Linux noob looking for best distro for a gaming rig

So with W7 finally dying the time as come to get off the boat. While I understand linux won’t be perfect it’s better than staying on W7 for obvious reason.

I’m looking not only for recommendation but also guide because the thing I do know is that it’s been moving extremly fast in the last couple years so the last info I have is from LTT’s video " Microsoft Should be VERY Afraid - Noob’s Guide to Linux Gaming". So ATM I have the following question:
-Is the info from that video still accurate for the most part?
-If yes, what would be the recommended OS for a gaming rig ATM with their pro/con?
-Is there a good general guide on Linux that I could be directed to, not for a specific distro but in general so I’ve not too lost how ?
-A game I’d really like to keep is Kingdom Under Fire II, which uses Easy Anti Cheat. On their website Ubuntu is listed as supported, in those cases should I expect derivative of Ubuntu to probably work with it?
-Current machine specs are i9-9900k with Corsair H115i, GTX 1660Ti, 32Gb of RAM and an NVME SSD for boot with 3 other SSDs in hardware raid0 for storage. Is there something I should be concerned about with this setup?
-Something I briefly talked about with someone was the idea of splitting the NVME SSD between two distro of say Manjaro and Mint, and since the main storage would be on the RAID array it’d allow me to keep files in both OS even if different base. Crazy idea or actually sensible?

A 1000 thanks for the help.

Most games which support Linux were tested on Ubuntu only if tested at all. So that’s your safest bet.

If you were running an AMD GPU i might have suggested a distro with more up newer kernel like Fedora as it uses an open source driver that’s shipped with the kernel these days.

Apart from that there’s not a huge difference except for support, and potentially the development and security of the distro its self.

Try it an see i say.

Just keep in mind that a lot of your games may not work.

You can but why?

2 Likes

Basicly the idea is that if something doesn’t work as good on one OS I can switch to the other. So say on Manjaro Easy Anti Cheat didn’t run I could try on Ubuntu.

In that case you’d be better with a windows 10 OS along side your linux one.

If something like Easy Anti Cheat doesn’t work on one Distro, it won’t work on another either (Spoiler: it works on no Distro at all). The reason is simply because the game and hence the anti-cheat runs under WINE, and that is the same on every Distro. There might be version differences but those can be “fixed” by using a different repository then the standard one.

If you need Anticheat support you will need a Windows install (either natively or virtualised, which is a whole different discussion), there is just no way around that for the foreseeable future. WINE imitates being Windows, but it is not Windows. Anticheat is mainly looking at modified API files and since WINE is not using (and cannot use for various reasons) the “real” Windows files, it will always be detected as a cheat, that’s just the nature of how they work. So until we get Anticheats that recognise WINE as its own Entity and check for WINEs validity in matters of cheats, we will always have that issue.


So, for the question at hand. IMO there’s not really a “best” Distro, for anything, period. Some Distros are better at things then other Distros are, that’s just the nature of it.
That being said, I’m with @Eden here.

Ubuntu (and it’s Derivatives like the -buntus, Mint, pop_OS) is probably the Distro to look at purely from a support perspective. Ubuntu is always one of the first things that pops up when looking for any kind of issue online and there’s almost always a solution.
Personally, I don’t like Ubuntu (including derivatives), simply because I always had weird issues with it even just using the system-provided tools. I ran with Fedora more then a year back and I haven’t had any major issues yet. Fedora has more up-to-date software, but it is not quite as bleeding edge as Arch/Manjaro. Starting with Manjaro can be fine, if you know what you’re getting into. Anything Arch-based can potentially break at any time due to a software version that was pushed too early, and if you don’t know how to fix it you’re out of luck.

One general thing since you already mentioned 2 Linux Distros in parallel: Make a separate partition for your /home directory, most installers will give you that option right away. This makes it way less painful if you first want to find the Distro for you since all your settings are carried over between Distros if you don’t accidentally delete your /home.

1 Like

For your use-case, I always recommend dual-booting Windows 10 and a Linux distro of your choice.

