Are you sure the Whining isn’t coming from other components?
I have a friend who also has the reference and he says his is fine. I haven’t tested it with a stethoscope but putting my head inside the case next to the GPU is the loudest.
I think I’ve decided that I’m going to go through with the return and look at 4080 cards. Leaning towards Founders or a Gigabyte Gaming OC.
Since you’ve ruled out basically everything else, it’s most likely your electrical at the wall. You could look into getting a power conditioner or a double-conversion (aka online) UPS.
So replace yours with the reference Model and that will be that.
These cards will far outlast Nvidia anyway and lots of those also have the same issues with Coil whine…
Already using a UPS, not sure I mentioned it or not.
Double conversion?
What kind of UPS? When does the coil whine start?
What model 7900XTX do you have?
Its a Cybperpower 1500va unit. I somewhat recently replaced the batteries in it.
I’ve had three 7900 XTX cards. A reference AMD card that had the coil whine and hotspot issue, then two Asrock Taichi 7900 XTX cards.
as someone who was a hobby miner and has owned hundreds of GPUs, coil whine is more to do with power than the GPU itself. and a UPS can actually make crappy power worse.
a good power supply, a correctly grounded circuit, and either a real surge suppressor, or no power strip at all, will help eliminate coil whine the most.
some GPUs are more tolerant of bad power than others are. unless the GPU is failing, coil whine is not initiated at the GPU, it is power related. but even a high dollar PSU may not eliminate power issues if your house electrical is 99v instead of 108v.
Thanks for the insight! I was curious how much of an issue it was for people who have higher quantities of cards resulting in more experience/data points. Youtubers like Wendell or LTT come to mind but miners would count there too.
As far as I’m aware the power here is fairly good. No sign of brownouts or any other issues. I suppose it may be possible the UPS I’m using is causing issues. My roommate is using the same model but his batteries are older.
I’ve boxed up the card to go back to Newegg but I will maybe give it one more try connected directly to the wall without the UPS to see what happens. I’ve tried the card in two computers but I have a third that may be able to handle it that I can try but its an i7 4770 based system so pairing it with a 7900 XTX to see if the card whines will be interesting.
The power supply I have is 1000w platinum and my roommate has a 850w gold. So theoretically they should be fine. I’m not going to run out and buy a 1500w titanium unit for this.
Assuming Newegg approves my return I’m looking at either a Founders 4080 or a Gigabyte Gaming OC 4080.
I realize it really is a lottery and vendor/brand doesn’t matter but I’m just tired and want something reasonably quiet. I’ve tried three AMD cards with no luck so I’ll see what Nvidia does.
see if anyone you know has a multimeter and stick it in the wall outlet to find what the actual volts in the system are, as an example my house shows 125v. then if you really want to see what is going on you can also get a watt meter and see what wattage you pull under load and calculate amperage and even get a little bit of an idea of if you are seeing more voltage droop under load.
my guess is a multimeter will show the house power is on the lower side of what 110v systems should be. mine at 125v is on the high side.
My guess is that this is not one of the line-interactive or double conversion models, so it’s not actually conditioning your power at all, just providing standby power if mains goes offline.
This is the specific unit I have. It does seem like it just has surge+battery without anything else.
I do have a multimeter but its not a great one and I’ve never used it on AC before so I may just take your word on that.
Its one I use on Arduino/Raspberry Pi stuff.
I’m going to see what my roommates computer with the 2080 does without the UPS and directly connected to the wall. I’ll also see about turning as much stuff with the shared circuit as possible.
you could also find the breaker in the place that the computer is hooked up to and switch it off and see if any major appliances turn off too. you really do not want the PC on the same circuit as a microwave or refrigerator, or even a big TV.
Just took a look at the panel and there isn’t anything major on the same circuit. I’ll take a look again later today with my roommates system to see how the coil whine in that computer changes based on where and how its plugged in.
Easier to use that computer right now since the 7900 XTX is already packaged up and his computer has the 2080 with coil whine.
Wether it whines or not may also be a thing about age of the reviewer. If you are young, ie under 40, you can hear frequencies that us older people can not.
Did one more final test with my computer and a friend’s R9 380X as it was the only thing I have to test. I put it in my 7700X system and ran Core Keeper (only game I could get to run over 100fps at the time) and I could hear a faint whine from it when connected to the UPS and main power.
So this makes me think either my main power is faulty in some way which I honestly doubt, or there is something else in my system causing it - likely power supply or motherboard. I would expect coil whine in games but not at 100fps.
Have you tried taking your PC to your friends house and try their outlet
The friend with the 380X is 2 hours away, so not yet. Next time I’m there I may take my computer with me just to see what it does.
I’m going to look at getting a 4080 assuming the refund goes through. I think I’m going to get stuck with coil whine on it too - the question is how much. With my luck its going to be worse.