Need help,I need to choose between ryzen or xeon

Hi, first time here.

I need to work with Intel e810 NICs (I need XDP — eXpress Data Path — hardware offload support and DDP — Dynamic Device Personalization). I think the e810 25G is a good price/performance, but I may change it later, and other components must be compatible with it.

These PCs will be used headless — ZTP for the first configuration, then SSH for all stuff.
I’ll need two systems, one for pktgen. I need to run benchmarks for research purposes.Since pktgen is not easier than receiving high pps,I’m thinking buying the same.

Currently, I’m using a ThinkPad with 32 gb ddr5 and an intel ultra 5 125u and it’s more than I want for my daily work,these systems are for a university research project on XDP/DDP.
My lecturers said the hardware will be funded by the university, but if not, I won’t buy the computers myself.

I’m between two options:

  • Second-hand servers:
    Xeon E5-2680 v4 (may need two per PC because one might not handle high PPS).
    I found one locally for $20, with a 2-year warranty.
    High-capacity but old second-hand ECC RAM.
    In this option, I’m worried about unknown motherboard brands like JginYue (?).
    Even if I weren’t, I’m not sure what the university would think about funding a JginYue board.
    I live in Turkey, so buying from eBay etc. is nearly impossible due to taxes and import laws.
  • brand new ryzen:
    ryzen 7 7800x3d for the large l3
    At high gbps,accessing the ram may mess up my benchmark results,so I think it’s necessary.
    Intel CAT (Cache Allocation Technology) would be wonderful, but that hardware is pricey.
    This build would basically be a gaming PC with an e810 instead of an rtx
    The second option costs roughly 2× the first one.

What do you think, and why?

Since these systems won’t be in my home, electricity cost, space, and noise are out of scope.

This topic was automatically closed 273 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.