My Phone os dilemma

I know a lot of people here hate apple and everything they make but I don’t need a list od reason why they suck, I made a different thread for tgat called What do yall hate about apple products/company . Keep this one for helpful and respectful suggestions cause I really don’t want one my threads taken down cause it turned into yelling match.

I have been stuck in this dilemma for about 4 years and 2 different phones (my phone carrier does bring it back program where they give you a phone you basically pay half the phone for two years and then at the end of that two years you can either give the phone back or buy off the phone with the remaining amount in cash), I have been an iPhone user ever since my parents gave me a device that can be connected to internet that was my own(probably reveals my my age but whatever) so I have not used android as my daily driver device but a few years back I bought a pixel 3 xl to mess around with android and see if it makes sense for to go through the hassle of migration and came to conclusion it’s not cause for what I use my phone for I gain nothing of value cause I won’t side-load any apps cause that’s just more risk than I am willing to take,general security of the play store at that wasn’t great at that time (app isn’t too much better at that either ) but it has improved greatly since then and finally I was looking into which operating sends more telemetry data back to some server somewhere in the world and to no surprise both where sending a boat load of data but iOS actually stopped onced it was disabled the ones I could disable without doing some unholy things to the operating system but google being google didn’t stop sending once they were it just sent a little less often(this test was done in 2022 ,so both could have improved or got worse. Most likely worse cause we are the product and pay for the product to help rip other people off in a year ) after that I stuck with IOS but kept watching what’s going on in the android space and when I saw it not improving in way I wanted, I went into android rom space where I found calyxo os,graphene os and a bunch forums and reddit threads of people yelling at each other about which is better and saying some unhinged to anyone who uses anything else that the one they picked but ignoring that, I ended up trying calyxo os cause it’s the only that supported the phone I had and didn’t give a gut wrenching feeling that there going to be a rat(remote access trojan) baked into the os. Tried it out it worked great but then I looked into how they did the degoogling (microg) part was immediately disappointed cause they just signature spoof to trick the apps into thinking they are took to a google server so I immediately discarded it as option to many risks not worth. Then into looked grapheneos which didn’t support but seemed to the gold standard for security and privacy but at that time and now from what I have seen it has some problems with some apps that most people can’t just ditch completely or replace due some reason, which for me that was public transit app cause at that time public transit was my main way of transportation and there weren’t any Foss alternative there now but as far as I know there are now but mostly all American or British public transit :sob::sob:.

To the present my current phone plan ends in November and I don’t know what to do cause iOS last year has been a buggy mess and now with ios 27 auto enabling there ai after the update and if you disable it you can’t siri (which I rarely ever do cause siri sucks rotten eggs) and android not being any better in terms that stuff, I said from the looks of it I get what the newest pixel is or previous years one assuming the price will drop and slap grapheneos on it, oh how wrong and unlucky I am, not are the pixels worse than previous years model it’s also more expensive thanks to our ai overlords greedy and selfish assholes by buying all the storage and memory from every single trusted manufacturers so I said I will get previous year models cause the price would have dropped it didn’t​:sob::sob::melting_face:. Let alone that I managed to dig myself deeper in the apple ecosystem throughout those years by either buying said apple product myself or gifted by family (this was this year cause I didn’t have the greatest last 4 months of 2025, so my family wanting to get me something to cheer up on my birthday they got an Apple Watch , which if you didn’t know turns into a expensive paper weight without an iPhone ffs apple ).

So if anyone has gone through this process before let me know how you decided and if the switch was worth it or a complete mistake. Cause I am stuck in a state of limbo right now with no obvious path forward.

Thank you in advance for your suggestions

If you don’t mind the iOS UX or the restrictions (most people benefit from the restrictions for security reasons) then just stay on iPhone. iPhones have better performance and security.

Some people on the internet get way too worked up over phones.

Assuming your current iPhone is reasonably recent, I would just keep using it. Maybe you can switch to a cheaper plan that doesn’t include a phone subsidy as part of its monthly cost.

3 Likes

I wouldn’t use a proprietary operating system on my PC, and I also wouldn’t use one on my phone, for the same reasons I wouldn’t use it on the PC.

Graphene OS is the most privacy respecting option currently available, so that is what I use.

I mind what the phone looks like, and I don’t care who made it or if it works with my watch, I just want a phone that isn’t spying on me.

1 Like

You probably want a dumb phone then, because any smartphone irrespective of OS is going to leak data to/via the applications you run on it.

And even then, your carrier knows where you are and can/may resell that information to anyone who asks.

Enjoy!

3 Likes

Sounds like an iOS device is the relatively simple solution to get the privacy and security features you want, then just be very mindful of what apps you load on it and especially what you use the device for (and be mindful of what you do when on mobile data networks or especially public wifi). Apple has been pressured to give government access to a device but refused, and if enabled the on device security is robust.

