Andy Yen from Proton shoots himself in the foot

AI is a tool… it is as good and as bad as the user that implements it.
AI have now found Thousands of CVE in Microsoft products, Linux, Apple, Adobe etc. etc.. all those CVE’s was coded software before implementation of AI.
AI is good on finding bugs and vulnerability’s wayyy better then humans.
The last years numbers of CVE’s is the proof.
Hackers use it with great success..… Developers need to learn how to use AI to scan their code too, so it becomes less vulnerability’s in the code for hackers to abuse

AI coding.. If you isn’t a long term developer that actually can code by heart.. then vibe-coding can be bad.
But if you is a software developer with years of knowledge.. AI can make your work go faster and you have the knowledge to see when AI mess up the code.. bug-fixing etc will go faster.. fix patches for CVE’s will go faster.

I am okay on bash scripting.. not good and not bad.. I’m not super fast on the keyboard, just around 120 characters a minute.. But writing a 500 line script with AI take a few seconds, and then i spend a few minutes checking the code.
and as i dont have all commands in my head, i use a cheat-sheet.. if i should manually write those 500 lines and look at my cheat-sheet and look up some things in man-pages.. it will take a lot longer time.

Is AI implementation good or bad………
it depends on use case…. and if the person has knowledge enough to actually interpret the output.

Okay.. i have signed up for free email three different times.. one 2 years ago.. one 1 year ago and one a few months ago… they never asked me for a second email

They used to not require an email, or even contact info/address to get a premium account. They had like an option to mail cash or something. I don’t recall the specifics but it was funny to read at the time.

I definitely made my proton account without using another email maybe 3 years ago.

I dont need new proton mail.. but i have a feeling i still can register without a second email.
My last one was a one time only need.. i needed an email for a hack event.. being on the same platform as 600+ hackers, makes you a tiiiny bit paranoid.. and i think that is a valid time to actually be paranoid without a tinfoil hat. LOL :rofl:

1 Like

Oh right, I forgot about that. The way they were treating staff was disturbing. I think I mentioned that in my “official complaint”.

At least they seem to have walked that part back.. publicly anyway.

I’m not aware of a 3rd or 4th controversy. Hmmm…

There was one about supporting Trump or funding people in America and another about the who they were choosing to advertise with on Youtube etc. where the choices were proper hard right grifter types. This AI related interview thing and then being shitty to the staff makes 4-ish by my count in roughly a year to a year and a half. That’s just the ones I’m aware of so there could be more or they depending on your views of the world and politics you could view them as classic shitty tech bro behaviour that’s counter to who or what you want to support or nothing burgers.

Regardless, he’s brought or stoked controversy and it’s an aspect of Tech Bros I just don’t want to support anymore if I can help it and we the citizen have almost fuck all say in most things. So I’m holding off to see how it pans out before I decide to renew any subscriptions using the only leverage I have, my money. This timeline, broadly, sucks.

@Trooper_ish

A nice lesson in companies are not your friends no matter how much you idolize them. I would see how it goes, initially it seemed bad but the official response seemed reasonable.

Proton has several offerings but I am using none. For VPN I still am on Mullvad and for email I don’t think I have much to gain from Proton. Email is an inherently untrustworthy technology, it has gotten better with TLS but overall you need to assume every email as compromised.

What I find important is to have services or VPSs in countries with a high freedom and justice index. In Switzerland, Iceland and Norway you can at least be sure that an actual judge reviewed your case and weighted you personal rights too, before police or intelligence services get access. In many other countries, including Germany, not so much.

For example in Germany a judge will pretty much always side with law enforcement and they will raid your home because you downloaded LatestMovie.mp4. In Norway for example personal rights, and rights to privacy still count. As far as I know the ruling is that ISPs are not even allowed to hand out the names belonging to IP addresses in this case because personal rights weight heavier there then a copyright infringement.

For servers and services not under my direct control I can not stop police and intelligence services from gaining access but I can choose a jurisdiction that actually considers my rights.

3 Likes

True, but we can do better than letting the likes of Google handle it.

Interesting mention about Tuta Mail. My privacy goals are centered on avoiding hacks, scammers or identity theft stuff, and spam avoidance mostly, so LE access isn’t concerning for me, but I guess that’s a bonus for Proton’s base country for some people.

It seems the larger the country and “bigger” the government, the more resources and willingness they have to ignore privacy. I think that’s why Tuta wasn’t as interesting around the time that I de-Googled - Germany is a fairly big one.