I've read the thread a bit and I think there needs to be some clarification.
Money and currency are two different things.
Money is something that is generally accepted as payment for goods, services and debts. Money functions as medium of exchange, unit of account, and a way to store value. Really, anything can be money if both parties have confidence that the thing is money, AKA something that is a medium of exchange, unit of account, or way to store value.
Currency, is the implementation of money within a country (I suppose it could be a society or something too....details...details...); I.E. A system of money.
Now that that's out of the way, is the FL judge erroneous in his judgement? Well, what did the judge actually say regarding bitcoin as money??
Since I don't have a way to parse this scan of the court order to pull out words, here is a snap shot of the part where the judge comments about bitcoin as money.
TL;DR on judge's official statement that bitcoin is not money:
The judge basically states that bitcoin is not a commonly used means of exchange, is not accepted by all merchants or service providers, is extremely volatile and therefore does not act as a good store of value, and it lacks ways to curb the volatility. Therefore it is not money.
I don't think he understands the difference between money and currency. Since anything can be money as long as both parties have confidence in it, Bitcoin is clearly money.
However! If you take what he says about Bitcoin and apply it to currency, the implementation of money within a country, everything he says makes more sense. A good currency follows all the definitions of money described above AND is relatively stable. No government is going to make a legal tender out of something that is not stable or at least not knowingly stable. Bitcoin sure as shit is not a currency.
IMO he made an error here with his definitions. He should have said Bitcoin isn't currency. That said, I agree with the outcome in Count I. I'll leave Count II and III alone.
Thought: Does FL law distinguish the differences between currency and money? hmmmm...
Also I think it's funny that someone involved in a Bitcoin case had this name: