So, I could use some advise. I have Verizon Fios 1 Gb ISP service that has it own wifi, bu then goes down to my basement to a 1Gb unmanaged switch, of which one of the ports goes to my office to yet another router (1Gb) that router goes to my machines. Also have another 1Gb unmanaged switch in the office as well. Anyway, I was looking to upgrade to 5Gb internet from fios, therefore I would need 2 small switches, 6-8 ports. My main two computers have 1 Gb via the mother boards, but my server has am unused, copper Mellanox CX346A-BCQN Rev B7 QSFP+ dual 40 Gb card in it. So while, I would not be against getting an small inexpensive 10Gb switch (I think I would need 2 or at least 1 in the basement, but that would leave my Mellanox ConnectX-3 Pro not fully utilized. Then the whole debate of Copper versus optical or 10Gb Ethernet? So, what could my inexpensive options be for two switches of the same, or different ones? Maybe just connect my main two machines with direct copper (get a QSFP+ card for my other machine)? There are so many different options to consider, let alone which switches or direct connections, my head hurts. Please help, all welcome, here is a diagram etc.
This upgrade might be a good excuse to get your network properly sorted, even though it means spending more then intended.
Centralise your network by getting an 4-port (or more) SFP+ switch to use as the core switch of your network. Actually, it’ll be the only switch in your network as everything else connects directly to it. Do make the switch to fibre, I’m understood to believe the 10Gb SFP+ to RJ45 adapters are prone to run very hot. You can leave the current wired network in place as fall-back option, but in time it’s just a power-drain on your utility bill. Technically you could split the dual QSFP ports in your server into 8x 10Gb ports and aggregate these in the managed switch to a single 80Gb connection, but I highly doubt that’ll ever be a bottleneck even with just 2x 10Gb bonded instead.
As for which switch to buy, that’s largely dependant on your budget and any future expansion plans you might have. The bare minimum for the setup above would be the Mikrotik CRS305-1G-4S+IN. It’s a 10Gb 4 port SFP+ switch with a management port and has an MSRP of just 150 USD. But that also means expansion is pretty difficult. Your better choice would be the Mikrotik CRS309-1G-8S+IN which has 8 SFP+ ports and MSRP of 270 USD. Mikrotik is a European company and as such has to adhere to EU privacy regulations (GDPR), meaning the s/w cannot have backdoor access. Downside is that setting stuff up is a bit more involved over non-EU competitors from the US and Asia (read: China) and their slick data-sucking GUI’s, but that call has to be yours.
Fibre lines and suitable adapters can be had from fs.com and infinitecables.com, both have been promoted by LTT in the past (and probably other tech-space YT-ers as well), YMMV!