Bedhedd's home theater adventure

Sound is volume (literally) so what may be pleasant to me with my specific setup won’t be pleasant to another with the same setup in a different space; audio is the only scientific field where I personally feel that speaker reviews fail the most, because it’s subjective and hyper-dependent. Is it reproducible? Yes. Do you have the available currency to make that happen in your own home? 99% of the time, no.

The only solution is “try before you buy.” With used speakers it’s not that easy (nor new unless a local venue actually offers that service for free), but if they’re locally sourced, insist that the seller prove their wares the same as if you were buying anything secondhand. If it’s truly worth the money compared to typical market value, then they shouldn’t have any problem proving that they work on their own personal setup (which is an entirely different thing to take into consideration). Period.

Makes sense, I already bought the speakers. I’m just looking for a reciever that can power my speakers + work as my avr.

I want to make sure I buy a avr that can work with the 2 scenarios.

I won’t go broke spending $500-600, but if I’m spending over $900 and the process or quality is as janky as if I had got it cheaper. I would be more disappointed. I want to make sure I get this right

For example there are suggestions for the
Pioneer lx305, Pioneer VSX-LX505, Denon 4800H
https://old.reddit.com/r/hometheater/comments/1azro9b/before_buying_denon_x3800h/ks56g0g/
https://old.reddit.com/r/hometheater/comments/1azro9b/before_buying_denon_x3800h/ks934oh/

People prefer other brands because dirac is not included
https://old.reddit.com/r/hometheater/comments/1gun9ui/denon_vs_everything_else/

https://old.reddit.com/r/hometheater/comments/1gun9ui/denon_vs_everything_else/lxvit1x/
At the mid range of $500-600, it seems denon is recommended

These were some other reasons

https://old.reddit.com/r/hometheater/comments/1gun9ui/denon_vs_everything_else/lxvjyte/

I agree with that, pretty much why I chose a Denon. Full preouts (plus the denon preouts are full line voltage and low distortion compared to some other brands) and being able to disable the internal amps are huge features if you plan on using external amplifiers, otherwise it really just comes down to room EQ and Audessey is really the what of the entry level systems, especially with the third party tools. Plus they optionally support Dirac if you’ve got money to burn.

2 Likes

The Martin Logan’s? I did admittedly miss that the first time around. See below in bold amidst my rambling (I sincerely apologize)…

Not remotely fun to work with. I gave up after buying a cheap as hell adjustable tripod even for more my measly little space. The only thing that I could find for troubleshooting was on random forums and piecing it all together to it MAYBE being that the microphone gain needed to be raised, but I don’t own a laptop (a friend brought theirs over, but that was a year and half ago and they’ve been swamped out of the ass) and I have a small window to be able to turn EVERYTHING noise making off just to find out if that’s the problem. The mic supplied by the Onkyo works, I’ve recorded myself talking on it. Dirac doesn’t. :expressionless:

I did, however, buy my Onkyo at a steep discount ($800 vs $1,200 when my model was available). Probably should have led with that as far as my first comment goes. I’m sorry.

I specifically wanted HDMI 2.1b 4K 120hz on as many ports as possible so that I had room to grow with the receiver, because you can always pair cheaper speakers with a higher end receiver, but not the other way around. Denon’s model at the time that actually offered 5.1.4 had a SINGLE HDMI 2.1b port that actually offered 4k 120hz, while the other ports were buggy because of a bad chip and it still cost more than MSRP of my Onkyo… I chose a shitty Room EQ program over something that I will be using possibly for the rest of my foreseeable future. If I get 10-20 years out of it, then that’s $80-40/year respectively. If it breaks before that time frame, then it’s an immediate “learn how to fix it now,” which will technically be fun. :upside_down_face:

1 Like

Based on

And

I pulled the trigger on a open box Denon X3800H on ebay, it was cheaper than adorama. I didn’t want to go through the headache of buying and returning a reciever

HDMI EArc works without any issues for 4k 120hz and hdr. I had to set the signal format for the game input to 8K enhanced.

