Mix-matching DDR5 DIMMs?

Can anyone confirm mixed ram working? Different sizes, different speed specs? Even different mfg?

We all know that’s a big no no, stability, lower speeds, blah blah but have you seen the prices of ram lately? No seriously, have you?

Maybe it’s time we go back in, time, like we used to mix-match memory DIMMs to the lowest common denominator settings.

So has anyone with a few dozen random DDR5 sticks just laying around, doing nothing, tried booting different combinations?

I know someone who bought one ddr5 5600 dimm with expo and the other ddr5 dimm not even the same memory modules samsung vs sk hynix that only supports XMP. It does work but you cannot use either expo or xmp in the bios and instead have to run manual settings at slightly slower timings

1 Like

Mixing DDR5 memory modules of different capacities and frequencies usually works, but the system will automatically throttle the speed to the lowest specification; stability depends on the compatibility between the motherboard and the memory.

1 Like

As an update, I picked up a 64GB kit of the Kingston Fury Beast 6000 Mhz on ebay for a lot cheaper My existing 32gb kit of the same name and model. Turns out, they are completely different. Different ranks (single vs dual), differing timings, etc.

Been fighting the Asus B850m bios to get things trained and booted. The best I can I do is 3600 Mhz with all four sticks installed - which works fine at 96 GB but memory tests at 38 GB/s - it was 62 GB/s under just the 64 GB sticks alone. 4800 Mhz did boot, but I started getting hard lockups - and I couldn’t really boot memtest86.

I do not call this a success. So, I am considering pulling the 32GB kit. :frowning:

I will say that I have a system with two kits that are exactly the same as each other and manufactured within weeks of each other so should for all intents and purposes be two matching kits, but they also will not boot any higher than 3600mhz, so I think this is more of a 4 dimm issue than the kits not matching.

1 Like

Yep, pulling the small kit is the right move. The memory controller on your CPU isn’t magical and will not usually have a good time even with matching 4 stick kits, if you have 4 sticks of dissimilar size, speed and build you should do everything possible to not have unmatched RAM modules… Oh, and if the memory isn’t on the motherboard’s QVL list you shouldn’t buy it, it’s very likely to cause you headaches.

1 Like

The AMD 9950X3D2 beast. No PBO, all stock.

I’m mis matching SODIMM in work laptop, 5600 and 5200. It defaulted to 5200 and work fine. YMMV

I gave up tinkering with 4800. Just pulled the 32GB kit and will remain on 64 GB.

I guess I lost the silicone lottery.