I tried out the linux gaming scene a few years ago and wasn’t satisfied with it. Some games work fine, some need troubleshooting, some are just impossible. Proton is promising but not perfect (haven’t tried it myself) and VM’s with GPU passthrough are…way too much work. I would expect mixed results if you try to avoid Windows entirely. As mentioned, many games are only tested on Ubuntu (if at all), but other distros should be compatible, some additional troubleshooting notwithstanding.

As for distro choice, it doesn’t really matter. The best thing is to try a few until you know what you like; they’re all free, and distro-hopping isn’t as much work as you think (esp. with a separate /home). I find debian-based distros easier to work with since so much software is available as a deb package but not as an rpm—you have to build from source or use flatpak etc much more often. Troubleshooting issues will be nearly, if not exactly, identical between all versions and forks of Ubuntu, which makes it easier to get started without much experience.

To respond to your points specifically:

  • Linus is probably over-selling Linux gaming a bit to drive clicks (don’t hate the player, hate the game). I’m sure things have improved somewhat over the years, but the open-source community is too fragmented and disorganized to go from zero to viable in 3–4 years. I think the biggest step forward is Proton, which wasn’t even pitched by the FOSS community.
  • Ubuntu is the best choice for linux gaming but you can forge your own path on any distro you want. You will still have plenty of issues on Ubuntu.
  • I learned how to manage my linux box by using it, not really by following a guide. As you tweak settings and fix problems, you’ll naturally get used to the CLI, learn the major parts of the system, etc. Most distros are fully usable without CLI knowledge (not Arch).
  • Not familiar with Easy Anti Cheat but it’s been addressed.
  • Your drive setup will be fine afaik. I don’t hear about issues with RAID on linux often, and it’s an important feature for enterprise so you would hope it works, right? Especially if it’s hardware raid. You will be able to verify this in the installer probably.
  • I don’t know anybody who dual-boots two different distros. If you really hate Ubuntu, but have games that only work on it and refuse to touch Windows 10, it might work. I would use the RAID array as /home, and leave everything else on the respective NVME partition (i.e. /, root, mounts on an NVME partition).

As mentioned, you will a much easier time by running a separate Windows 10 install for games only (or any other Windows-only software), and doing everything else on Linux. However, it’s up to you whether or not that’s acceptable.

Hello, have you considered passing through your gpu and use win10 as per usual and use lookinglass?

Just do Pop OS or Ubuntu.

i’d recommend Pop over Ubuntu.

Don’t mess with manjaro or any other rolling release / bleeding edge things. Your hardware doesn’t need it

For tutorials on getting stuff running, I would suggest reading up on Lutris, also Steam and turning on Proton.

As per Eden - Ubuntu is the most well tested and will offer the best out of the box experience at the moment.

This may change, and there may be obscure edge cases if you have particularly bleeding edge hardware, where you can get better performance from something more bleeding edge but there is generally more work involved.

Short version: Start with Ubuntu LTS (18.04 i think at the moment?) and see how you go. Once you get more familiar with Linux and think there may be a reason to change, then consider changing.

Ubuntu really is the path of least resistance for this stuff.

edit:
or Pop! which is basically the same

That’s hardly a noob friendly exercise, and IMHO if starting out i’d just try and get most stuff working via Lutris/Wine/Native first and accept that some things won’t work without some fair amount of screwing around when you get more experience.

I wouldn’t recommend tackling pass-through until you’ve got some reasonable linux exposure under your belt and are a bit more comfortable with the platform in general.

edit:
On the flip-side from the compromises you may need to make with Windows games, i’d highly recommend getting Lutris (to help run windows games as well) and playing with some retro platforms. Lutris is great for retrogaming.

Lutris is great for any kind of gaming, in my expirince on arch runs pretty fine, no issues for 1 year now, only thing i dislike is non unified mono installs so it has to redownload but thats on wine-s side tho

Also, passthtough isn’t the best option, but it is one that can/'nt enable playing drm games

That is getting fixed with WINE 5.0:

https://www.winehq.org/announce/5.0

  • The Gecko and Mono add-ons support shared installation, where the
    files are used directly from a global location under /usr/share/wine
    instead of being copied into every new prefix.
1 Like

ARCH is good for testing bleeding edge stuff and applying fixes/patches with relative ease. However people should be aware that Manjaro and some other distro’s enforce a stricter driver deployment method which can prevent the easy testing of BETA released drivers.

