So recently I upgraded my phone from a samsung s20 fe 5g with a combined storage of 386gb to a samsung s25+ with 256gb of internal storage.
The biggest difference between the 2 is I no longer have an micro sd card slot for expandable storage.
I usually use most of my storage for my music for when I’m driving. So local storage is more of a must than storing the music on a cloud drive (witch also runs the risk of getting deleted at corporate digression). I know I can get a usb-c card reader but I charge my phone and connect my phone to the aux connection of my cars radio and I just don’t want another dongle to add back the functionality back to my phone.
So I am looking for a portable music player with a minimum of 512gb of storage of internal or external storage preferably with a micro sd card slot so I can change out the card when needed. Have my collection of music in lossless file formats and some stuff in mp3 as well so it needs to support multiple music formats.
Doesn’t have to be top tier bran but not look looking for some two cent pos either. Not looking to spend the $500.00 to $1000.00 for storage upgrades for internal storage either.
I respect the drive to keep things local. I did the ipod thing for a minute. They arent that hard to build out yourself. Rockbox is an old firmware I used to like over stock.
Well i was going to reccomend a Sansa Clip Zip, but apparently those are ebay-only at this point as they’re no longer made. Format it with Rockbox (a custom firmware for many MP3 players) and it’s actually pretty nice. I have a microsd card I load podcasts onto so I don’t have to connect the actual device to my PC.
I have a raspberry pi nano sitting next to me I was going to turn into an MP3 player, but I haven’t gotten around to it. The idea was something that could stay in my car, and just ran off a cigarette port. And no battery to randomly catch on fire. My car is older, aux ports were a ‘new feature’ when I got it.
I’d need to learn a LOT of skills to make it into an MP3 player (that was partly the point) but…don’t hold your breath.
I’d say check out the rockbox forums and see what they recommend for stuff still being sold.
My concern is when I loose network connection. Driving around in a car has a tendency to find dead zones / low bandwidth areas. Yes I know of a few areas around me that I cannot get a signal.
That is certainly one option. Have 250 - 350 cd worth of music and prefer to listen to the music I’ve already paid money to have and not have to pay for it again or ads or availability if I can avoid it!
I use a hiby M300 for my EDC DAP. It’s cheap enough and get’s the job done. I had a Sony Walkman NW-A306 but parked it after getting the M300 which seems to perform better. I’m using either ATH M-50X or DT 770 Pro’s.
I still have an ipod classic surviving for this very purpose. Doesn’t fit all of your criteria, HDD based, non-expandable storage, and they are LONG out of production so you’re talking second (or more) hand for a device that wears out and the battery is almost certain to be dead on (mine lasts for exactly one song not plugged in). Also being apple, it doesn’t support a lot of file formats, but itunes will convert them to “apple lossless”. I’m also not sure what the highest size of the HD is. Mine, which I don’t know if was the final gen, is 256gb if memory serves.
tl;dr - ipod classic from ebay or whatever is probably a bad choice, but might meet the need if you can’t find anything else.
Cringey old person that I am, SD Card + wired headphones are deal-breakers. I wouldn’t get a phone that didn’t have these, and luckily Sony Xperias are avaiable in my region. If you’re having upgrader’s remorse about the new handset, can you trade it in for a Sony Xperia?
If not, adding flash storage and a new battery to an older iPod would be a fun project, I’d look into that.
This usually isnt an issue for me as the stream is buffered. You of course have the option of downloading ahead of time if you know you’re going to be without.
Regardless, I think the best option without streaming would be an old 4th or 5th gen ipod classic. They have a ton of aftermarket support and you could build out one to be as large as your wallet is willing to suffer.
I dont want to derail, but just to illustrate what one can do with these.
Storage
This will convert the old spinner to any SD card of your choosing. If you go above a certain size, you will need to use something besides stock firmware iirc.
Replacement Batteries
There are differences between the different sizes of ipod, but this isnt a big deal as you can usually mix and match.
Parts
They even sell a different back that would reflect the storage you might choose
These things have made a pretty big comeback.
Firmware
I highly recommend Rockbox, as this allows you to decouple from iTunes. You just drag and drop media onto it and rescan with rockbox. It has a ton more features than these devices came with like a fully parametric 10 band EQ.
I am hesitant to look into anything apple as they are know for bricking your device if the upgrade / repair is not done at the time of sale / thru an apple authorized repair center.
I will be looking into the other options. Thank you everyone for your suggestions!
The Nothing/CMF Phone 2 Pro has a micro sd card slot, no 3.5mm jack but it’s just $279.
One of the very few new phones available in the US market with an sd slot. 256gb onboard storage too. Pretty bare android 15.
The Sony NW-A306 is okay, very pocketable with an sd slot and 3.5mm
I also have a Hiby R4 which is heavier and has an sd card slot, but has better battery life and sound.
Ended up trying a hiby r1 and didn’t care for it. Very sluggish interface. Didn’t connect to my cars blutooth.
Returned it and picked up a Fiio jm21 and a 512gb micro sd card! So far I am happy with it!
I happen to get it on sale for $155 ish!
Only gripe I have is it could use a 6 - 8 inch screen vs the 4.7 inch display for people like me who’s eyes are not the best any more.
Now just need to clean up my messy music collection! So many files from over the years and not all of them have proper meta tagging or meta tagging I prefer.
I don’t need 5 listing for sting / sting and the police just for 1 album but nooooo have to have it divided out 5 times for each song and my player just plays the 1 song and then you need to go in and find the next song manually to play or find the album listing vs the artist listing to play the full album. and then switch back to continue with the original artist……….. royal pain in the ass when driving!