If you go the DIY route it will be a mixed bag depending on the device and what you want to run on the phone, it won’t be nearly as simple and it will be on you to diagnose and resolve issues yourself. That may or may not be good enough for you, especially with battery life and performance which may or may not matter to you.

Just remember the only truly secure data is data that doesn’t exist, security of data beyond that is a sliding scale from “secure for now” to “not secure”. There is zero click malware now that can load in with advertisements on a web page, my understanding is that sort of thing is going to be part of a targeted attack for now. Part of online security is being sure to block advertisements any chance you can (even clicking a search result promoted ad link accidentally and interacting with the webpage can compromise your device, try to avoid Google and block all ads)

1 Like

I’d keep the iPhone since you’re already using it and see what happens with the GrapheneOS and Motorola partnership

3 Likes

You control what apps you install. And what they are allowed to do on Grapheneos.

1 Like

I’ve been brewing an insane idea in the past two to three years: buy a Jolla or Linux phone and remote into an Android phone that’s living home for apps that need to run there.
Maybe even a Pixel with GrapheneOS and wall powered without a battery.

But this is a wild way to close this gap.

5 Likes

Yes and no. Apple did publicly refuse to unlock some iDevices. But iDevices pass most of their data through iCloud and Apple is more than happy to supply copies to the government upon request. For residents of China and Russia, iCloud data is siloed locally and the government keeps the encryption keys so no need to even ask Apple.

1 Like

My current phone is an iPhone. It’s an iPhone 16 so unless the buyout price for it is a complete rip off I’m most likely I’m just gonna buy it off of them cause the new ones are not worth the price.

Yep, with Google trying to lock-down their open-source-based operating system, all mainstream mobile OSes generally suck. Had the DoJ not been the cowards they are, they would have forced Google to break Android into an independent, completely open independent body [1]. Additionally they could have required all Android device makers to unlock their bootloaders so we could install the OS (AOSP-based or otherwise) of our choice. Then we’d have actual control of our hardware.

[1] of course, seeing the sort of hostile crap going on in the various opensource organizations and consortiums, with the politicised purging of those exhibiting “wrongthink”, and ever-expanding user-hostile engineering decisions, we might not have been better off anyway.

1 Like

I do have to make the observation you can’t eat you cake and have it to, so some choices/collisions have to be made.
You could try the following.
Focus on 3 things you find the most important requirements the phone must meet.
Also make list the 3 worst deal-breakers.
If stuff conflicts in the 2 lists think a bit what you find more important of the 2 conflicting.

Also did you consider just to return your current phone, and swap to sim only plan (call+data)
And no phone as part of the the plan and see of you can get a, decent condition previous gen pixel.
Put GrapheneOS on it and see how things go and if after a few weekt it’s not for you, go grab a ASOP or LinageOS or whatever rom looks best to you from a reputable XDA developer.
Some open fork of Gservices to keep the play api gatekeeper happy.
And you have a fully functional phone while you search a better alternative in your time.

Relating to GrapheneOS.
About compatibility and broken apps, did you read these 2 posts?

Personal opinion about Google, and Apple zero trust on just about everything they do.
Samsung is also a great 3th name as they have proven in actions they don’t think your phone is you’re device to modify or use to your liking, a mindset all 3 companies share.
The one thing you can trust is they will never never spare any effort or steep to low to get just a cent richer.

Also ever heard of Sailfish OS?
It’s not fully open source but for a good part and not based on android.
I does have a way to run android apps so you can have access to a whatever you need.

And finally a kind request to please use the enter key in such walls of text.
I have incredible difficulties reading what’s written as it all forms in a white blur few sentences in.

1 Like

You will also quickly discover that a lot of what you need refuses to run without access to the Google Play Integrity API.

1 Like

You don’t control your radio signal triangulation via cell towers, etc.

You dont control all the data that you have to disclose to the services you actually use either. Ebay (and to some extent the payment processors aka visa mastercard) knows what i buy for example. DUHH its the middleman.

The point here is limit the disclosure to the bare minimum, not become a ghost.

1 Like

I like the idea. A thin client phone. I’d use it .

2 Likes

You’re not stuck because you missed some secret third OS. You’re stuck because a phone is no longer just a phone. It holds identity, money, travel documents, 2FA, photos, and a pile of apps that don’t have real substitutes. Once that’s true, “which brand is less evil” is the wrong question. The useful one is: what does this device actually have to do, and what are you willing to give up for that?

