Which RAM generation is best?

Never OCed DDR2, just encountered many board vendors that certified brands had changed their chip vendor at some point–some AMD Phenom boards wouldn’t boot using four sticks, some ASUS boards required memory using tighter timings(both AMD & Intel). On prefab there are makers that only prefer SK Hynix or Samsung sticks, ASUS(desktops/laptops) and Lenovo are famous for this during DDR3/DDR4–could be the same on DDR5.

I love that this question is deeper than “what should I put in my build?”.

DDR4 gets my vote because of a recent upgrade cycle I did. I pulled some sticks out of a 6th Gen Intel NUC to do an upgrade, and on a whim, decided to see if the SODIMMs in a Ryzen 5000 series laptop were compatible.

Swapped around, booted, and it Just Worked™.

I credit DDR4 directly with machines having a meaningful working life of over a decade. Old machines benefit so much from having massive, inexpensive RAM being so ubiquitous.

1 Like

Questions like these really show that we as people being so similar yet have such different ideas and opinions.

I enjoy reading everything that has been said about ran sticks because it’s so interesting why one person thinks one is better then the other.

Puts things into perspective!

I’d say DDR5… but I’d also confess I’m heavily biased given my good fortune with DDR5, bad luck with DDR3, and having skipped DDR4 entirely. Sorry in advance for the verbosity!

Been adding memory to systems since the SDRAM days. DDR was incredibly simple to use, as others have already said it was just a five timings to change and it either worked stable or didn’t boot. Even not knowing much of anything I could tweak those on my Abit IS7 board to optimize it and achieve a level of pride and accomplishment that no loot box could aspire to attain.

DDR2 was okay, but I remember it wasn’t atypical that 800Mhz and higher modules could become unstable because they would run so hot, especially if all four slots were populated. DDR2 really popularized all those memory cooling peripherals and even spawned those watercooled blocks for RAM, which I think speaks for itself. Didn’t like having to keep a fan on DDR2 kits just to ensure stability, especially given those new quadcore CPUs like the Q6600 were running hotter than ever already.

DDR3 was good up to 1600… after that it just became a nightmare. Nothing above 1600 wanted to work on my Haswell rigs. Could never leave well enough alone and eventually got 1800 stable but the effort involved wasn’t worth the performance gains, especially given it was a kit rated for 2400. Didn’t help some kits never worked at all on any XMP profile. I bought one 32GB kit of low profile 1600 memory, but it turns out it was defective from manufacturing with a failing chip that didn’t rear its ugly head until many years later. For years it could pass memtest and yet it had been behind countless odd and edge-case issues I’d experienced up until then, culminating in WHEA hardware corrected errors that grew more and more prolific. Eventually those became “uncorrectable errors” with BSoDs at which point I was finally able to narrow it down to the specific module triggering them.

Skipped DDR4 entirely.

I was excited for DDR5 because it standardized 16GB per module as the baseline and the voltage continued to decrease. The frequency gains are already eclipsing DDR4, which keep in mind is still happening on first-generation DDR5 IMCs. Intel’s first generation DDR4 IMC was only rated at 1866/2133 and not good past 2400 for the average chip if I recall.

Learning about SK Hynix, Samsung, and Micron die on DDR5 has been fun, but I still am incredulous the timings & subtimings and frequencies SK Hynix die will do with minimal voltages, while Micron and Samsung chips aren’t even playing in the same ballpark.

Going from problematic Haswell straight to AM5 I was extremely happy that the Microcenter bundled 6000CL30 memory just worked with no stability problems. Later figured out it was Hynix A-die at which point having watched some of Buildzoid’s early videos on Hynix DDR5 tuning I instantly began turning knobs and messing with settings I’d never even touched before. It has been especially satisfying decreasing so many subtimings by substantial percentages using pure stock volts and no compromise to stability. It’ll even run 6200 at stock volts synced 1:1 with the UCLK for 10 minutes before it reboots, so the inevitable next time I get another itch I might tweak a couple voltages to see if that can be made stable.

No memory I’ve ever had holds a candle to DDR5 SK Hynix memory, and it’s freaky that this stuff doesn’t cost a super premium. In any other past generation it would’ve been the most expensive kit on the block for what it can do.

I was an early adopter of X99 and DDR4 in 2014. 2666MHz worked on the first boot with that machine, and ran that way with tuned timings below the profile defaults until about 10 months ago when the launch-day i7-5820K finally started having IMC issues. I had given that machine to a family member after about a year of owning it, and the overclocked settings worked for 9 years. That said, I was ambitious early on and tried to run 3000MT/s, which instantly failed by the way that Haswell-E handles async DRAM:BCLK clocking forcing the BCLK over 115MHz.

That’s surprising, and incredibly unlucky. I’m consistently pulling DRAM kits out of recycling lots and even on Z68/Sandy Bridge platforms, if they are 2133MT/s or lower 1Rx8 DIMMs they just work. 2000MT/s CL10 on X48 in 2008 was basically a guarantee with Micron DIMMs of the era, by Haswell everything just works in my experience. Broadwell-DT is the only caveat I can think of, the i7-5775C has a very fickle IMC where training 2Rx8 DIMMs above 2133MT/s will usually fail on the first go, but will work after training at a lower speed then rebooting and trying the higher speed. Once it’s booted though it’ll handle 2600+ with little complaint. Skylake with DDR3 gets complicated because the IMC physically cannot handle above 1.5v, so you have to rely on very late manufacture 1.35/1.5v DIMMs to avoid damaging the IMC.

