LiFePo4 Drop in for UPS - Please help understanding V, C-capacity, A, VA

Hello everyone, I have obtained a used APC SMT1000RMI2U UPS without batteries for a decent price. I’ve already ordered and installed 12 V LiFePo4 packs which allow operation of the device. Those work in a 2S2P configuration which results in a nominal 24 V operation.
Out of curiosity i’ve checked for 24 V models of LiFePo4 packs and stumbled across two models by TalentCell: LF8011 (6Ah) and LF0800401 (4 Ah)

They are labeled with “[email protected]” / “[email protected]” and “Max discharge current: 10A / 5A” respectively.

From what I’ve read, that would result in 6 Ah * 0.2 C = 1.2 A. Which is far from the claimed 10 amps on the label.
This comes down to 1.2 A * 24 V = 28.8 VA instead of 10 A * 24 V = 240 VA.
(Dont’t get me wrong, the 28.8 VA are by far more realistic from everything I’ve read. I’m just wondering.)

Could anyone of the fine people here explain that discrepancy to me?

Thank you very much.

This is not a good idea, APCs tend to have high float voltages and I don’t recalling being able to adjust them on this particular UPS. The best case senario you can hope for with this high float is a significantly reduced service life of the batteries.

3 Likes

At max. continuous current (i.e. 10A), you will get less capacity out of the pack than at lower current (e.g. the 0.2C listed here). It will do the 240W no problem, but you won’t get the pack’s listed capacity if you do use it that way.

4 Likes

Thanks for the warning. Is that also true for packs with integrated BMS, like the ones i’ve used?

My typical load is at around 200 Watts. As the UPS is a line-interactive model, the batteries will only be used in case of a power loss as far as I understood it. And those don’t happen very often here. Is my assumption correct?

*it depends.
Theoretically a BMS could prevent issues, but in practice I’ve noticed BMS overvoltage protections don’t trip at normal lead acid float charge levels which can lead to the degradation.

2 Likes

I’ll be honest I know very little about the ins and outs of UPSs… I just know about batteries

1 Like

@nibbs is correct, the line interactive UPSes just let normal mains power through to the devices on it and will only switch to batteries when a brownout/blackout happens… The caveat to this is that the more professional line interactive UPSes will periodically go into a self test mode (perhaps once every 24 hours, it depends their firmware) that tests the batteries by switching to them which does exercise them more.

1 Like

Thanks @twin_savage for mentioning the “float voltage” issue, which I was not aware of - with that, I’ve found a few sources describing the methodology for changing it in the APC-UPS’s. I may take a look into it later.
For the the moment i will leave it at that. When the batteries die, I may use other packs/cells. Maybe by then, there will be options from power station manufacturers which will be a suitable replacement.

1 Like

6 Ah @ 0.2C is a capacity rating and 10A is a maximum current rating. You’re correct that the capacity rating is taken at a gentle 1.2A discharge rate over 5 hours (1 / 0.2 = 5) but the battery can also be discharged more quickly at it’s maximum rate of 10A while remaining within its rated specifications.

1 Like

ahhh if you can adjust the float voltage low enough, this should alleviate the problem. Many manufactures tend to hide this functionality behind “secret” menus or not offer it at all.

Being able to adjust the float voltage was originally intended to allow you to adapt 3rd party manufacture’s lead acid batteries to an UPS since optimal voltage differs by manufacturer.
There is a perverse incentive to not offer/expose this feature to force end user’s into buying “genuine” UPS batteries from the original manufacture (at a high markup of course).

3 Likes

Well, it’s not a documented procedure and was discovered by reverse engineering from what I understand, which will void the warranty of course. This won’t be an issue anyway as it’s a used system that’s well over ten years old. For the moment I will use it as is and finish some other projects and possibly dive into in the winter.

