2X64GB vs 4x48GB on X870E Proart Creator

Are your workloads even highly memory bandwidth dependent?

IN my experience, outside of gaming, and things like that, memory speed haven’t had a huge impact on the things I do.

All of that said, pay attention to if the larger memory modules you get are single or dual rank. You can think of a dual rank memory module is essentially two RAM sticks in one.

  • Two single rank modules = traditionally best performance (but it depends*)
  • Four single rank modules = traditionally worse performance (but it depends*)
  • Two dual rank modules = essentially the same thing as four single rank modules.

*If your system can maintain the same bandwidth settings, it really depends on workload, but it is not always entirely straightforward which workloads will be hurt (slightly) from multiple sticks per channel, and which can benefit (slightly) from multiple sticks per channel.

Benefits include that your address range for memory goes up to a full 64 bit per channel (from 32bit). Drawbacks involve needing to interleave between them, and limiting bandwidth on the channel. Some productivity loads like two sticks per channel better, some perform worse. Some games like two sticks per channel, some perform worse. You really have to benchmark your own workload.

Reducing clocks when multiple sticks are installed - as you have mentioned - has traditionally been an issue with multiple sticks per channel.

AMD specifies the the 9950x3d RAM capabilities as follows:
2x1R - DDR5-5600
2x2R - DDR5-5600
4x1R - DDR5-3600
4x2R - DDR5-3600

As with all things there is some room for tweaking here. It is notable that some people run even DDR5-8500 on their AM5 systems, and while it is not supported, it works.

Just because AMD says the max supported speed is DDR5-3600 with four single rank sticks, does not mean that setting them at their rated speeds won’t work, BUT it isn’t going to be guaranteed.

I have also read that non-binary* DDR5 RAM sizes (24, 48, 96, etc.) put more stress on the memory controller than traditional binary sizes (16,32, 64, etc.) so I would try to stick to the binary sizes if possible.

*(no pun intended, please don’t drag culture wars into this, I just can’t think of a better term for this right now)

Another thing to keep in mind is that AMD’s RAM is a little more complicated due to their chiplet design, with a separate IO die and the infinity fabric that ties it all together.

There are three different clocks that you should be keeping in mind:
- MCLK: This is the clock of the RAM itself. It is half the DDR5-xxxx figure (due to DDR). So a DDR5-6000 stick is 3000Mhz.
- UCLK This is the “uncore” clock. The memory controller will be running at this speed.
- FCLK This is the clock of the fabric that ties everything together, which can be another bottleneck.

AMD used to recommend running these three 1:1:1, at the same speed, but that changed with AM5. The recommendation is now to leave FCLK at “Auto” (which usually results in a clock of 2000-2100 Mhz depending on the motherboard, and how lucky you were with the silicon lottery on the CPU)

They then recommend that you get the best performance if you run UCLK and MCLK at 1:1 (the same clock)

There is no benefit from running UCLK faster than your MCLK, but if you can’t meet it 1:1, you generally have to drop it down to an even divider of 1:2, and then UCLK runs at half your RAM speed which has performance implications.

UCLK will usually hit 3000mhz stably on all AM5 CPU’s, which is why DDR5-6000 is the most popular RAM speed for AM5 CPU’s, as it hits that 1:1.

If you are lucky, on your CPU UCLK can be stable up to 3100Mhz, and then the best RAM to get is likely DDR5-6200, but the problem is there is no way of knowing without testing it.

All of that said, there can be performance benefits from running RAM faster than UCLK. For instance, a very fast clocked RAM stick can do operations (such as clears) that don’t use bandwith and instead rely on waiting for clocks to go by) faster. The problem is the fact that there is nothing between 1:1 and 1:2 on the UCLK to MCLK ratio.

So, the implication here is, if you go out and buy the highest clocked DDR5 RAM with EXPO there is right now (which if you are looking for EXPO profiles, which you should for RAM on AMD appears to be DDR5-8000), the following happens.

Your DDR5-8000 RAM will have an MCLK of 4000Mhz, but your UCLK won’t be able to hit 4000Mhz, so it will have to run at 1:2, which is 2000Mhz. This will bottleneck your memory bandwidth.

There are still some workloads (with many clear operations) that might benefit in a setting like this, but most workloads will benefit from higher UCLK bandwidth instead.

Now, if DDR5-12000 RAM were a thing, that would probably be amazing on an AM5 system (if you could get it to run) as you’d be able to sit at max guaranteed UCLK of 3000 Mhz, and have your MCLK at double that, and benefit from more clocks passing faster for things that involve waiting for clocks to pass.

Anyway, that is neither here nor there, as this RAM will likely never exist, and who knows if those clocks could even be supported if it did.

But that is the theory of it all.

Try to keep your CAS latency (and other sub timings) low
Try to keep your clocks high, but not too high so you get pushed into 1:2
Try to use single rank sticks if you can.
Try to use two sticks if you can rather than 4.
Try to avoid non-binary RAM size numbers. (24, 48, 96, etc.)

Here is what I would do in your situation:

I’d buy a kit that meets your needs (though I’d probably try to avoid the non-binary sizes) from a retailer with an excellent return policy (like Amazon) and test them.

I’d likely go for DDR5-6000, and try to get a lower CAS latency (I’ve seen them as low as CL24, but CL26 and CL28 are the most commonly available lower timing sticks. (The CAS Latencies of your two examples are really high! But maybe that is due to the limited availability of 64GB sticks…)

When considering latency, keep in mind it is specified on clock cycles, so - as an example - a DDR5-6000 stick with CL30 is going to be lower latency than a DDR5-5600 stick at CL30, because those 30 clocks go by faster at 6000 MT/s than at 5600 MT/s

For comparison purposes, Techpowerup has a decent calculator that can help understand the true latencies for each as measured in ns:

Pop them in, configure them to run at their rated speeds, and if it doesn’t work, return them and buy something else. It is very possible you can get four sticks to run at full rated speeds, but your chances are higher if you stick with two single channel sticks.

And this is where the “non-binary is harder on the memory controller” bit comes in. You can get away with running RAM outside of the specs AMD lists on their website, but if you use configurations that load the controller harder, this is less and less likely to work right.

I would test your ram with Passmarks Memtest If it passes a full run of this (which will take quite a while) you are pretty much guaranteed it is stable and works well.

But then it comes back to the whole “will you notice the difference” question.

If you were planning on playing games, especially if you were a competitive super high framerate type of player, I’d say yes, this will make a difference. For most productivity/workstation type of workloads RAM bandwidth makes much less of a difference.

There are exceptions though, especially when it come to some scientific and other highly compute intensive workloads that work with large datasets that fit in RAM.

I think if you were running benchmarks on your photo/video type of workloads, you’d notice a measurable performance improvement in your workloads from higher RAM speeds, but I highly doubt it will be a highly measurable difference to you in your day to day work.

Hope this helps.

Edit:

It looks like maybe I was a little bit too optimistic when it comes to the chances of achieving DDR5-6000 with four sticks, but you might find this thread interesting:

A few folks in there have gotten their four sticks stable at 5600. 4800 is also prevalent. I guess the takeaway here is “definitely higher than AMD’s speced 3600” but maybe not quite up there at 6000.

One guy is even running 4x64GB at 4800. (he used DDR5-6400 sticks that he underclocked in order to achieve this) He said 4800 is where he stopped testing, so he may even have been able to go higher.

3 Likes