On my nobara HTPC. I use a club3d DisplayPort to HDMI adapter into a club3d HDMI cable to get 4K 120Hz HDR.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0C4FTWLCJ?psc=1
https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B07H5Y5N55?psc=1

Here’s a compressed uncalibrated sound check with my Martin Logan Speakers at ~65-70 volume


The vocals are super clear

For the sound tests, I used temporary cables to check if the reciever worked. I am looking into getting a more permanent set of banana plug cables. I was thinking of getting the same banana plug cables for my desk setup

But parts express only has 1 cable in stock, so I would need to wait until the back order arrives. I might DIY banana plug cables

For cables, I was thinking of getting 14 gauge cables, but I read that 12 gauge cables work better for difficult speakers

https://www.hometheaterforum.com/community/threads/speaker-wire-14-or-12-awg.151874/#post-1652705

With the gauge decided, I was browsing cables when I noticed the CCA cable was much cheaper than OFC

So a quick search I came across this article

OFC seems to resist oxidation better than CCA. So I’ll go with 12 gauge OFC speaker wire

This guy recommanded nakamichi plugs

The guage of your speaker wire depends on the length of wire and the load of the speaker. All modern speakers should be assumed to be a 4ohm load but over short distances (2m or so) it doesn’t really mater. I’d just get 12AWG and not worry about it.

images (16)

Oxygen free copper is sort of snake oil, almost all copper wire is oxygen free but there’s no electrical difference between that and regular copper, it really only matters for industrial and chemical applications. CCA has higher resistance than copper so 12AWG CCA is equivalent to something like 14AWG copper, but that’s the only difference. Stick to copper, I don’t think it’s really worth what you save on CCA as you’ll need thicker wire anyway, and watch out for cheap copper wire as often it’s just CCA labelled as pure copper.

1 Like

Cool I went with 12 AWG

This is a good table, will need to keep it handy

Got it. My runs are 10-12 ft, but good to know

Rolled my own banana plug cables, I decided to write a post with my learnings

1 Like

added the edited sound test to the op

chapters
0:00 Crab Rave - Noisestorm
3:12 Clint Eastwood - Gorillaz
8:49 All Caps - MF DOOM
11:00 –CUPID– - Miki Matsubara
16:21 Chamber of Reflection - Mac DeMarco
20:10 Show Me How - Men I Trust
23:45 Body Paint - Arctic Monkeys
28:31 Telescope - Cage the Elephant

1 Like

I’ve been looking at subwoofers for black Friday recently. These were some questions I wanted to learn more about:

  • What is the cost sweet spot for middle/high end?
  • sealed vs ported subwoofers
  • What is the difference between a active and a passive
  • What is the sweet spot in terms of size? 10 vs 12 inch

sweet spot for middle/high end

It seems that a mid range sub gets near 20hz

as the RSL Speedwoofer 10S mini

sealed vs ported subwoofers

While browsing for the svs sb-1000, I came across this thread

This response was interesting

Tl;dw people prefer sealed for music and ported for home theater. Ported subs tuned for deeper values have a best of both worlds
There was a follow up read linked in a response

active vs passive subwoofers

According to this article, the main difference seems to be the built in amplifier

On the hometheater subreddit, This post confirms it

On the my AVR, it seems that it only supports active subs

https://manuals.denon.com/AVRX3800H/NA/EN/GFNFSYaxhqtbzr.php

This reddit response also confirms it

size sweet spot

Bigger seems to be better, but 10 and 12 inch inch subs can cover a wider genre.

According to this article
[Quote=Thurgendry]
Compact satellite and bookshelf speakers work well with an 8″ or 10″ subwoofer. The sound quality of a 12″ subwoofer is superior to that of larger floor-standing speakers and a larger center channel.
[/quote]

[Quote=Thurgendry]
An 8″ sub is great for jazz or classical. The smaller, more agile cone responds quickly and accurately to this music’s frequencies.

The 10″ will respond quickly to the strong percussion in rock and country songs. It can move the extra air needed for live music, and isn’t that the goal?

Rap music’s synthetic bass is the most demanding. If so, you need a subwoofer. The 15″ sub moves the most air for this sort of music. A stock or aftermarket 6×9 speaker can’t handle these notes. 15″ is excellent if you have enough airspace.

Finally, a 12″ sub. This is the most adaptable option for those who listen to a wide variety of musical genres. It handles rock’s snappier drumming better than the 15″ cone, but it can’t keep up with rap’s air volume
[/quote]

sub for my room size

Given that my room is about 22x20ft with a 11x14 area for the tv and high ceilings. I need to figure out what type of sub I need

While looking for recommendations for given rooms, I came across this page. It contained a equation and table

following the equation, I get a room size of 3520 ft³ for the entire living room and 1232 ft³ for just the tv area.

