How to decide between HDMI and DP KVM?

I’m trying to decide the “best” KVM to purchase & can’t figure out if the HDMI or DP version is better.

I have 4 computers & 2 monitors, so I’ve narrowed it down to either the:

  • 1.4 Display Port KVM Switch - Dual Monitor - Four Computer
  • HDMI 2.1 KVM w/EDID & Serial Control - Dual Monitor - Four Computer

I have 4 computers split between Linux & Mac, but could swap one Mac for Windows if/when I switch jobs:

  • Ubuntu: 2 Display Port, 2 HDMI (RX 580 graphics card)
  • Ubuntu: 1 Display Port, 1 HDMI, 1 DVI-D, 1 VGA (old PC that is rarely used)
  • m4 Mac mini: 2 Display Port (USB-C/thunderbolt), 1 HMDI
  • m4 MacBook Air : 2 Display Port (USB-C/thunderbolt) (work laptop, so it may switch to Windows at some point)

I don’t play games, but I watch videos occasionally. I’m leaning towards the HDMI version for 2 reasons:

  1. it’s less expensive to get DP or USB-C to HDMI adapters than the other way around
  2. HDMI 2.1 has more raw bandwidth

I think the downside of the HDMI option is DP natively supports adaptive sync, but I don’t know how important that is.

Am I on the right track? I want to make sure I get this right. Thank you

Inquiring minds want to know. I have this same problem. Does anyone have a recommendation?

I went with the HDMI 2.1 version. For me the determining factor was the cable cost & ease of converting:

  • It costs about $25 for a good Thunderbolt/USBC to HDMI cable, but to DP was $70. Given the number of cables that I needed for 2 Macs, it was a big cost difference.
  • it’s less expensive to get DP or USB-C to HDMI adapters than HDMI to DP

I worked with support & received the following message from them which guided me in this direction:
The only issue with HDMI is that USBC → HDMI 2.1 connectors are tricky. USBC → HDMI tends to be limited to HDMI 2.0, which is 4K 60Hz.

There are special Mac HDMI 2.1 adapters being made like this one from Cable Matters, though:

It is easier to convert DisplayPort to HDMI though as you said so that is a positive & this is one of the few of its kind

For DisplayPort,
You will need 2x USBC to DisplayPort cables like these for the Mac Mini, and 2x for the MacBook Air:

This is correct! I feel like I helped write this :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye: Ie. I think you reached out via email?

1 Like