Apparently, the U.S. administration banned all foreign-made routers starting next year.
Does this cover router hardware? If I build a PFSense router, which will have ASUS or ASROCK parts etc, is this now banned?
It’s easy to say ban all foreign routers but how much uncertainty has just been created.
No. It is about router devices, appliances.
The devices sold as routers.
What parts are used dont matter. This would theoretically ban the sale of the same device you build, if i (as a businness seller anyway) assemble it in europe and try to sell it on ebay to US customers.
Hmm. Isn’t the big concern in the software or firmware rather than the hardware?
What if I mfg a nice router in the USA and then load it up with sketchy software developed in China…
They are not in china though so the gubberment can reach at them or even revoke their brand from the whitelist. It is about gubberment control over manufacturer. To allegedly enforce regulations ensuring a better/safer product. And save the kids and puppies
Sure, but vulnerabilities and backdoors are like cockroaches! For each one you find there are 10 you don’t… Good point, though.
This really sucks for Mikrotik. They make quality stuff at good prices, and now they either give up US market or get a whole manufacturing facility over here.
From the information I have seen, literally every company except Starlink manufactures their routers outside the US. And while it is “nice” that currently sold models are exempt and this only applies to new models released from here forward, it still really hurts every other company out there with scrambling to find some way to make their new products in the US for reasonable prices. And those manufacturing facilities dont even really exist on scale in the US right now.
This is interesting. It’s trying to address a very real and serious problem.
I might have gone about it by having some kind of firmware cyber security certification process on all routers regardless of origin… although this is probably even less feasible than the FCC’s new approach.
I think people are misinterpreting this new directive, what it does in the near term is establish a hardware and firmware chain of trust to existing new products:
The long term aspect is the onshoring to USA which is kind of up in the air to me, it may never even happen, but the near term goal does seem reasonable given the severity of the problem.
I’m not sure how I feel about the grandfathering in of existing routers though, I understand it was done to make this less disruptive, but it gives the optic that this isn’t as serious of a problem.
I wonder if Kim Jong Trump should instead stop all foreign internet traffic, for safety?
Might be easier…
It’s only going to effect the big players. The actual off brand cheapos you find on AliExpress and even Amazon now by the likes of YangLee have fake FCC stickers and Fake UK Listed stickers, and never had FCC certification to begin with.
It’s also not going to effect existing approved models. Even stuff that hasn’t hit retail shelves yet but has received FCC approval, will still be released (so thankfully my new Omada Fusion Firewall that comes out in June, will still be sent to me for review).
And some brands new this was coming. It is part of why TP-Link has been transition the Omada brand off on its own thing. From TP-Link Omada, to Omada by Tp-Link, and soon just Omada Networks.
Aren’t almost all routers in homes, from ISP’s?
I agree having a safe, secure hardware chain of trust is important, but that is achieved by tech companies who have devices made in other territories, including China, and regularly checking components.
Obviously people who buy their own router, including perhaps a quarter or half the folk here, are less likely to buy the cheapo Chinese ones, but other non US vendors are strong competitors.
And the larger US companies, like Cisco, have a lot of their equipment made in China (with strong verifications of trusted supply chains)
Obviously, the security services, still target individuals of interest, not just the NSA intercepting and backdooring Cisco’s equipment, but presumably other actors, domestic as well as foreign
You must buy your severely vulnerable cisco routers. Don’t try to buy the Chinese vulnerable routers, you must go with the star-sprangled flavor of sh*t, not the yellow stars on red background flavored sh*t.
Do as you’re told!
I didn’t say I agree with it. Rather the compromised products that have zero FCC certs still end up on Amazon so it’s only hurting the legit brands, and the shelves of major brick and mortar retailers.
Also pointed out how it doesn’t effect already approved models, because people only read the headlines that say things are banned and don’t read the details, where it’s specifically just won’t approve new FCC certifications. It’s not good what’s happening and very stupid but at the same time it’s not the sky is falling all these routers are not going to be pulled from shelves. Legitimately just an extortion tactic by the administration against the big brands, since they all can apply for exceptions.
It’s okay
Twin savage, made a good point about chain of trusts, which was a good point
US made does not guarantee it, of course, but would vastly reduce casual interference by specifically the CCP, who are particularly egregious
The rest was just my own ramblings
As for not retroactively trashing past, it’s more they can’t and so little Carr, is just doing what he practically can, to please the king
So now ISPs will have to brand them as switches or modems…
Yes, but there are some ISPs such as Frontier for example where their router is a TP Link or Asus they send to you. I have one of their TP Links in a box in the closet even. ATT and Comcast have their own hardware, but many other ISPs do not.
My Comcast modem device is from ARRIS.
Also sucks for Cisco and HPE lol.
I am not aware of any US brands that still make stuff in the US.
Made in China.
I am aware of like 3 brands for networking gear that are not made in China:
This entire thing is a giant piece of security theater: Lots of noise, very little use.
This is what happens when you elect the dumbest person/people on the planet to run your government.
Cheques and Bank Balances, like the founding fathers intended
