Return to Level1Techs.com

Linux Munich Crisis; doesn't look good

I'm surpirsed to not see this on L1 news or on this forum.

A decade ago, Munich was at the vanguard of a movement towards open-source software, switching thousands of staff to Linux from Windows at a time when a move on that scale was almost unheard of.

After spending nine years and millions of euros on the project, today the city's politicians agreed to begin preparing to return to Windows by 2021.

Under a proposal backed by the general council, the administration will investigate how long it will take and how much it will cost to build a Windows 10 client for use by the city's employees.

Once this work is complete, the council will vote again on whether to replace LiMux, a custom version of the Linux-based OS Ubuntu, across the authority from 2021.

There is quite a bit to this story, although I haven't really looked into it that much, but it includeds...

  • a newly elected mayor of Munich who "apparently" hates free software and is a self confessed Microsoft fanboy.
  • a study into the the Munich's current IT problems, conducted by Accenture, who were 'Microsoft's Alliance Partner of the Year 2016'.
  • early indications that Accenture are recommending Windows 10
  • an iterim realease of the Accenture report ( in German) that actually shows Accenture did not only not recommend Windows but found under resourced IT departments and issues that didn't directly relate to Limux.
  • open letters form FOSS advocates/companies; open letter from The Document Foundation - Libre Office
  • other related factors include Microsoft recently relocating their German corporate HQ to Munich
4 Likes

Munich's ditching of FOSS is just a small drop in the bucket. Many countries and cities out in the world use Linux, for either government, or public use. Venezuela, Turkey and North Korea all have their own distros.

On Wikipedia their is a page that documents the countries and cities that use Linux in some fashion. That page can be found here.

Yeah from my understanding Microsoft moved to town, there some higher ups who like Microsoft, the study that was done was done by a Microsoft company.

It's like the 90s again.

1 Like

This seems to be somewhat of a big deal as apparently Munich was the poster child for possibilities of FOSS; not in the server world, but in the desktop world.

There small examples though, there's many gov orgs who've moved to Linux over the world.

You have to hand it to Accenture though. It appears they did an impartial job as the report does not put Linux as the root causes of Munich's IT problems. *Apparently their report even shows that MS software has similar issues.

*edit

Yeah that's true. Though you'd look at the news and assume the report said Linux root cause of all problems.

Really makes you wonder how they get away with spinning things like that.

1 Like

I didn't get that feeling. Not in many reports from the last week anyway (which was when the Accentrue report broke).

What headlines gave you that impression?

We can't look at the news and assume anymore. Hell we were probably never able to do it in the first place.

1 Like

"Hi we'll open a shop in your town and hire some of your grads if you switch back to MS."

Guessing that's how that conversation went.

2 Likes

Not to mention the most of aftica uses linux where there isn't much for IT. The internet boats that travel the rivers are pretty fascinating to research about.

1 Like

One wonders if Microsoft, or their surrogate, contributed to the mayor's election campaign ...

1 Like

Yup sounds more like MS is pulling out the trojan horse. Nokia tactics all over again.

"For 80% of the workstations running in Munich, the operating system
doesn't matter," he said, adding that if the council agrees to replace
LiMux with Windows at the same time as restructuring IT, "the problems
will be solved and it looks like Windows has solved them, but it won't
have".

You got to admire the evil genius behind this...

you just named three fascist countries....not sure I'd want those three countries representing Linux

Nothing wrong with anyone using Linux. They use windows too..

Im not sure why they make their own distros any way, I actually think its a bad idea. They should use distros with support and customise them with supported tools. Far easier to maintain.

1 Like

And then again in 2006, and 2008 with Office OpenXML.

Totalitarian actually. Not fascist....And no it is not the same thing and the distinction is important in the grand scheme of things...

Can you be a Totalitarian without being a fascist? Heck the term and definition was conceived by fascists.

Anyway, where is @Zoltan ? He probably has a more direct view of what is going on

1 Like

Of course you can...Totalitarianism is a system of Governance. Fascism is only one type of a Totalitarian system with a specific political position. Fascism legalizes the totalitarian nature of the state by presenting it as a representative of a superior race, religion and culture in general. You can justify a Totalitarian system without using racial or cultural criteria. North Korea for example is actually an anti-fascist regime and completely rejects the definition of superiority based on race and justifies its totalitarian nature as a method of social engineering to create an equal classes-less system (the same way every pseudo-communist regime justified it in the past).

EDIT: And i think the earlier use of the terms was used by leftists in order to criticize the soviet regimes.

1 Like

Because 909% of the general population doesn't know that it's being spun like that.

The news doesn't inform people, it gives them bias. That's the intent these days.