China ddr5 inhouse production and future demand and prices

Am i completely off perhaps but from what i understand china is ramping up their own production of ddr5 outside of the big memory brands?

If so China will basically stop buying memory as much as possible from the outside owned companies. This would mean that the demand would ease up.

Not sure how much China need in share of the goobal production though. As i understand it this is not the factories that makes the ddr5 memory that is owned by companies outside of china. Not sure if this ddr5 factoy is owned by chineese government or not. If it is it would mean that chinese ddr5 would be considerable cheaper for China.

My guess is that chineese demand for outside ddr5 might even be the reason the companies are raising prices a lot to get a payout before the demand from china plumets…

Havent seen anyone discuss memory prices from this angle. But it is a valid point in tech nowadays to always ask what china is doing. They actuallly plan and have a strategy of what their society need and not only what the companies think they need to make short time profits. This is the potential and advantage of a mixed economy!

What is your take on this?

1 Like

China arguable has it even worse than the rest of the world because their central government started playing games with who was allowed to sell in their market, and their market reacted. To be fair I don’t think it was the central government’s intention to keep DRAM prices low domestically so they aren’t making a mistake in their own view.

CXMT is a viable memory producer though, they are only several years behind the west instead of the ~decade(s) China’s digital logic fabrication is behind the west.
I would be concerned about about their ability to maintain their fab equipment though, I’ve heard talk of problems in that area due to souring relations with the equipment manufacturers or outright blacklisting, so that is a risk factor that could push memory up even more in their domestic market.

I think the DDR market’s volatile enough it’s not particularly worth trying to forecast how shifts in CXMT’s production might influence DDR pricing and availability in general. CXMT’s DDR5 launch date has been like a year of month for month slip which, well, politicians versus engineering to make stuff actually work.

DRAM prices are up like 30-60%. So it’s difficult to argue consumer DIMMs going up ~250+% is primarily Hynix-Samsung-Micron attempting near term profit taking. As opposed to DRAM prices rising on increased demand and Corsair-G.Skill-Amazon-whoever using the opportunity to gouge.

To the extent DRAM cartel price collusion might apply, it’s not apparent more of a story than AI+HBM is needed. Raising prices because CXMT might start making more DDR5 is a hard sell when negotiating a contract.

Last I checked, South Korea was more or less mostly east of China? Though Hynix has more fabs in China than in South Korea and like 20% of Samsung’s fabs are in China. Not sure how Micron’s volume’s distributed but probably 11 Singapore+Taiwan+Japan+China fabs produce more than the three UK+US ones.

I guess a bunch of googling might enable estimating how many wafers of which DDR run in which fabs and, from that, production could be roughly mapped.

Taiwan seems reasonably also described as east of China (though some are rather insistent it’s part of China and others are understandably insistent it’s not). Yeah, Intel’s saying 14A in 2027 and TSMC’s saying 2028 for A14. But even if the nodes do enter production in that order it’s a while yet.

At this point the media/everyone is using “the west” as a catchall term for anyone but China and it’s close friends; I find myself using it all the time now without making a conscious effort to do so.

Intel’s already pumping out tons of 18A chips though which I think is ahead of TSMC?
I haven’t actually delved into how Intel might have a real world performance and efficiency advantage over TSMC’s N2 node because of backside power delivery; on paper TSMC looks to have more dense logic than Intel but I keep hearing it might not in practice because of Intel’s BPD

1 Like

Seems a bit hard to tell at the moment but you may be right. Both companies claim to have started production on their nodes but I’m not having luck finding a well defined launch date for an N2 chip (Feynman and Venice are H2 2026). Whereas Intel’s saying early Q1 2026 for Panther Lake.

18A I do have some hesitance about, given Intel’s history of process issues and current financials, but hopefully it’s not a paper launch or another Raptor.

China making their own DDR5 Chips? or you talking ram sticks?

whoops, when I wrote that I was thinking Sierra Forest was 18A, but that is not the case.

Yes to both. CXMT is actually a world class fab in the processes it has specialized in, in contrast to SMIC.

1 Like

Yep, they got that world class Samsung tech :+1: :rofl:

think they can be at least on par with micron? which is the worst of the three big manufacturers.

I’m not sure if I’d call Micron the worst, the fastest DRAM memory on any x86 system purchasable by us normies is Micron:

but to answer your question, they can likely make comparable memory at perhaps worse yields. I know they straight up delayed their DDR5 ramp earlier this year because of bad yield of ~50%.

i dont know if its because they cant or want to but i havent seen a 6000mhz 64gb ddr5 stick from micron with cas latencies in the lower 30.

everyone seems to agree on Sk hynix>Samsung >Micron. at least for DDR5

I think this is true if ultimate OC is the metric you are measuring memory by, but only for the 16Gb dies used in DDR5.
I’m not so sure about the 24Gb and 32Gb dies because SK Hynix seems pretty bad on these two (or maybe everyone is bad at these densities?).

It’s my understanding Hynix is tops in 24 Gb, especially demolishing Micron in refresh timings, and the 24 Gb Hynix timings I’ve tightened to are about as tight as I’ve seen anybody post (I could push farther but it’s well into diminishing returns and I’d rather leave stability margin than spend days trimming out every last clock). Haven’t come across 32 Gb Hynix UDIMMs but then I rarely look below 48 GB.

FWIW the few not terrible 64 GBs that came available before the DDR insanity are, to the best of my knowledge, Samsung. Crucial’s 64 GBs weren’t close.

If China increases its DDR5 production, their imports could drop, easing global demand, and affecting prices. Local production might also make DDR5 cheaper in China. Your point about companies raising prices before losing Chinese demand is interesting, given China’s strategic approach to tech.

What “games” ?
THis is just rational response to Orange Man’s over weaponization of tarriffs.
CPC is aware that China is next target on Rockefeller’s list, after Russia and Iran.

THey know that they have to achieve self-sufficiency ASAP.
Since Chinese “commies” are far the most capitalistic scene in the world, CPC had to enforce some rules for all the main players in order to achieve common interests of the society.

So, when CPC imposes their own measures on their own market, those are “games”, but when Orange Man grabs their oil tanker or sanctions them for no obvious reason, this is … what ?
“bussiness as usual”, “free market”, something else perhaps ? :roll_eyes:

Chinese DDR5 production, as most else, is aimed primarily at self-sufficiency, not export.

IMO they have zero interest to aid Uncle Sam in any way.
If anything, I’d expect them to bundle their memory with their competing tech to make it more attractive for the West.

I’m not going to argue what the geopolitical rationale is behind a given players moves, because you and I cannot predict them nor make productive discourse from it.
What I am doing is shedding light on the question of DRAM prices in China, how local production and import policies are fighting each other and increasing prices for Chinese consumers.