Quiet cooling for Asrock TRX50 WS with Threadripper 7960X?

Currently I have the 92mm Noctua NH-D9 TR5-SP6, this is fine till I start a windows VM and then I can hear the fans get quite loud. I was thinking of the Noctua NH-U14S TR5-SP6 as I had a version of this on my previous machine and it was very quiet. However on this current motherboard it would be in a vertical orientation and I am wondering what experience other have had with this?

I have looked at AIO for this cpu but when I read the specs for the Silverstone SST-XE360-TR5 here:

https://www.silverstonetek.com/en/product/info/coolers/xe360_tr5/

you see the noise level quoted as 46 dBA, which strikes me as quite loud:) And that AIO is supposed to be a good one for this socket since the water block covers the whole area of the cpu.

I have no interest in learning to make custom loops, either a quiet AIO or air cooler for me!

What is the CPU heatsink clearance limit of your case?

So you have an 350W CPU and noting a slight fan ramp up / 46 dB spec? :wink:

FYI, I recall the sTR4 version of that cooler having a max wattage of 280 Watts (no overclocking!). Same cooler as your sTR5, just they installed faster (louder?) fans for the higher wattage.

The only answer to your question is overcooling - to where the system at idle fans has enough reserve to remove greater-than-a-large-GPU amount of heat.

For that, you’re looking at water-cooling with 360 or 420 heat exchangers (100W per 120² fan basic rule too cool with medium fans). Even then, you’d need 6 fans for push-pull in order to keep the fans idle and no ramping.

An 360 AIO may have enough reserve to allow for short bursts of that windows VM. But they too will start to ramp up after a minute as a 360 is borderline for 350W. However, they have never really existed in the past because of how large the die is and how little TR there are out there.

Note that if you do find an AIO, make damn sure it has the very large copper plate for Epyc/TR chips. The ones I’ve seen were standard consumer small plates with adapters to mount to a TR4 socket. Gamers Nexus actually did a video on this and showed how the chiplets were not getting cooled.

Once I switched to Threadripper, I gave up on desktop silent case builds. They now live in my server rack for 5+ years.

Like @eduncan911 said, custom loop water cooling is the answer for “silent” performance under load, just be aware if you want quiet, inaudible, or undetectable it requires different levels of hardware.

I have a 5950X & 7900XTX on a custom hard loop with a 360mm & 280mm radiator, it is acceptable under light load, kinda noisy under a heavy load.

A 3970X Threadripper with a bitspower 360mm AIO, I just need to spend some time tuning the fan curve because it is kinda annoyingly loud and worse yet it ramps up and down a decent bit. I will probably use a motherboard temperature sensor header and stick a probe in the radiator fins to control AIO fan speed off the radiator temperature.

A 9970X Threadripper with a 140mm, 280mm & 420mm radiator custom EPDM soft loop for just the CPU AND the loudest thing in the case are the R9700 GPUs and the pump when it ramps up, the CPU loop is pretty quiet, but the system isn’t silent.

And a way overkill cooled gaming rig with a 14900k & a 5090 both cooled by a custom EPDM soft loop using 2x 280mm, 2x 240mm & 2x 480mm radiators (12x 120mm Noctua fans & 6x 140mm Noctua fans). It runs essentially inaudible within arms reach under modest load, barely a whisper under really heavy loads.

Other people run one or more MORA external radiators they locate a few or several dozen feet away, possibly in another room even. Those can be a great option if done right.

The point is if you want silent or really quiet operation under load you need a lot of fans running at low RPM moving air across a lot of radiator surface area. Otherwise you are limited by the size of a tower cooler and what it can dissipate (based on it’s fin density, number of heat pipes, ect…) plus how much air the fans can move.

You can also consider modding what you have to work with different fans, if you can design and 3d print things then a fan shroud from your existing tower cooler to a 120mm or 140mm fan could work to move a ton of air and maybe provide more CPU cooling potential while most likely being quieter.

1 Like

Arctic WS360-SP6, 150 bucks but killer temps. 38mm thicc rad!

I have a 7965WX and was using the Noctua NH-D9 and then upgraded to the Silverstone XE360PD, and it greatly reduced fan noise.

It looks like the SST-XE360-TR5 model you are looking at uses different, noisier, fans but it looks like they just upgraded the model to include the same fans the XE360PD ships with: XE360-TR5-V2.

The important thing to know about the AIO and those FHL120 fans they ship with is that you do not need to spin them at max RPM. They are “industrial” fans that spin up to 3000RPM at max rates, and I have found that is not really necessary for cooling a single socket. I have one notch of my fan curve set to 50% RPMs at 75C, and it stays right under 75C even if I run

stress-ng --cpu 40 --cpu-method matrixprod --stream 8

So the max noise level of those fans may be ~40dBA, but unless you are running in a location with high ambient temperatures, you aren’t going to be running it anywhere close to max fan speed.

That said, the XE360PD has dual pumps so I imagine it is a higher flow rate than the XE360-TR5. If you want to reduce noise as much as possible, I would get the XE360PD as I expect it will perform better (but I do not know this for sure).

This is interesting, thankyou:)

I can find references to the v2 XE360-TR5 on sale outside the UK but not here. So I’ll look at the more expensive XE360PD, which also seems to require a separate mounting bracket, I assume form the pictures that it does cover the whole cpu?

edit: what did you do regarding this:

image

Yes, you do need to buy the appropriate mounting bracket for the XE360PD, which adds cost. Make sure to get the right one, I wasn’t paying attention and at first I had ordered the SP5 adapter instead of the sTR5/SP6 adapter.

The 12V output was not an issue for me and I doubt it is an issue on your ASRock motherboard either. I think if you have non-PWM fan headers that vary the voltage to control “fan” speed - it may not provide enough power to the pump if you set the speed below 100%. Your motherboard should support it fine - and you can just set the speed to 100% in your fan curve and not worry about it. Additionally, I’m pretty sure the XE360PD also ships with a molex power adapter to run the pumps at full speed without using a fan header at all.