Modern cars, propriotary software and jailbreaking

I’ve never looked into more modern computerized machines, but they are just engine with a computer that controls the signal?

modern ICE cars have engines run by electronics (the ECU). The injectors that put the fuel in the combustion chambers, the spark plugs, the fuel pump and whatnot are operated by the ECU. Anything that does not have a carburetor is run by an ECU of some kind.

Taking a generic wiring schematic from the speeduino wiki for example


This is a separate system from the onboard media “tablet” and GPS and radio and whatever, those are not running the car and in well-designed cars they shouldn’t even be connected to the canbus where all the other automotive electronics talk to each other (brakes, steering, the digital screen showing the speed and engine rpm and whatnot).

1 Like

mostly yes.

The simple solution to that is something like Android Auto or Apple Carplay

where the car’s “multimedia system” is just a dumb device that is set up to pair with the user’s phone and just act as a bigger screen for it (and pipe the sound to the car’s speaker system).

Obligatory “Do you guys not have phones” meme applies here. The user in the Year of Our Lord 2026+ is going to have a smartphone anyway so all the multimedia aspect should be offloaded to that instead of embedding a crappy tablet-like device that won’t get meaningful updates (if any) for more than half the lifespan of the actual vehicle.

It’s still a form of vendor lock-in (either to Google or Apple ecosystem) but it’s less bad than being vendor-locked to whatever the car manufacturer puts on the media system.

But obviously car manufacturers want a piece of the pie in data collection too, especially for EVs. So this is less common in EVs already and some manufacturers like GM want to drop it from ICE cars too in the near future of 2028

That’s kind of scary.

Most of the proposed legislation I’m seeing it more about restricting the criteria for cars registered as “historical vehicles”.
Heck I’m looking at the criteria now and I’m thinking I should register my daily/weekly as a historic vehicle in the next couple of years when it meets the age threshold, It’d be way cheaper and I meet all the other criteria.

1 Like

This just came up in my feed. Seems interesting:

My automotive 30,000ft view 2 cents:

There will be a selection of cars/trucks that either due to ease or fan-base or combination of both will receive excellent ‘full spectrum ‘ aftermarket support. So things like ECU hacking, tuning, flashing, replacement, OEM head units and their upgrades or really well integrated aftermarket systems (canbus support, model specific features support etc). 3d scanning and printing of all sorts of parts. Thorough mapping and sharing of tech manual data, community lessons learned etc. a strong healthy aftermarket community that is finding and listing common breakdowns, fixes, alternative parts resources etc (like some digikey parts to replace electrics on unsupported/no longer made OEM electronics/hardware hacking like figuring out a 2004 ford explorer rear end swaps almost perfectly into a 2027 Tacoma, the former being cheap and plentiful the latter having some kind of supplier snafu).

Then there will be cars/trucks in-between the above and below, where its pretty decent support and parts supply but some community noted failure points. For example plenty of engine auxiliary parts (water pump, alternator, head units, mirrors etc) but a glaring unobtainium list like transmissions and their parts etc, or absolutely bonkers pricing.

And then there will be cars that don’t get a fraction of this and will be examples of how bad right to repair has gotten.

How to select what will be highly supported will be highly informed speculation, like smartly managed stock trading. Car enthusiasts in “the know” will have SWAGs (scientific wild ass guesses) with likely high accuracy what platforms will get the top tier aftermarket love. Cars that have immediate enthusiast adoption like performance variants (but not all) of Subaru, Honda, Toyota, Ford, GM etc etc that will have droves of autists combing over every spec, supplier, protocol. Vehicles that have crazy sales numbers like F150s, Camry’s etc are a pretty safe bet as there is monetary drive for highly resourced parts producers to support.

Sources: im a avid automotive enthusiast with some age under my belt and lots of modding experience. All my current whips are over 20 years old and i keep them running - its been enlightening and educational.

Wasn’t there a recent incident with new Porsches in Russia, where they all had complete ignition failures over the space of a couple of weeks because of in-country server failures, so their phone homes failed?

In any case…IMO the comparison with 1940s cars is less relevant than with cars from about 1998-2010. That was pretty much the golden age for cars which were as safe and efficient as is required, but also able to be worked on without needing permission from the manufacturer.

It’s for this reason that I have a 2001 MG ZS 180 and a 2008 Audi TT. Hell, a couple of weeks ago I dusted off the MG after 18 months in the garage…fired up first time, not even a cough; the old girl might be a patchwork of welds and running repairs, but she wants to live :wink:

Compare that with my mate’s 2021 Golf, which spent a couple of years in his garage due to illness and chucked a bunch of nonsensical errors when he tried the ignition. The explanation was that it had missed too many OTA updates, and couldn’t be resurrected without being towed to the dealer for a manual update.

Just…nope.


Will there ever be a market correction?

When every manufacturer is producing planned obsolescence trash, at some point is there not a market demand for more reliable, easy to repair, and affordable cars that don’t sell your data behind your back?

Like really, how much shit is the general consumer going to put up with? I find it baffling that people accept this…

My beater is ~20 years old. Its not fast or fancy, but goes from point A to B and isn’t spying on me. It has no connection to the internet, it doesn’t need updates. My steering is not controlled by a computer so it can’t be hacked to remotely steer me into oncoming.

I don’t think I will ever purchase a modern vehicle unless things change. And if the law ever regulates out cars older than n number of years so you must buy newer (as is happening in some places), then I will be jailbreaking or ripping out the modem / applying a dummy load to the antennas so it can’t communicate. My data is my data, No means No.

1 Like