Problems hdmi KVM switching with a specific laptop

KVM Model:

MKAG-8KT3114 (4HDMI in 1HDMI out)

USB Interface (5-gigabit or 10-gigbit):

USB 3.2 (10gbit) (but the computer I’m having issues with is using a USB-C to USB-A cable)


Problem:

I’ve got 3 laptops connected via HDMI. 2 of them switch consistently, but the Surface Laptop 6 for Business will only display if I restart the KVM and then quickly switch to it. The success rate for this technique is pretty low, but it sometimes works. When this technique fails, switching to the other inputs is also futile.

Other Notes:

The two laptops that work are connected via HDMI and USB-C. The Surface has more limited ports, so it’s connected via USB-A for the usb connection and the USB-C port is used with an active USB-C to HDMI converter.

I tested this type of converter with my monitor and the laptop prior to hooking up the KVM, so I know it works with the monitor. I also tried using the USB-C to HDMI converter with one of the other laptops that supports it, and switching to it continues working just fine.

Finally, another quirk I’ve noticed is that when things aren’t working, sometimes unplugging the USB-A to C cable and switching will cause display to start working. But after about 5 minutes switching to that machine results in no display again.

Possibilities

I was thinking this might have something to do with USB power settings on the Surface, as when I am able to get it to display I’m also having issues with the mouse and keyboard input getting stuck repeating the same input intermittently. I did try tweaking the USB power settings a bit in device manager I think. I noticed some improvement but then the problem came back.

Final key (or misc?) detail

Just now when I had the KVM set to the second input (the Surface laptop), the USB-A was unplugged. When I plugged it in, I noticed that the monitor started flashing “HDMI 2” in a different way than it does when it’s idle/not receiving. It’s like it’s trying to receive, receiving -something-, but ultimately not able to display it. I’ve noticed this in other scenarios as well, sometimes while switching, and while otherwise trying to debug this.

I ran this by AI and it says the Surface Laptop 6 for Business is notorious for having a very strict USB implementation. It suggests trying a lightning dock, which I haven’t shelled out for yet as they are quite expensive for what you get.