Write the requirements down before you buy anything. Split them into two lists:

Must work on the device in your pocket

  • Calls / SMS

  • Banking / payments / 2FA

  • Transit / tickets / boarding passes

  • Maps while walking

  • Camera you actually use

  • Watch pairing (this one matters for you)

Can live on a laptop / tablet instead

  • Email, browsing, shopping, work, most “apps that are really websites”

If the first list is short, a cheap flip or a locked-down “dumb” phone plus a Linux laptop with full-disk encryption is a real option, not a meme. A basic flip with unlimited minutes is still in the ~$100/year range. The phone then holds almost nothing. The laptop holds the rest, and you can actually inspect and lock that down. For anything that looks like government, banking, or “this would ruin my month if it leaked,” treat the phone as less trustworthy than a properly configured laptop. Always.

If the first list is long — Watch, banking apps that fingerprint the OS, transit that only exists as a vendor app, family iMessage — then you are choosing among bad compromises, not finding a clean exit.

On GrapheneOS specifically

It’s the best engineering answer in the Android privacy space: Pixel hardware, relocked bootloader, verified boot, sandboxed Play if you need it, no stock Google telemetry stack. Pixel 8/9/10 series are all supported; you don’t have to buy the newest one. Banking apps in the US generally work with sandboxed Play. Transit is better than it was in 2022, but “works on Graphene” is still app-by-app, not a guarantee.

The part people skip: you are still trusting a small project to ship an OS you will not personally audit. Most of us will never read that code. AI can help scan it; it does not replace a threat model. GrapheneOS is not “off-book untrusted binary from a forum.” It is still a third party standing between you and the hardware. That’s a smaller, more competent third party than Google or Apple — not zero third party.

CalyxOS + microG was the right instinct to walk away from. Signature spoofing to fake Google is a compatibility hack, not a security design. Graphene’s sandboxed Play is the less ugly version of the same problem: some apps still want Google’s identity, so you isolate it instead of pretending it isn’t there.

On staying in iOS

Your 2022 telemetry observation still tracks the shape of the problem: Apple gives you more switches that actually stay off; Google’s “off” is often “less often.” That doesn’t make iOS private. It makes it more toggleable. iOS 27 made Apple Intelligence harder to treat as optional — Siri and the AI stack are more fused, and turning pieces off has real feature loss. You can still refuse the training prompt and use Screen Time restrictions to pin Classic Siri, but the direction of the OS is obvious: the assistant is becoming load-bearing.

The Watch is the expensive paperweight you already named. That’s not a philosophical problem. That’s a switching cost measured in cash and family Christmas. If the Watch stays, an iPhone stays, or you eat the Watch.

On travel / unlock / “the phone is a wallet”

A phone that can be compelled, cloned, or unlocked at a border is a different object than a laptop you leave at the hotel or don’t bring. That’s not theoretical anymore. If you travel, the right move is often: phone holds a clean profile and a travel SIM; laptop holds the real keys; nothing important lives only on the device that goes through the scanner. GrapheneOS is stronger than stock against a lot of extraction, but the device in your pocket is still the device in your pocket.

How people actually decide (the part that ends the limbo)

There are four honest paths. Pick one on purpose.

  1. Stay iOS, shrink the blast radius. Keep the Watch and the family chat. Turn off every Intelligence / analytics toggle you can. Don’t put banking only on the phone. Accept that you’re buying convenience and ecosystem lock-in, not privacy.

  2. Pixel + GrapheneOS, accept app friction. Buy last year’s Pixel if the price is actually lower; don’t wait for a crash that may not come. Test your banking and transit apps on Graphene before you sell the iPhone. Budget a weekend for the migration and a month of “this one app is annoying.”

  3. Two-device split. Dumb/minimal phone for calls and texts (Nokia flip, Light, Mudita, Punkt — pick by how many apps you still need). Encrypted Linux laptop (or tablet) for everything that matters. This is the only path that actually matches “I don’t want this computer in my pocket.” Convenience is the tax. That’s the whole trade.

  4. Stay one more cycle on iOS while you run the experiment. Your plan ends in November; you don’t have to solve identity, payments, and a Watch on the same weekend. Get the requirements list on paper, try Graphene on a cheap used Pixel before you trade the iPhone in, and see which apps are actually non-negotiable.

Was the switch “worth it” for people who did it? When their must-have list was short, yes. When they still needed iMessage, Watch, and three vendor apps with no substitutes, they either bounced back or lived slightly annoyed. That’s not a moral failure. That’s the product surface.

Don’t optimize for which company you dislike less. Optimize for: what data is on the device, who can compel it, and whether a laptop should have been doing that job the whole time.

2 Likes

Thank you to everyone for your advice and suggestions cause they have helped make the decision a lot easier and made me reevaluate what functionality I need for my devices​:grin::grin:

2 Likes