Andy Yen from Proton shoots himself in the foot

My sub is up for renewal in a couple of weeks. I don’t use it that much, it was more of a test the water/donation but was all set to move key things over. I’ve stopped the renewal and I’m watching to see what happens.

This is his what 3rd or 4th drama in the last few years. 1 or 2 in this modern age, maybe, just maybe they could be explained or handwaved away. The problem I feel is we’re into “people telling you who they are territory” at this point and I’m not gonna lie the pro-poton posting on Reddit definitely has an air of AstroTurf about it. I’m hoping I’m being overly paranoid (is there such a thing in this timeline?!) hence not detonating it all and heading off somewhere else but I’m not at ease with it like others than I can merrily push on so I’m doing the sit and wait thing for a bit.

Astermail and Informaniak are two I’ve heard positives about and I’ll be checking out Ente and Tuta along with any others that I see recommended in the various threads. No harm in looking and as others have pointed out, spreading stuff around and self hosting shrinks the blast radius in theory.

When I was migrating from the google cloud I researched many different services and Proton was one of the top ones at first.

On closer investigation I saw a company that didn’t listen to its customers, they had a strange feature and cost tiering. On top of that they were not even remotly interested in open source or openness so they went into the bin.

2 Likes

I haven’t cancelled myself but obviously this news was concerning. And knowing that “AI” is tearing through every tech company now, I’m sure their competitors are also using it. So I’m not about to panic switch and will continue to watch and signal that security and caution are far more important than speed ever will be. I’ve already communicated this to them directly via their support.

@Dryparn I don’t understand where you’re getting the “doesn’t listen to its customers” and “not even remotely interested in open source or openness” at all. What gave you that impression?

Unless I’m seriously misinformed, my research has always indicated that they were extremely responsive to customer feedback. Even with trouble tickets I’ve put in myself, I’ve gotten a detailed back and forth where they collect more information and provide a final response. It’s more than I expect from any tech service company. Many tech companies - with orders of magnitude more money sitting around.. don’t even seem to have a way to email them, let alone get multiple responses back from a single ticket.

When I look at their feature request list, the biggest problem with the list I saw was that they don’t do a good job marking features complete once they’re added. I counted a ton of things requested and upvoted that were already live, or recently went live.

And on the open source point - all their client side software, AFAIK, is completely open source. How many companies do that out there?

I’m concerned about the AI impact of course but I feel like cancellation and calls for resignations is an over-reaction. They’ve built a good thing, I’m fine giving them a pass on one mess up. That said, I’m glad there is still some pressure on them. So even what I’d call over-reaction serves some purpose, I suppose.

1 Like

I’m still looking for a secondary email service to replace tuta’s just up and close my account for lack of use. One of the services that the the fine folks of this community pointed me to proton and I was considering switching over when Andy yen went off the deep end. And then bitwarden changes happened.

I’m still on the wait and see but I would prefer a company or companies that are not causing drama!

I’m still taking suggestions!

1 Like

I did renew my subscription.

I was for sure being a drama llama, and they don’t seem perfect, but I definitely allowed out of context views and expressions to colour my opinion.

I believe the company as a whole, is good, and the people working there, are goods also.

So, am happy to give them more money, and will keep an eye out, in case changes start earning warnings from security peoples and such

so.. am continuing, but keeping half-an-eye more than before on it…

1 Like

The problem with this sort of thing is that we have no way to know what anyone is doing behind closed doors, really. Maybe their competitors are doing worse, but better at keeping quiet about it?

I don’t blame anyone reacting or avoiding Proton at the moment after some hot news like this though.

1 Like

What I’ll likely do is just diversify my stack over dropping Proton entirely. Their mail service is good and they might oust (or slap) their CEO over this, with luck nothing much will change in the end. But it never hurts to diversify so I’m not as effected if something like this happens again.

2 Likes

diversity is a good idea, and I must admit, I had sleep walked into having too many eggs in one basket.

It is a nice basket

but, like those who sleep walk into an Apple or Google ecosystem, it can be difficult to detach parts after something happens.

Diversifying before troubles, is a good idea…

2 Likes

Yea. It’s why I’m waiting to see what the fallout is and if they go thru with what the apology says they’ll do!

2 Likes

I don’t think they will oust Mr Yen.

I am not sure much of anything might happen to him

There’s always the slapping option, I have my rotten fish ready.

3 Likes

Agreed. It’s what I’m looking to do. Already got away from ms for the os ……. now need to split up my google dependency as much as I can……. still have an android phone thou!

1 Like

Out of curiosity, for those thinking of moving to another provider, what provider?

I’ve been moving everything into proton because they have third party audits and while their email client isnt the best, the degradation of gmail has made it easier for me to use. None of their apps are particularly good, but they’ve all been usable, except email search does missing things, which I’ve had more problems with google for.

Proton does seem to be slower, ie it takes longer from when you send an email to when someone receives it, and vice verrsa than gmail or outlook tho. Same with drive, but from the few times I’ve notices it, 10-30 seconds hasn’t been too bad

Edit - I guess mail is the big where can you even move that isnt worse?

1 Like

that just makes me think of python…

monty-python-fish-slapping

2 Likes

I don’t even really want Andy to resign. Not yet anyway, I’d prefer him to just change his strategy and not push AI. I’m not going to so easily throw someone under the bus who I largely agree with on such an important topic. They’ve built a great service and I’d say they’ve earned a chance to correct their mistake here.

And not everyone in the company feels the same way about this AI push. As a paying customer, you can voice your concerns and desired direction. In theory this supports the components of the company who want to prioritize safety over speed.

The elephant in the room here is saying… do we really believe that their competitors aren’t leveraging AI? Well, of course they are… so it comes down to who do we want to trust more to use it responsibly.

1 Like

I was presuming, he is more nerdy, with a desire to make a great product, but the productivity made him loose focus, from where I think, should be security and safety and privacy, above productivity and change.

1 Like

Totally yes… unless he escalates in the wrong direction, or we find out more that makes this worse, I see this as a simple mistake that can be fixed.

2 Likes

I have registered Proton mail and VPN and storage without giving them my email..

So was it a paid service you signed up for, and if so, they do need both contact information and payment method..

For fear of being called a drama queen of one of the virtue signalling adjacent terms, the AI side wasn’t as big an issue (it’s a tool) as Mr Yens comments to/about his staff and the email regarding interviewing people on their AI usage with the outcome possibly losing their jobs. I want and feel we need competitors to the Googles in this world but it’s a hard thing to swallow supporting similar attitudes to what they show.

If this was a one-off then you could see it as bad wording or a weird/ socially inept person being that but this is the 3rd of 4th controversy involving him. That’s edging towards a pattern IMHO. The shields up and hope it blows over doesn’t help either. A firm slap with a fish would definitely help but at the moment as I’m not deep into them I’m holding off to see what happens and checking out Astermail and Informaniak amongst others.

Really bugs my happiness that we can’t just have nice things, no strings attached in this timeline.

1 Like

I signed up for free proton mail. They requested a previous email address during signup.