Being someone who enjoys Linux-oriented media here and there, I’ve often come across the refrain that Apple is “just as bad” as the next megacorporation when it comes to violation of their customers’ right to privacy.
@wendell even said something to that effect in a video kind of recently, saying pretty emphatically that Apple brings the same ethics to customer data as all the other companies.
I’m gradually moving away from Apple because they don’t believe in slots and sockets, but should I also be clearing out all my data from Apple’s various “cloud” services? I’m more-or-less bought into the idea that they’ve distinguished themselves as having a generally customer-respecting approach to data, being uniquely positioned among the major tech companies as having incentives that are remotely compatible with that posture. Why not make the most of that competitive point of distinction, right? (They sure have with their marketing.)
I’m really curious as to the specific examples of Apple misbehaving, aside from ads on their mobile app store, which is, for me, in the realm of grudging tolerability.
Honestly, it’s kinda hard to find any major controversies regarding Apple and user privacy.
Like they’re not perfect, but my complaints about Apple have to do with arbitrary restrictions with hardware and software that create a dependence on Apple and encourage planned obsolescence, not so much about data.
Maybe somebody else has some good examples similar to how Google totally banned a guy who took a picture of his child to send to his doctor, but got flagged as a false positive for CSAM. And even after the police investigated and found no wrong-doing, Google still wouldn’t open his account.
Not directly on topic, but here’s the stance from Apple.
Basically as long as the government goes through the correct process to request data, they will give it to them. Anything you store in iCloud, Apple has the keys to it.
BUT, there’s also ADP, which sounds like Apple’s version of zero-knowledge encryption.
Problem is, it sounds like you need an Apple device in order to set up ADP and access your stuff. So it’s yet another barrier you have to break down later in order to leave the Apple ecosystem.
This is more generalized, but interesting.
There was an Oxford study in 2021 that basically found that Apple still collects a whole lotta data.
I would argue they are worse as the corporate double speak of valuing / protecting your privacy while also using it against you is worse than someone like Microsoft, Google, Facebook that openly state you are the product.
depends:
would you trust me or anyone on 4Chan to host all your data?
If no:
then clear it out
if yes:
seek help
Here’s a couple excerpts from that post you linked, about the Oxford study:
There’s one big caveat regarding the new study: It was conducted before the introduction of iOS 14.5 in April 2021, which made opt-in to tracking and app privacy labels mandatory on iPhones.
The researchers analyzed the code, permissions and network traffic of 12,000 randomly selected free apps from each platform that had been updated or released in 2018 or later.
That is about what I expected. Apple’s using a light touch with third parties, not just assassinating Mark Zuckerberg like we all want, which would be anti-competitive.
Law enforcement having access to iCloud with warrants isn’t news.
I liked that video, though I don’t think it gets into qualitative details enough for the scores to be a representative comparison… I still think there’s a large distinction to be made between iOS and Googley Android. (Waiting on a non-Pixel phone to be available before seriously considering GrapheneOS.)
I’ve actually got that turned on. The worst part is it disables fonts in web pages and everybody uses those for icons now. 1 star ratings and 5 star ratings alike are converted to 5 box ratings. It gets harder to figure out site navigation elements. It also screws up familial location sharing and shared photo libraries for whatever reason.
AI on a phone allows end-to-end encryption to be defeated, as the AI can scan media and sensor data prior to it being encrypted for transmission. This allows the company to publicly say “Apple can’t see your data” — and be “technically” true — whilst at the same time having the AI running on your own phone perform the data analysis that they want, and which governments of all persuasions are demanding.
The Sensitive Content Warning “feature” mentioned earlier was a precursor to client-side and pre-encryption scanning by AppleAI. Your Apple device would decide to report you to authorities based on what it thought you were doing… even though “Apple couldn’t see your data”.
tl;dr: AI on a phone eliminates the concept of “privacy” completely, grants the phone manufacturer plausible deniability for gaslighting consumers, and allows phones to be sold in jurisdictions where governments demand back-doors — thus maximising corporate profits. Apple’s privacy claims are all smoke and mirrors.
PS: Nearly all mainstream/modern phones have two processors. The OS that you install and configure runs on the first (main) processor. When you “power down” your device, you only power down that processor. The other processor is always on, cannot be turned off, and runs code installed by the manufacturer that you have no control over. The baseband controller, additionally (and if distinct from the second processor), has firmware that is mandated by regulatory authorities in the jurisdiction where the phone is operated. In effect, there are two levels of code below what the end-user can see or influence. Even FOSS running on FOSH can only give you control over two of the three levels. Control is an illusion.
consider degoogled android or linux. there are challenges to both and may not be viable for every day carry depending on the applications you require. unfortunately the phone landscape kinda sucks.
you don’t need a pixel to be private. LineageOS is good and supported on most devices.
Historically, there have been zero-click vulnerabilities in iOS. There are virtually certain to be more of them. While, probably, nobody’s going to burn one of those on somebody like me, there’s a non-zero chance that something like that is used for mass exploitation of phones sometime.
I’ve always hated Apple’s default non-configurable approach to embedding media previews and parsing in everything everywhere. So I turn on Lockdown mode so that happens less. It just seems like common sense to me.
It’s not just “just as bad” it’s actually worse. As I understand it, Apple essentially parses every single image on your device (whether you are using their cloud storage or not) to make sure there is no child porn on it. Of course, that system is not foolproof, and is subject to human review. Which means countless Apple employees have oggled countless nude images of its users’ adult wives and girlfriends.
Less of a privacy issue, my real issue with apple is how offensively restrictive the walled garden is. Why can’t I run an emulator on the device I paid for? Why can’t I install a browser that is not Safari’s (artificially restricted and intentionally slowed down) webkit?
Apple has accomplished a truly great feat of (social) engineering and manged to remove the general purpose from general purpose computing.
How absurd; a turing complete machine that isn’t truly complete.
I do not think Apple is materially better than the other tech companies with respect to user data and user privacy.
I do agree that within the US, Apple appears to be involved in fewer user privacy scandals. That said, Apple’s moves in China offer their Chinese customers nearly zero data privacy. In my view, this clearly confirms that Apple does not view user privacy to be a primary goal. I don’t think this is surprising, the purpose of a corporation is to provide to maximum return for its shareholders.
See the article below as an example of Apple’s moves in China: