Is this a good burn in option for my first TrueNAS system? (badblocks)

Debating on which exact test to run.

Supposedly this one is a good middle ground, would take 2-3 days for each batch of 3 drives tested.

Would running this badblocks test, that’s ~2 passes, be a good solution? Or what do you guys think?:

  • badblocks -nsv (badblocks non-destructive)

  • 3 drives at a time (out of 6 total, to prevent overheating system)

Exact command I’d run (for 3 drives):

badblocks -nsv -b 4096 -c 65536 /dev/sda &
badblocks -nsv -b 4096 -c 65536 /dev/sdb &
badblocks -nsv -b 4096 -c 65536 /dev/sdc &

My specs:

  • Case: Cooler Master HAF 922

  • CPU: AMD Ryzen PRO 4750G

  • Motherboard: ASRock B550 Pro4

  • RAM: 64GB UDIMM ECC (2 x 32GB Kingston KSM26ED8/32HC 2666 CL19 ECC 288 PC4)

  • NAS HDD Hard Drives: 6 x WD Ultrastar DC HC580 WUH722424ALE604 0F62798 24TB 7.2K RPM SATA 6Gb/s 512e 3.5in Recertified Hard Drive

  • Mirrored Boot OS SATA SSDs: 2 x Intel SSD DC S3700 200GB (used enterprise gear)

  • Fans

    • Front: Noctua NF-A20 PWM (200mm x 30mm Fan)

    • Rear: NF-A12x25 G2 PWM (120mm x 25mm)

    • Bottom: NF-A14x25 G2 PWM

    • PCI-e Cooling: Noctua NF-A9 PWM 92mm Fan

  • HBA Card: LSI 9305-16i

  • PSU: Corsair RM850x

Just run a long/extended smart test on each drive, you’re still concerned just do a pass with dd using a sane blocksize.

1 Like

The thing I would want to know is this:

Can I read back the same data that I’ve written.

In that regard a non-destructive test is somewhat lacking.

Personally I’ve opted to just write my data and run a scrub / verify occasionally.

I like the smart test idea too though.

I have a few layers of software block antics going on so I like the e2e nature of restic check --read-data and other high level validations, (a ZFS/btrfs scrub is sort of a middle level validation.)

1 Like

Smart long test only does a full read test, I believe.

you don’t need the non-destructive option on new empty drives. Non-destructive is for drives with data you’d want to keep.

I don’t think it makes sense testing drives 3 at a time. If all drives running overheats you need better cooling, since I assume you’ll use some kind of redundant raid and probably the drives will run at the same time in real use too. See it as a test of your cooling setup..

personally I’ve done a single badblocks test on new drives and then a scrub after filling them. Two full passes with large drives is a lot and takes ages. But if you have the time and motivation why not?

1 Like