getting too excited and found surprisingly little information about them from consumers (e.g. home users) ; Google Search

there was some sentiments in the comments here suggesting that since these are HAMR drives, they would have much lower tolerance for vibrations, such as you would get from having a stack of 10 of them in a single PC tower ATX sized case, which could cause data IO errors and eventually data corruption (??)

but those comments all came from Reddit, so i was wondering if any L1T members here had any other insights?

The data sheet for these drives is here https://www.seagate.com/content/dam/seagate/assets/support/internal-hard-drives/enterprise-hard-drives/exos/_shared/files/exos-recertified-drive-DS2045-2-2010US-October-2020-en_US.pdf

( backed it up here for posterity Wayback Machine since it seems L1T forum does not allow file uploads)

What do you all think? Anyone tried these things out? Wendell???

I have a stack of 10x of the Seagate Exos 20TB drives from Server Part Deals here, in a ATX case (Fractal Define 7), I have been waiting for a significant capacity increase before upgrading, and 28TB is starting to get within range of the storage size needed before an upgrade is appealing, with the ~$350/drive price getting close to feasible as well. But I could not find a lot of reassurance that these drives wouldnt crash and burn in a home server (non-rack server) setup. Would be great to have more input from any experienced persons who have used these types of drives before.

wow just took a look and the price increase is pretty high. the entire recertified exos line were all ~12tb$/tb a few days ago and now all ~14$/tb

I was also considering these but saw the reddit posts and lack of reviews about em. They should only be a little over a year old which also made me suspicious cause as far as I could tell only became sold in volume in 2024.

the reddit posts suggest that large batches of these are sent to hyperscalers for evaluation then get returned mostly untouched, resulting in the manufacturer recertified stock. Not sure if there’s and corroborating reports of this. I only see it mentioned in reddit.

also I am guessing the price increases could be thanks to Trump tariffs? who knows

These are back to $340. Some of the other exos prices seem to have dropped down too.

Oddly enough they also sell a refurbished 28tb drive that costs more and has a lower warranty.

$310 for 26tb exos is also appealing to me.

Seems some more posts on reddit about these newer HAMR drives now and at least I haven’t seen reports of problems. Saw a post that say the startup power an these is 30W so might have to consider that if i add multiple into a system.
https://www.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/comments/1kcdp93/28tb_exos_in_consumer_nas/

I have been accumulating several of these drives and swapping them into my server, no issues so far

1 Like

Btw a quick follow up, as per the previous posts I went ahead and swapped in about six or seven of these into my system. Been running them for about six months now and not a single problem.

I guess the real issue now is that the “AI boom” has ruined the hardware prices and availability. These drives were $345 when I purchased them, now six months later they’re $470. Crazy.

I’m finally at the point of needing more space again and unfortunately the Seagate Mosaic drives aren’t available as manufacturer recertified on Server Part Deals, I ended up being forced to get the 30TB versions new from the “Seagate Store” on eBay for $680 each. Ouch

Seagate Exos M 30TB ST30000NM004K

These seem to go in and out of stock on this listing; after I bought them they went out of stock, then came back with 10 more available, now “almost gone” again.

This is the hardware purchasing landscape we’ve got to look forward to in 2026 :scream:

2 Likes

This same family of drives is what you can find in the Expansion line of external drives right now, and they can be had for close to or less than the refurbished price. I have been shucking these as fast as I can acquire them because unless the failure rate is 50% or better it’s still cheaper than paying the enterprise prices for new drives with warranties. So far they have worked out very well. But you know, sample size of one…

I have never seen external hard drives in the 28TB and 30TB sizes

how many exos out of all those have you gotten?

Zero. None of them are labeled “Exos”, but every single one has been HAMR.

so barracuda then… or at least it is on the label. I had a seagate expansion for a bit (idrive express disk to seed data to them) it was 20TB and performed more like an exos cuz the transfer rate was much higher than the barracuda of the same size. I couldn’t use qdiskinfo cuz it was blank for it, seatools just says “Seagate Expansion HDD” and I’m definitly not gonna shuck cuz the drive wasn’t mine)

I am not aware of Barracuda drives being manufactured in these sizes

I only know of Exos and IronWolf Pro being made in the 28TB+ sizes

due to economies of scale I would have to assume that an unlabeled Seagate drive of these capacities surely must be one of the two

Right, it says “barracuda 28tb” but on that same label you can clearly see, “class 1 laser product”. :joy:

which are binned HAMR drives that didn’t meet Exos standards

2 Likes

this is really surprising to me and it makes me wonder which quality standard the drives could have failed to meet to be considered “Baracuda” and not Exos

Mosaic drives are a minimum 30tb. They do not make a 28. So, I suspect based on the 32-28 drop they have a totally non functioning HAMR head. Or two or three for the 24/20tb ones.