Can't find the right upgrade path

I’m running a self-built E-2288G on a gigabyte c246 motherboard with 128GB of ECC DDR4 & an RTX 3090.

I run proxmox to virtualize a linux server which runs some docker stuff, handles ~80TB of storage, and I also use it to virtualize windows 11 for CAD software and some light gaming. I’m starting to hit the limits of the hardware right now though, so have been thinking about upgrading to something with more PCIe lanes, more NVMe, etc.

With a 3090, 8x SAS HBA, and x550 NIC, plus 2 NVMe drives, I am totally out of expansion slots.

The E-2288G can also get a little bogged down when there’s a lot of stuff going on (like if there’s a ZFS scrub going on).

So I’m looking around at the component landscape, but it seems like the HEDT segment has basically disappeared. For the price of a 64-core Zen 3 Threadripper, I could get an EPYC Genoa on Zen 4 with DDR5.

But then you look at desktop/enthusiast CPUs, and the performance gap to HEDT & server hardware is basically gone.

So I feel like a sucker spending an extra $2000 and an extra 200W for negligible performance gains, even though I need the extra expansion.

So is it just me, or is this a weird time to buy? It seems like the shift to DDR5 and PCIe 5 (and 4-slot GPUs) have tilted the enthusiast market toward expensive gaming motherboards with 2-3 PCIe slots, poor memory support, but having otherwise great CPUs.

HEDT is basically dead, or at least it feels well behind the curve. Maybe it’s recency bias, but given the performance of Zen 4, I don’t see why one would pay so much for a 5000-series threadripper today given what’s coming down the pipeline.

I guess the only saving grace is that there’s Zen 4 server hardware out now that no one is buying thanks to the recent shift to GPU demand in enterprise. But even there, there’s basically only one motherboard that makes any sense at all (H13SSL-NT), and the ASUS WRX80 SAGE looks like a better all-round fit for my needs (modulo inflated cost of 5000-series threadripper)

Anyone else facing a similar dilemma?

This.

Intel announced the Xeon W-2400 and W-3400 lines. Puget has an interesting article around that. I think they are expected to ship a little bit later in the year. Costs will settle as soon as the early adopters have been served.

There are speculations that AMD may release an upgraded Threadripper platform earlier than later for improved competition.

So, there is a chance that in a couple of months, maybe a year from now, we have two competing HEDT platforms on DDR5 and PCIe5 with sufficient lanes. Not certain, but one can dream.

This topic was automatically closed 273 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.