Capacity (to do work) is measured in ampere-hours, how many amps can be supplied for a given time duration. In this case, 6 amps for 1 hour, or 3 amps for 2 hours, etc. However, this is an incomplete metric as losses (both internal and external) increase at successively higher amperage discharges, and so as to qualify, the discharge rate must be specified.

At no time should the discharge rate exceed a 10A rate, according to the manufacturer.

As mentioned, Capacity, is C. The units for C are (1/t) or in this case 1/hr. And so 0.2C is 0.2 (1/hr) * 6 Ah = 1.2 A. This means that the battery is rated to provide 6Ah of total capacity at a 1.2 A discharge rate (for 5 hours). Discharging at a higher rate will reduce the overall usable capacity, i.e. discharging at 6A will likely not result in 1 hour of life (maybe something more like 45 minutes but without more data, impossible to predict). Correspondingly, discharging at less than 1.2A will likely provide more than 6Ah of total usable capacity. Again, how much more cannot be accurately predicted without more information.

We can think of VA as Watts (W), the difference being watts is real power, whereas VA is apparent power. I will not delve into the nuances of such, as it beyond the scope of my reply. Suffice it to say, for what is nearly a purely resistive load (where the power factor is very near 1), VA and W ratings will be effectively the same.

Power delivered is A times V (at the load), making 1.2A * 24V (=28.8W) the recommend load for a 1.2A discharge at start of discharge. Keep in mind that as batteries discharge their output voltage decreases, and so for a constant power application (for example, at 28.8W draw) the amperage will increase over time – as voltage goes down, “current” goes up for an equivalent power delivery. What this means is that the battery will start at 1.2A delivery but will increase over the duration of the discharge, effectively exceeding the rated 0.2C, lessening the rated capacity, as it is a function of amperage.

The data point given to you of “[email protected]” is just a point. In order to more accurately estimate runtime, a discharge curve is required; perhaps available buried deeper in the product specs. The best you can do is estimate runtime and even with the discharge curve will have to integrate over time to get a more precise result (which would also require the voltage discharge curve for the underlying cells used in construction of the battery unit).

Best practice is to oversize your UPS for whatever may be the intended application while simultaneously taking into consideration both expected runtime and power delivery requirements.

Hope this helps.

Note: Lots of edits due to lots of type-o’s.

1 Like

Hey just a heads up, but you may need to worry about current mismatch causing issues when running these packs in parallel.

Since each pack is slightly different than the others due to manufacturing tolerances, one could trip over-current or over-discharge protection and put twice the load on the second set of batteries.

Most of these packs don’t have a very good BMS, so it could release the magic smoke and fail to protect the cells from damage.

You may want to find a battery pack solution that can support the rated power output of your UPS, or ensure that you never apply a load that exceeds the combined power of the packs.

In addition, be aware that LiFePo4 cells are not self-balancing. They require electronic balancing (usually built-in to most BMS circuits) that dissipates excess power as heat when charging. If your float voltage is not within the range of this circuit, it’ll either never apply balancing, or trip out because the voltage or current was too high.

There’s also the possibility of issues with multiple packs in series too. If one battery trips protection before the others, it may not come back without applying a load or external voltage to the pack to reset it.

2 Likes

Thank you very much, for the comprehensive explanation. Very much appreciated. :slight_smile:

Thank you for the advice, @daveMeister! I think, that was the initial impulse for looking further for other battery packs (with 24 V), as with that, at least the series-problem would be mitigated. That’s how I stumbled across the TalentCell packs. I still wouldn’t know the quality of the cells and the BMS so it’s rather “meh”.

I also entertained the idea of building a pack myself for a stupid second, but that’s far beyond my knowledge. So I am still contemplating the best route to take. My favorite drop in solution would be a pack, build out of prismatic cells @ 24 V with a good quality BMS and active balancing. But of course those are not available in the needed shape and connectors to just put in into the UPS, just too niche.

Guess, I will try to find a service who could build that mid-term.

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 273 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.