HP Proliant 380p + expander backplane cant boot from HBA

Good afternoon, everyone. Could anyone please share their experience?

I have an HP ProLiant DL380p Gen8 with a 25-bay expander backplane. It is intended for use as a Ceph server, so an HBA has been installed—an LSI 9217.

All attempts to make it boot reliably from anything other than an HP RAID controller have failed.

What we tried:

  • LSI 9217 in IT mode — it refuses to boot at all, possibly because of incompatibility with the backplane. The HBA detects all drives as if they were in slot 0 or slot 50. It is also impossible to enter the LSI configuration utility because of a known HP Gen8 bug that causes an NMI error.

  • HP H240 in HBA mode — does not boot, and mixed mode is not available.

  • LSI 9217 in IR mode with a bootable logical drive — boots only intermittently. After a hard reset, the server starts normally. After rebooting from within the OS, it does not detect the system drives under “Hard Drive C:”.

The only controller firmware version on which anything worked at all was P14.

I’ve had similar issues with Dell Poweredge servers and HBA/SATA controller cards

Some things I’d recommend trying:

  • With iLO 4 access, validate that the card shows up in the hardware inventory (might not be a thing as I only have iLO 5/iDRAC experience)
  • In BIOS, disable any raid options as most servers also come with its own software raid solution
  • Set anything regarding storage to AHCI mode
  • Try booting in BIOS and UEFI modes and enable option ROM if available in BIOS settings
  • insert a known good drive into the server connected to the HBA and boot a live Linux USB and see if the drive shows up
  • Might be a SMBus issue, tape the B5 and B6 PCIe pins on the card with either electrical or kapton tape (for the LSI card)
  • In the BIOS, try to manually add an UEFI boot entry and see if it sees any of the INITIALIZED drives in the file selection
  • Watch the boot process, it might display an error if the system doesn’t like the card
  • Perform firmware updates on the system, including iLO, CPLD, BIOS,…
  • Try a different PCIe slot and different cables
  • Disable auto detect of PCIe bifubricarion and set it to full speed of the slot, PCIe link training should still occur

Unfortunately some servers will just not boot with a non-branded HBA or AHCI/SATA controller card. Had the same issue when upgrading from Poweredge T140 to R440 where a known SATA card from the T140 did not boot or show up in the R440.

1 Like

I managed to solve this problem: i bought HP H220 HBA(literally same LSI 9217 but with HP firmware) - it identified drive bays correctly AND it does not suffer from aforementioned LSI 9217 + Gen8 bug, so i was able to enter its bios via Ctrl+C on boot and pin boot and alt boot drives

Also some notes:

  • LSI 9300 allowed entering its bios via Ctrl+C, but also did not enumerate drives correctly, making all appear in slot 0 - therefore marking one drive as boot makes all drives marked as boot and as far as i know, it will fail on first(i guess random) boot device and not retry

  • Making LSI 9300 and 9217 bootable IS possible, however it required vibecoded script to edit bios and setting boot disks via sas address, not the official bay:enclosure way

  • rebooting “reliably” with LSI 9217 in IR mode was made possible with systemd hook that triggered hw reset via hponcfg

2 Likes

Just in case:
In conversations in related telegram chats, person showed exact same setup working with 9300 and 9200 controller, versions he shared:

HPE DL 380p G8
Serial Attached SCSI controller: Broadcom / LSI SAS2308 PCI-Express Fusion-MPT SAS-2 (rev 05)
mpt2sas_cm0: LSISAS2308: FWVersion(20.00.06.00), ChipRevision(0x05)

mpt2sas_cm0: LSISAS2308: FWVersion(20.00.07.00), ChipRevision(0x05), BiosVersion(07.39.02.00)

I updated bios, but didnt work for me