Is Xlibre really that bad?

So doing this more that once would be a bad idea? How many similar projects do you think would support Wayland. The plan is to have 50 or more Xlibre-esc applications.

Yeah, XFree86 would never survive with just volunteer contributions.

Also, like I’ve been saying… These developers do not work for free, my GPU $$$ is used to pay for DRM/KMS/GEM development.

We have at least 30 years worth of data, if you can’t draw conclusions from that… You are just avoiding drawing conclusions.

1 Like

One issue with running Xlibre is that the FDO community will shadow ban you for it? I hope I’m just too sensitive, if that’s not what happened someone can reply to my accusation here.

1 Like

Old thread, I know.. but the inevitable seems to have happened. The people at Artix using Xlibre figured out Xlibre is just a rage-fork without actual development or bug fixing. Shocking!

Besides the usual drama (everyone calling everyone woke), there seem to be tons of bugs and no actual plan to actually fix Xlibre.

I actually do enjoy the drama and read a few Reddit posts. Wow. I enjoy my distro (where I have no idea what boot system or window server is uses) because it works. But I chuckle seeing all the people suffering because they choose their distro just to make a political or ideological point.

I think Xlibre is/was just an ambitious rage project. It attracted a lot of political fans, but not actually good developers or maintainers. As it turns out, getting a lot of Reddit traction isn’t the same as delivering a good product.

3 Likes

This is the kind of Meat this thread is looking for, it’s just unfortunate that if you think about any of these points for more than 30s they fall apart. Here is how/why:

  1. Form that story the issues were not sent upstream… so of course, in that case, it’s up to Artix alone to fix the issues
  2. The opinion of one group is not “by itself” evidence
  3. Xlibre team is anti-woke, they seem to believe if they choose not to decide they have not made a choice – Rush
  4. Choosing Linux is an ideological choice and there is no getting around this; why do you insist on mixing thoughts and politics
  5. I’ve responded to this already, Wayland’s core design makes this 50x worse by splitting the X11 Server into 50 Compositors that are now each supported separately
  6. Even if true, wayland has no good developers either; I’ve already proved this so I won’t rehash it here
  7. The same is true of Wayland; being popular is not synonymous with being good, see MS-Windows

Edit: Also didn’t you know, Xlibre works perfectly! I’ve been running it for months now and there isn’t a single issue, so Artix users are just showing their Skill Issue – Channeling my inner Wayland Supporter

1 Like

I have been using xlibre for over 6 minths.
Gaming with is seams smoother. I don’t have time to run FPS and frame timing tests but my subjective anectdotal evidence suports xlibre resulting in a more stable and smooth FPS.
I’m using arch with the official xlibre repo for arch and sonic desktop.

I’ve not noticed any difference in framerate between X11 and Wayland, they both work fine.

Locking the mouse cursor to the window works better with X11, with Wayland I could force the mouse to leave the window. It’s only an issue if you use multiple monitors, and using gamescope does solve the issue. Not the end of the world, but still annoying.

I love this about minor issues with Wayland. My comment about how “Xlibre works for me” was meant to mock all the people who always say “Wayland is a usable solution because it works for them.” We are just supposed to forget about pesky things like testing everyone’s use case or setup, those are an afterthought(if it registers at all) to the people who push Wayland and that should just be mocked at every opportunity.

Is it really impossible, since Apr 2009, for GPU manufacturers to keep their code secret? I wonder when the law goes into effect.