I came across this avs post, which recommended the PC2000

Looking at the product page it is a 12 inch driver

Spec Measurement
Driver 12"
Amplifier Rating 550 watts RMS (1500+ watts peak)
Freq. Response 16Hz to 290Hz +/-3dB (standard mode)
Freq. Response 17Hz to 290Hz +/-3dB (sealed mode)
Dimensions 34.34" (H) 16.6" (W) 16.6" (D)

A lot of the opinions about sealed and ported subs are from the time before DSP and room correction and really don’t apply anymore. One thing which is worth thinking about is due to the way bass stacks at lower frequencies even if the subs are in different parts of the room having multiple sealed subs can get way more extension and output than ported subs due to their slower roll off.

If you’re looking at SVS then the 2000 series are worth getting over the 1000. The 2000 and 3000 series are really the sweatapot depending on budget, though I’d probably get 2 1000s over a single 2000.

1 Like

After months of deliberation, I finally pulled the trigger on a RSL Speedwoofer 12s.

$994 (884 + $15 of shipping protection + $90 taxes) was above my initial budget of $400-600, but I realized that for my room size of ~3520 ft³ (22"-9x20x8), the 10s I previously considered wouldn’t be enough.

What ultimately helped my decision was my interaction with the RSL support. They seemed very knowledgeable and helpful when I provided them my room size, current setup, and my research.

Funny enough the thing that sparked this purchase was because sweetwater reached out to me with some personalized offers. I asked if they had any suggestions for a 500 W active 12 inch, ~19-240Hz frequency response, with a 121 dB max accoustic output.

Their suggestion didn’t really confirm if the subwoofer would be good for my space
Initially they suggested the Polk Audio Monitor XT12
https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/MXT12SubBlk--polk-audio-monitor-xt12-100-watt-12-inch-powered-subwoofer-black
But it was pretty hard to find any reviews that weren’t just review spam. The best i could find is this post from the audioholics forum

Basically the frequency range was nowhere near the ranges I researched.

I asked sweetwater if they had any other suggestions if I stretched my budget a bit more. They suggested the Klipsch R-121SW Subwoofer
https://www.sweetwater.com/store/detail/R121SWBlk--klipsch-r-121sw-subwoofer-black-textured-vinyl-wood-grain

When I found reviews, the Klipch wouldn’t be good for my room

What sealed the deal for Klipch was

When I read the linked reviews to the Speedwoofer 10S MKII and the BIC Acoustech PL-300,

The two of them performed better than the Klipch which was more expensive. I also read somewhere that on cheaper subs, the amplifier is cheaper and lower quality.

While researching the Klipch 1215W, I also came across this reddit post which linked to a subwoofer recommendations
https://old.reddit.com/r/hometheater/comments/wxqoln/klipsch_r121sw_vs_r101sw/ilsl7sn/

https://old.reddit.com/r/HTBuyingGuides/comments/1jr1y4l/product_recommendations_subwoofers_20252026/

After some further discussions with sweetwater, I felt they didn’t justify their recommendations. The sweetwater recommendations felt more like they were trying to fit within my budget.

At this point my mind had decided RSL because 10s had a really good performance in the review. I decided to contact RSL about my room specs and if I could get away with a single 10s

RSL sales

Thanks again!

The response detailed and fast. I ultimately decided to get a single 12S because I didn’t have space for 2 10S subs

sweetwater sales engineer

I got my subwoofer setup and plugged in. I still need to calibrate it further, but here’s the config I am using. It is based on the audessy calibration

# read as Speakers > Manual Setup
[speakers][manual setup]
[crossovers]
Front Crossover=60Hz
Center=80Hz

# read as Speakers/Manual Setup > Advanced >  > Low Frequency Effects
[advanced][low frequency effects] 
Subwoofer Output=LFE
Low Pass Filter=150Hz

sound only came from my front speakers

These were some helpful guides since my audessy mic didn’t work/wouldn’t calibrate
https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R3R35KXZ8SB8YF/ref=cm_cr_dp_d_rvw_ttl?ie=UTF8

I suspect I killed it with esd as even when my subwoofer was shaking the room, the audessy mic kept getting a reading of 39 db

I started by searching denon x3800h front speakers have all base on brave. Funny enough the ai answer linked to the denon wiki had this page that gave me the hint to disable full range
https://manuals.denon.com/AVRX3800H/NA/EN/GFNFSYitmloggd.php

After browsing the denon page, I then looked at the first reddit result, which had this solution

The svs article had a great explanation for the crossover frequency

I then looked up my Martin Logan Aerius speakers

based on the rating and the measured frequency response, the Aerius is about 40-50hz, so I need to set the crossover frequency as 60hz

songs to test my settings

I was looking for some songs to test if my subwoofer was working

great range


Hotel California was highly upvoted

great wall and window shaker

1 Like