I have used these isolations many times. I have made this electrical connection many times and they have never failed. Nobody claims that this is the standard for Eth on a daily basis but in an emergency situation when a new cable cannot be laid, OP can use such a connection.
However, if you are referring to photos with electrical insulating tape, they are not mine and they are not advice but an illustration which is to give visualizations of wire-to-wire connection for OP. Familiarize yourself with the topic and context of the conversation.
What you provided in the link is “god awful” in my opinion. I also dealt with it. I would not recommend it especially the cheapest ones. Many times they lost contact and had to be replaced. But since you like them …
I worked in telecom for a few years and the ones I linked can carry a signal with over 50+ splices for a mile with no loss. If you look at the post I replied to it was very clearly the one with electrical tape.
I worked for ISP for quite a few years. We put networks based on cat on a daily basis in various places. All buildings. Air connections as well as between buildings.
Maybe you had good luck with them. I had to replace them more than once. 50+ for a 100/250Mhz signal?
Personally, I prefer soldered connections. From experience, my statistics simply speak for such a combination. I don’t trust anything that clenches. Too much risk that problems arise. But it’s a matter of individual approach and preferences.
But we depart from the case … OP does not make uplink between the USA and EU just wants to put rj45 on a thin cable.
As for quoting, for some reason a whole tree of posts appeared to me. So it was hard to guess which post is cited. But rather it should be obvious that such a twisted wire and tape is not a good solution and it is only a visualization for something else.
And there are several effective ways to connect wire … Many roads lead to Rome.
Soldered can be better, but for most people simple beanies are more than good enough. And I have had to replace tons of them as well and never due to a faulty one, just user error. Pairs not all the way in, not compressed all the way. Shit like that.
The user … One of the reasons why I prefer solder connections and those that also have stress relief points.
I have dealt with a mass of situations. Dogs, Cats, Children, Drunken idiots … There is a saying “idiot resistant solution”. Very often, this average user is the cause of the problem that I need to solve / repair after him. For this I prefer to use an armored solution than to do something twice.