How to set up multiple Yubikeys for the same Arch user?

I’m struggeling to set both keys up. I generated the data using pamu2fcfg and wrote it to .config/Yubico/u2f_keys

I tried it like this:

user:handle1,publickey1,es256,+presence
user:handle2,publickey2,es256,+presence

but then only the last key works.

I also tried it like this:

user:handle1,publickey1,es256,+presence,handle2,publickey2,es256,+presence

but then only the first key works.

What am I do wrong in order that both can be used to authenticate?