Currently I’m using EndeavourOS which is fine but their default WM XFCE4 has some issues such as poor font representation under WINE apps. (and other things which I forget now). Currently I use this with Plasma5, never seems to fail me! (WM choices are available in their ONLINE installer)

I highly support switching to Linux. So I hope you have fun.

I’ll echo everyone else and say you should go with Ubuntu. I’ve been using it since Warty Warthog (the first release) and it has generally just worked for me. Any time I ran into issues it was due to me messing around with things. And I’d say it’s been more stable than Windows over the years.

All that said, you will run into times when you need Windows. It’s really really annoying, but we’re a long way away from being able to ditch it entirely. So instead of two linux distros, I’d suggest dual booting with Windows 10. (Remember, you can just run it without activating it.)

Make Ubuntu your main OS, though. Once past the learning curve, it is much more fun than Windows. Eventually you can jump into virtualizing Windows with GPU passthrough, but I’d suggest sticking with a simple dual boot at first.

As for good resources for learning… Google your questions. Look for results from Ubuntu forum topics, Stack Exchange sites, and the Ubuntu wiki. (If you use a non-Ubuntu based distro, look for their forums and wiki.)

When lost, ask on a forum. Don’t let anyone get you down with replies that are curt or feel like they’re just saying “read the manual”. I still get those, and I’ve been running Linux as a System Administrator for over 10 years. I firmly believe that there is no such thing as a stupid question. Just do your best to answer your question on your own first.

Have fun!

2 Likes

To add to this, if you need Windows for non-gaming uses, install virt-manager and try running it in a KVM/QEMU virtual machine.

KVM is solid, and its the way i run all my instances of Windows at the moment for the few windows only things i need (mostly windows remote admin tools for work).

Windows gaming you also can do with QEMU/KVM and video card pass-through as suggested above, but its a bit more of an advanced topic with some caveats to consider (like, you need more hardware and to compile some stuff).

1 Like

I want to chime in as a normal desktop user, I don’t bother with anything I can’t run out of the native steam client. No VM’s, nothing. I honestly don’t have that many issues, and you aren’t going to get any better performance from one distro to another for gaming specifically.

What you choose in a distro is your workflow.

2 Likes

Apologies for late reply, things got really busy on my end.

Something I guess I forgot to mentioned is that I would cascade my gaming from trying Native -> Proton -> Lutris -> VM. With trying VM, not from the get go but eventually.

Thanks for all the respond they actually helped a lot and with a discussion I had with someone I’ll drop the dual boot, I understand now that there’s no point. I’m still looking into it but I’m thinking I’ll go with Pop OS.

I thing I’m still not sure about something however that will have to do with the VM, do I need 2 GPUs for a VM or is it best with the solution Wendell has shown multiple time (name escape me)? The person I talked to said that’s probably unneeded but that might have been for more generic VM solution rather than trying to have a full gaming setup.

The “thing” that Wendell “tried” was probably GPU Passthrough via VFIO you’re talking about and that is the solution that needs 2 GPUs (at least if you also want desktop usage), since 1 GPU is passed through to the VM, and 1 GPU stays in the Host system.
You can technically do a VM build with just one GPU but then you would have either no Desktop on the Host, or would need 2 boot options where one loads the GPU driver for desktop usage and the other doesn’t.

I´m not fully sure but, since his particular setup is a 9900k
I suppose he could eventually do a vm with gpu passtrough with just one gpu.
Because the 9900k has an igpu.

But yeah for a starter it might not be the best thing to start out with maybe.

Anyway i think starting out with something Ubuntu base or Fedora,
would be a good place to start.

1 Like

Yes, though personally I do count that as “2 GPUs” :stuck_out_tongue: What I meant is that it is technically possible with only one GPU as well.

1 Like

Fair enough. :grinning:

1 Like