Does anyone know of a high bitrate voice chat or VoIP program designed for recording?

I’m looking for an application that can do Voice chat, with either adjustable static bitrates, or uses a high quality codec out of the box. The idea is to be able to record a conversation between multiple people with a level of quality acceptable for (budget) production use. Any suggestions are welcome.

Discord goes up to 96kbps, if memory serves. I know JB used to use skype, they switched to Mumble and I believe it’s what they still use today.

1 Like

The reason I’m looking into specialized solution is that discord doesn’t support static gain levels or bitrates, so one blip in someone’s connection or a loud noise can ruin a full minute of dialog

it also doesn’t support multitrack recording to my knowledge

That’s fair. I’ve looked into this in the past and found that the best (for production quality) solution was to get everyone in the same building.

Does this need to be live? You could always have people do local recordings, then sync them manually and just use discord as a “monitor” of sorts.

Ideally live support would be nice, yeah.

manually syncing audio with more than 2 people if you aren’t recording the mixed-down audio is problematic, as subject A may have 90ms latency to subject B, but the server is delivering subject C’s audio with 150ms latency, etc. You have to cut and timestretch intensively to to get it to sound natural.

Best solution I’ve found so far is setting up a high bandwidth paid mumble server set to record the stream locally and with static levelling/bitrate, but that still falls short if you’re recording someone who isn’t in the US.

1 Like

if you’re looking for poor-man bitrate modulation voip solution - its ventrillo (very capable of brutal adjustments on-go). Skype and TeamSpeak also do that today but are less capable.

you can also use voip in IRC, its capable of lowering bitrate to save on transfer speeds.

I want static bitrate so I know exactly what I’m transcoding from, though. I definitely don’t mind paying for a solution, like a more dialog focused version of steinberg’s collaboration suite.

IRC voip would be a way to go, but if you want professional solution i’ve worked with cisco voip, and they offer a lot of settings to play with - including pcm modulation etc.

you can hard set bitrate in ventrillo, tho if i remember its by default ‘auto’.

yeah, the reason I went for mumble/mutter over ventrilo is the OPUS support (much lower decode latency)

What particular Cisco VoIP soln would you recommend?

it depends how much you want to pay; if you buy decent cisco router it’ll have voip bios available. I’ve played with cisco 1800, 2811 and 3825 something something routers, and they all had decent configuration, and easy startup.

Though I’ve never played over actual long distance (like different countries, only us mainland)

I’d recommend setting up vlan have people join vlan (as it’d be more secure) and connect to chat through IRC (or random voip software) or actual voip phone. (on 1800 or 2811 you had ability to flash attached avaya voip phones with your configs, which was nice.)

Company i work for is using dedicated catalyst switches now, and dedicated vlan for office phones between states. Can’t say what hardware they are using, but i’d say they still use same principle of traffic just less exposure and cheaper with switches.

under 1k would be ideal, it’s for a small organization

you could go with cisco catalyst 2960 switches if its same building or skype for business - which requires exchange server or something - we have it done, but i didn’t set it up.

you can host your own instance of skype for business server.

would this work with a generic solution like mumble? I’m fairly new to this, which is why I asked for a software solution.

you could configure a switch or router to cut down or pcm scale the bitrate as its coming. As long as you know what protocol it uses (usually its RTTP) for communication you can affect it in many good, and bad ways. Some fun settings are pcm error correction making things sound better or worse; you can cut out specific Hz ranges from handle so outside noise doesn’t get transferred etc.

Its you and the world basically.

I have no idea how mumble works on protocol or how open it is with its transfer protocols. Its hard to say.

Now i’m thinking best solution for small business would be ‘skype for business’,
it should be quite easy to set it up (in past it was Lync if i’m correct). (and its open for all kinds of network ‘power-play’ from switch/router) + may be a cheaper solution than switch/router setup.

wanna say it uses rttp, definitely uses OPUS for encode/decode across the network.

If adding a 100hz rolloff and limiting high range to 8khz is possible before postprocessing, even better

you would need to research that on your own, I think vmware esx/workstation has some cisco or similar vswitch/vrouter virtual devices where you should be able to research it on your own without buying the hardware to test out your sol.

yeah, I know. Just hoping there was something drop-in (or close to it) that I could use,

I’ll repeat myself, i think closest to ability of in-depth control would give you skype for business in ready-to-go implementations. You can also test it with trial version, and i may have been wrong about it requiring exchange setup - maybe it doesn’t.

good to know, thanks for your help.

maybe try this (needs chrome based browser)

https://now.source-elements.com

only tried this up to 128k about 6 months ago - sound was excellent
think I could turn down bitrate and mono outgoing voice, as it was not going to be recorded locally
it has audio controls for each caller, but only stereo mix out from browser
no echo-cancelling and full bi-directional audio - headphones not optional