The data plane may be decentralized, but tailscale.com (or your headscale node) being a single point that compromising will in effect compromise the whole network makes me uneasy, since by their nature they also have to be relatively wide open to Internet traffic.
There is taillock which helps a lot, but tailscale still has a number of other features that an attacker might find useful to leverage (perhaps some of these are mitigated by taillock) such as:
The network ACLs
Routing rules
MagicDNS
Tailscale SSH
Tailscale Funnel
There’s also some potential to collect significant amount of network recon by enabling listing services, amongst whatever metadata tailscale.com can see.
At it’s core I see tailscale’s focus being towards it’s saas platform and commercial customers. That’s a good business model.
Nebula on the other hand I have no experience with, but I think the following is true:
There’s no default third party saas involved
The public network service (lighthouse) is untrusted by design
The single point of compromise is the CA key, however I believe that’s much easier to mitigate against than a network service like tailscale.com or headscale
The network ACL configuration is at the discretion of each node (I think?)
The cryptography is probably solid, it’s based on the well known noise framework and there’s a reasonable chance Slack has paid for an audit, but I still have more faith in wireguard
It’s more work to setup and less userfriendly than tailscale
At it’s core it’s a self hosted mesh VPN first, the defined.net company is a spin off
It won’t win data transfer benchmarks, but it’ll be fast enough (for me)
Also as a convenience for us Debian users Nebula is also in the official repos.
Now to me as a security conscious fellow I like tailscale, but feel that nebula might be the better choice for my humble home networking needs.
But nebula isn’t very popular at all, I was wondering if I was missing anything.
The NAT hole punching, the peer discovery, the easier to write network ACLs (with groups!), the routing taken care of - I’m suspecting is worth the trade off of setting up Nebula (or Tailscale etc).
With n nodes in the mesh, the n^2 possible connections makes management a bit of a PITA.
I’m guessing n will start around 5-10 (phones, PCs, laptops, routers, rpis, adds up fast!), but with new VMs involved might well end up around 20.
For my business, which has team members all over the globe, it was imperative that I chose the best VPN solution. I installed and tested:
Nebula, Tailscale, Headscale, Netbird, Cloudflare WARP, ZeroTier, and Netmaker.
Cloudflare WARP offered the best solution, but we did not use it because you are stuck with Carrier Grade NAT IPs. Long story short, we went back to plain ole’ Wireguard hosted on our OPNsense server.