Bad CD rips

likely none of that mate.
if you try to recode a cd at a higher bitrate than it was encoded with, you will get random pops and crackles.
basically your just recording system noise that would normally be masked if you were using a lower bitrate/sample rate.

check the file format with something like audacity, see what bitrate and frequency the original audio was encoded at.
use those settings when you rip to another medium.

That really shouldn’t happen! The upsampling is done digitally and there are algorithms that do it accurately. Digital audio is a solved problem. The mathematics of it are well understood. If you get pops and crackles something weird is going on beyond resampling.

ok well, it was all fixed when i put my cd drive in an external enclosure that converted sata to usb3. none of my rip settings changed, sampling rate has always been 44.1khz, 16 bits, 1411kbps

thank you! this thread was never about my rip settings. it has always been about something weird happening in my computer that is messing my CD rips. and I’ve just confirmed it by producing accurate rips on the same system with the same cd drive simply being plugged into usb3 instead of sata. there has to be something going on from the point the data leaves the cd drive to it being written onto any of my SSDs

1 Like