This Haswell with 2Rx8/2DPC 2400 CL10 is still the most painless DDR3 setup I’ve ever used.

Too bad you didn’t have much luck with DDR3 ram. Being able to take mine from 2133-almost 2500 was crazy and with super tight primary. In my thread of asking if people still have bulldozer/piledriver thread I will be posting my results which I think you might find interesting.

However everyone has different experiences and should have there opinion respected. It will be interesting times once DDR5 stays in the oven for a bit.

I recently built a 3770k with 2x8GB-2133 and it ran the XMP without a problem.

Ah, I forgot entirely about X99. I was thinking the 6700K was the first-gen DDR4 stuff. That’s pretty good results for Intel’s HEDT platform!

Dunno, could’ve been the combination of RAM & memory brands. It’s also possible I could’ve missed something obvious myself since all the Haswell rigs I was working on were the same Z97 ASUS board. I had replaced my Z87 Gigabyte board because it was exhibiting instability and random problems at stock… but it turns out that was because it was using what would turn out to be the defective 1600MT/s kit. So I actually can’t blame the board for that. if I’d stuck with the Z87 Gigabyte board longer maybe I would’ve figured out it was a bum RAM module a few years sooner, heh.

I’d dive into the DDR3 settings I tried but my memory isn’t good enough for it and those rigs were parted out on ebay (I can’t believe decade old Haswell CPUs & motherboards go for that much, seriously). I should’ve mentioned some of the memory straps that did allow higher RAM frequencies also hurt performance so I didn’t use those, same reason I’m not breaking the 1:1 ratio on Zen 4 even though the memory is good for it.

Either way, it worked out in the end. I really did not expect anything from a “free” bundle kit of DDR5 RAM from Microcenter, and instead it’s been the best kit of memory I’ve ever owned. Given the crazy frequencies Hynix can clock to if I drop Zen 5 (or if we are all lucky, Zen 6) into the system five years from now I bet the SK Hynix chips will be able to clock up to match it without a problem. But the flipside is also true, if SK Hynix makes DDR5 chips this good today then what they will be making five years from now will probably be some truly amazing stuff.

Let me guess. Was that micron?

Hah, you nailed it.

Was a Crucial 1600 32GB (4x8GB) kit of “low voltage” & low profile DDR3. Sounded absolutely perfect and so was the price… little did I know. Once the hardware instability became detectable one of the things I did was change the XMP to the second profile that used normal voltages, and that seemed to work for awhile so I assumed that was the problem and forgot about it. But it only delayed the inevitable.

Yeah, the faulty DDR3 I experienced are all microns. Also the micron DDR3 kit I had was so bad that I have to half the REFI from JEDEC to prevent it erroring during hammer test.

Vaguely remember some kerfuffle about DDR3 Micron chips, which of course I’ve forgotten now. Didn’t pay attention to memory die in the DDR4 generation since I was never in the market, but… Micron die are the least capable chips in the DDR5 space.

I mentioned elsewhere a friend of mine couldn’t get his Corsair 5600 64GB kit stable on his MSI board so I’ve been helping him with it. Of course it was Micron die in it, but I assumed anyway given the speed bin. I think we finally got it stable, he’s just doing long term verification testing now on it. It definitely required extra voltages to function at 5600, which is ironic because it ran perfectly happy at 5200 using 1.1v. It’s supposed to be rated 5600 1.25v.

DDR4 micron rev e is a beast. It can do 5000 cl18
In contrast, micron ddr5 is just a joke. Even slower than its ddr4.

absolutlely love ddr3, my old i7 4790 and 24gb of ddr3 system was the most stable system I’ve ever had. the only time I’ve ever gotten close to that was with an hp z620 workstation with a quadro and all ecc ram.

Right before they released the new 7000 series AM5 AMD CPU’s I bought an ASUS board that handles 5000 series AM4 motherboard because it had 8 memory slots (most still only have 4, even on AM5 motherboards).

The other reason for chosing that board was because it could take Unregistered ECC DIMMs (and the top NVME slot was not under the GPU / top x16 slot).

So I currently have a 128G RAM with a 5700G that I assign 16G to the APU graphics

what…where…häää?

That would be nuts if it existed. 4 DIMMs per channel on an IMC that only supports 2DPC. ASUS would have to do some incredible engineering work to make that a reality. Would have made headlines.

Corsair timing issues are common, their kits often listed on certified documents and they get boot failures on Intel NUCs(now ASUS NUC). For a very long time NewEgg had frequently done bundle “offers” pairing NUCs/ITX boards to Corsair memory, once seen a review mention avoid the memory bundles.

… Wasn’t Crucial still using SKHynix in the DDR3 days?
I had Crucial dimms that did quite well in 1866 9-9-9-24 at 1.35v. Could get them up to 2133 at 1.5v, but timings had to be a bit looser, so games were faster at the lower speed. Pretty sure they were Hynix, and Crucial was pretty tightly tied to Hynix for memory.
Elpida was well behind though. I remember 1060 launch, you could basically overclock your memory to 9GT/s unless you ended up with Elpida, which was mostly for the B-tier brands.

Crucial is Micron’s consumer brand. Crucial has never been anything other than Micron.