Modest disc shelf recommendations

Hi all. I have decided I’m probably not buying a HL15, I realised the price was without a motherboard (silly me) and so it’s pretty expensive, and worse by the time you get it to the UK. We can get Silverstone cases OK though, and I was watching the Silverstone 5U review.

Wendell mentions a disc shelf, which is probably what I should aim for as the most cost effective way to rack many drives, and build out a NAS from “trash drives”. I am limited by depth, with an 18" / 455mm network cabinet.

I think 8 to 12 3.5" HDD would be a sweet spot for me, or multiple shelves. I can probably build something out of “trash drives” if I have enough slots. The recent video showed a disc shelf but it’s full depth.

I’d love to see a follow up video of the Silverstone case being hooked up to a short disc shelf. I think a lot of us won’t have full depth server cabinets, and probably want to avoid the noise full depth kit can bring, particularly when racking kit in a modest home.

Does anyone have any recommendations on disc shelves please? I looked at the Silverstone NAS but it wasn’t quite what I was looking for. I looked at their disc shelves but 4 bays was £850, so it works out much cheaper to just buy a HL15 lol.

Maybe if I can work out what I need I can make a video myself to help others.

Cheers

Russ

Pic of my RM44 just because I love it

Do you require hot-swappable drives? All of them? If not, here’s possible solution:

In the first decade of this Millennium big towers were, well, big :wink: Most could house 10+ HDD’s (nothing hot-swap at that time as IDE still ruled). Nowadays, no new offers but you might be able to find something used at a charity shop or smth for pretty cheap. Included mainboard + RAM usually trash, PSU could be usable (pending testing) so a new(-ish) mainboard, especially with an APU (AMD R5 4600G or similar) and a pair of 8 or 16GB RAM sticks will do you fine.

As for shallow disk shelves, I don’t think they exist. I have a few disk shelves, all full length/depth. And make no mistake, those things are LOUD. Mine are NetApp 2246 2U 24x 2.5” units with a pair of 1U (=40mm fans) PSU’s each :roll_eyes: They scream! :scream: So they’re off, also as I can’t get (enough) high capacity SAS SSD’s for a reasonable price :money_with_wings:

1 Like

I have been grabbing using old Dell PowerVault MD1200 when they pop up on ebay cheap. The fans are loud, but you can use a serial cable and send it fan speed commands to make it a bit quieter.

3 Likes

This is actually a contender, the Sliger CX3702

$100 Fedex to the UK (or free for those of you in the States) AND it’ll fit in a network rack.